From the UKAuthors Collection
Kat's Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
By e-griff · Originally published 8 October 2007
A poem on theme of happiness or a happy moment
I heard a woman on a radio programme. Her story inspired this poem.
Heart
When your child dies,
the woman said,
you feel: it should be me
You cannot smile
Or be at peace
And one day
you climb a mountain in fresh air,
slowly plodding
under grey clouds
mind a-swirl, thinking of her
at every idle moment
Then clouds split open
sun shines through
upon your face
and in your mind
the clouds part too
and happiness, at last, touches your heart again
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
Happiness might touch your mouth to make it smile, it might touch your skin to make it tingle... but, if I lost a child, I'm not sure it'd ever touch my heart again :-(
Aww, it's kind of a happy-sad poem. Usually, my fave kind. But I'm so sensitive it's more sad than happy to me. Maybe cos of a cousin dying several years ago and seeing how my aunt's been ever since (his mum).
God, I wish I wasn't so doom-and-gloomy and didn't dwell on the sad side of this poem, cos I do think it has some nice touches and is meant to be a positive poem, not a negative one.
All the best,
Hazy x
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
Yes, you can't have happiness without sadness. I think that's come out in several of the poems. The strength of this poem is the very thing that stops it working for Hazy, ie the depth of the sadness that must have been there. Hard to think of anything sadder than the death of a child, but the clouds splitting open and the sunshine on the narrator's face create an epiphany that is well handled in this poem. I enjoyed the simplicity of the writing.
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
Happiness and sadness are at opposite ends but sometimes can go hand in hand. It is only when one is able to overcome grief that happiness can be more rewarding.
A well written poem, John, with a deep meaning.
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
Very thoughtful poem. It's funny, but I have been thinking along this theme a lot lately, that's why this really reached me.
Romany.
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
John, this is exactly the kind of thing I hoped someone would pen - I love it - and delph's comment captures why. I had an older poem which tried to put across an epiphany I had once, but it's just not up to muster. Your poem is a blinder!
Kat x
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
Hi John,
A lovely poem, which says so very much of how grief effects people and how they cope...the sun does eventually shine.
I can relate to this so much, you wouldn't believe. It spoke in volumes...the clouds do part eventually. Each stanza is different but has a uniqueness to the message that is given.
Sugar. xx
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
i agree (a lot) with Hazy. plus, it's almost an anti-poem mainly because of the story.
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
okay, i will tell you exactly what I don't like and don't accept in this poem at all (and that's why i said it's an anti-poem)
at last.
at last is very cruel and very insensitive in my opinion. or very unrealistic. or shallow in an insensitive and unrealistic way.
i'm sure it's not what you want to say, i have no idea why this woman said it, but you don't have to, so i think you must write one more stanza and drop 'at last'
Then clouds split open
sun shines through
upon your face
and in your mind
the clouds part too.
I don't know what
but something must
have warmed your heart again.
They do say life is sweet,
time is a healer
and hope accepts the universe
the same as despair.
something like that.
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
He who has never hoped can never despair.
Caesar and Cleopatra
George Bernard Shaw
(he who has never despaired can never hope)
you can accept the universe out of despair (when there is nothing you can do then extreme pain and sadness might make you accept the universe).
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
:-)
a) the end of a seemingly permanent sorrow is not "happiness at last" JUST LIKE the end of a seemingly permanent happiness is not "misery".
b) read this poem:
HAPPINESS
Don't flatter yourself,
It's just the open window,
A bird singing,
The bright sunlight.
The hundred-year-old woman in a dream
Closed the door ever so softly,
And still you woke with a start
To the trees full of leaves
Not a single one of which was moving.
There was a dead child in her arms.
Over her shoulder a city on fire
As if after an air raid.
A whiff of putrefaction reached your nostrils
In this enchanted place,
With its blue sky,
Trees like a mystery religion,
A lost ant going the wrong way, perhaps,
Under your black shoe?
Charles Simic.
:-)
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
A lovely poem and has a real ring of truth to it, in my opinion. Explained no doubt by the fact that it is based on a true story, but it's also in the way you convey it. Incidentally, I see nothing wrong with 'at last'; I bet it was a very long time before even a tinge of happiness appeared on her horizon.
I'm tempted to comment on the suggested substitute last verse above but, having been reading the thread on the forums about commenting on comments, I will refrain. But I like yours.
Daff
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
Of course I don't mind, feel free to comment on my comment Daff.
Egriff is it happiness that touched this woman's heart?
I answered. Don't flatter yourselves.
And I said: the end of a seemingly permanent sorrow is not "happiness at last" JUST LIKE the end of a seemingly permanent happiness is not "misery".
And the poem by Simic is another way to make you understand what I mean.
My alternative last stanza-suggestion was written hastily.
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
This is a great poem. Full of hope! We need hope and inspiration. This offers both.
Jay.
Kats Poetry Workshop Challenge : Heart
A moment we can all relate to at some point in life,the lifting of the heart after a bereavement when you think you can never be happy again. Time is a great healer a they say and life does move on. You captured the moment well . Val