From the UKAuthors Collection
Like music, pain
By shadow · Originally published 3 September 2007
Prompted by a sharp attack of sciatica
It begins
not with the scarlet blare
of trumpets, but a stirring
in the silence, a mosquito
whining on the violin
or grumbling ostinato in the bass.
Nerves stretch, tuning up.
A low note swells
throbbing on the cello till
the theme emerges, rising
in pitch, to coalesce
into the melody, which builds
to a crescendo, agony as art.
Slowly the climax passes, as
the orchestra obeys
the will of its conductor
diminuendo fading into
silence. Only the faint
shrilling of a solo flute
hints at another movement.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Like music, pain
What a clever way to portray such pain. Very well done...I'm sorry for your pain, but at least you have a beautiful piece of work to show for it.
blessings,
Jolen
Like music, pain
oh it's good, would it work better perhaps if it was a three-strophe poem?
It begins
not with the scarlet blare
of trumpets, but a stirring
in the silence, a mosquito
whining on the violin
or grumbling ostinato in the bass.
Nerves stretch, tuning up.
A low note swells
throbbing on the ‘cello till
etc...
and could it perhaps be an interesting edit for you (i'm about to change the first strophe of the poem i hope you don't mind)
It begins with a mosquito
whining on the violin,
not with scarlet blare
of trumpets, but a stirring
in the silence, or grumbling
ostinato in the bass.
I hope i read it correctly. I liked it shadow, cheers
Like music, pain
oh, I just read your short description and your reply to the previous comment! :( neuralgia of the sciatic nerve, my parents suffer from it. i'm so sorry.
Like music, pain
How incredibly original - using the language of music, normally a wholly pleasurable medium, to describe pain. Oddly, it works very well - memorable stuff indeed. Oh, and I hope it doesn't return, by the way. The pain, obviously...
Like music, pain
It is said that an artist has to suffer in order to produce outstanding work and you have proved it with this.
Excellent piece and I especially like the last stanza.
Luigi x
Like music, pain
nice. good analogy
i don't think you need 'cello (as from violincello) as cello is now a word in its own right in the oxford dic. :-)
Like music, pain
I'm so sorry, Moya...and it's good to know you're over it now...please take care...
Very good poem, btw...amazing comparison. Hope your next inspiration is more pleasant!!!
Regds,
niece
Like music, pain
Well you did get a very good poem out of your suffering!
Clever analogy - now I'll always think of pain in terms of music.
How then would you describe childbirth in music and musical instruments do you think?
Jemx
Like music, pain
jeffykins playing the bagpipes?
Like music, pain
This is excellent - very cleverly constructed and satisfying for the reader and you have my sympathies - 'agony as art' - ouch! Great expression though.
There's a full stop missing at the end of the poem (please excuse my beady eyes), but I loved that ending:
'Only the faint
shrilling of a solo flute
hints at another movement'
Kat x
Like music, pain
Very impressive, S. Reads so beautifully and nothing niggles. Lovely clever ending. cheers, Albert :)
Like music, pain
Hello Ms. Shadow. What a beautiful case of Sciatica you seem to have had. A very well written piece in my ickul opinion and no mistake.
Rate: My little Pony
s
u
n
k
e
n
loosely based on a cardigan
Like music, pain
Yes. it was a beaut. Still, no gain without pain, eh? Thanks Sunk.
Like music, pain
Overall, a very effective poem, but there are a few odds and ends (mostly to do with the musical stuff) that don't quite work.
You can't really build to a crescendo, as the crescendo is the build up itself, not the final destination.
Diminuendo is a fading process, so to say 'diminuendo fading' is a tautology.
Favourite phrase: "a mosquito whining on the violin". That's brilliant.
Like music, pain
Imagine an attack of Sciatica producing such lovely poetry!
The suffering is really unbearable!
What I want to ask you is, did it give you some relief in pain, because it (poetry) does distract you from immediate surroundings?
((Hugs to ease the pain))
Love, Zoya
Like music, pain
Quite brilliant! I have suffered with sciatica since I was preganant with my daughter and it's agony - just as you describe. Great stuff!
Jennifer x