From the UKAuthors Collection

this was deleted :-)

By e-griff · Originally published 27 August 2007

This has been moved Click Here

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Rupe

Salad Days with the Hula Girls and the Binki Boys

Hmm, hard to say anything constructive until we get to the end. It read smoothly enough, though it slightly lacks a central hook to drag the reader forward - we follow easily enough what's happening, but it's not altogether clear why it's happening. Obviously there's an element of suspense-building, but throw us some crumbs...

Black marks for 'Captain Haddock'...

Rupe

bluepootle

Salad Days with the Hula Girls and the Binki Boys

It seems to be lacking something in the hook department, I think, because I'm not finding a keen urge to read on, but it's difficult to comment more until I've seen the rest.

I don't know what 'The air was seamless with wonder.' means. Is that just me?

I'll come back to it when you've got the second part up.

delph_ambi

Salad Days with the Hula Girls and the Binki Boys

Not just you - I was going to ask about 'The air was seamless with wonder' too. It's a tad meaningless, and therefore not a great opening.

I needed more of a sense of time and place from this piece. At this stage, I don't know if it's a contemporary South Sea Island, or a piece of sci-fi. I don't think you should leave your readers floundering quite so much.

I'm left thinking, 'So what?' This reads fluently enough, but none of the characters has much of a personality. Harku has the beginnings of one, but the women and the boys have none at all. I think you need to do something early on to make your reader care about what's going to happen to Mala when she opens the door.

e-griff

Salad Days with the Hula Girls and the Binki Boys

thankyou delph and blue....

we shall see :-)

JeffDray

Salad Days with the Hula Girls and the Binki Boys

Well so much for the word count.

An intriguing start, I shall wait for the conclusion before rating.

len

Salad Days with the Hula Girls and the Binki Boys

I think it has enough of a hook. I was very curious as to what was behind the door. The theme of what is behind the forbidden door is the mainstay of many mysteries. Must be the fear and curiosity we have about the forbidden doors of our minds...len

Kat

Salad Days with the Hula Girls and the Binki Boys

Hi griffy

I read through this easily enough - intrigued by the title - and I liked the way you broke down the action which I thought helped with suspense, but would have liked to read it all together in one part.

I thought you had some nice phrases:

''kerfuffle from the parrots'

'a long tongue of mud that licked down the hillside.'

I wasn't keen on the generalisation/Boy's Own (is that something? lol) of 'boys' and 'girls' and the lack of description/personality of the characters in general - it made the names a little muddied! ;o)

You overuse the word 'mud' a bit too, and ? typo:

'assuming the door would muffle and noise from the parrots.'

Also the reference to heels kicking up dust from the path - would this be so after the rains and mudslide?

I did enjoy this - the apparent mystery of it! And I'll look out for the next part.

Kat :o)

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…