From the UKAuthors Collection
Sonnet 24
By Elfstone · Originally published 24 August 2007
This is my reworking of last week's collaborative Challenge/Workshop poem.
I loved Romany's opening line and felt that it was crying out for 'sonnet treatment'. I'm aware that I have wandered away from the original a bit but, hey ho! my muse has always been a bit wayward.
As always your opinions will be most welcome.
Sonnet 24
The clock keeps more than time, counts more than hours;
Routine is glumly stressed with each dull note.
Each tick precedes the tock that it empowers
To hasten on our lives' soon-ended rote.
Uncertainty and fate click in alliance
To tangle us within the Norns' coarse rope.
The pendulum allows us no defiance;
No halting of the swing, to give us hope
Of slowing down Eternity. To cower
hoping pointless hope in choiceless places
our lot. Our best, a realisation sour,
The paradox of movement breeding stasis.
Perceiving in that moment (a glimpse divine?):
Between the tick and tock, there’s all of Time.
© Elfstone 19/8/07
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Sonnet 24
I liked this more traditional treatment, although i had to google 'norn' ! Exceptionally though, I found the pointless/choiceless line a wee bit difficult.
Nice one. JOhnG
Sonnet 24
Yes, I thought of giving it the 'sonnet treatment' too, but changed my mind. Couldn't decide about the rhythm. I think it's given you problems here. First quattrain works beautifully, but then it starts to falter, and a few lines are too far from iambic pentameter for the flow to work, in my view.
Some nice corners though. I like 'the Norn's coarse rope' and repetitions like 'hoping pointless hope'
Sonnet 24
this is an extremely interesting line
The paradox of movement breeding stasis.
and the ending is also very good.
Sonnet 24
Another great effort for the challenge, Elf. I think you've done very well with the sonnet form, though this line, 'hoping pointless hope in choiceless places' trips up a little, I felt, though I love the rhyme, 'places' with 'stasis.' Your last couplet is particularly strong.
Kat :o)
Sonnet 24
Excellent Elf. You certainly know your mythology unlike some of us who had to rush to the dictionary to look up Norn.
'The paradox of movement breeding stasis' is a brilliant line.
A very good effort.
Sonnet 24
A top sonnet. Particularly like the enjambement that makes 'our lot' begin a line. That's very clever, and emphasises the bleakness very well.
The only line I don't like is 13. Not only is it metrically clumsy (is there not a monosyllabic equivalent of 'moment'...?) it also has inverted Shakespeareanesque syntax: 'a glimpse divine'... Ooohhhhhh.
All life is movement breeding stasis, isn't it? Alas, alas...
Mac
Sonnet 24
I wouldn't know a sonnet if I caught one in the lake but this seems very well done. Not sure about the line ending 'our lot' - seems to be missing something - but enjoyed 'paradox of movement breeding stasis'.
Sonnet 24
Hi Elf,
To elaborate on my comment about meter (as requested): line five has too many syllables (presumably you want 'alliance' to have just two, but I can only read it as three).
Same problem with 'defiance' in line seven.
Line nine, similar problem; I can't read 'cower' as one syllable, or it comes out as 'car'.
Line ten has the correct syllable count, but most of the stresses are in the wrong place. You don't have one iamb in that line, as far as I can see, which would be fine if you'd mixed up a few of the other lines, but you haven't, so it jarred for me.
Line eleven has twelve syllables the way I read it. (our, lot, Our, best, a, re, a, li, sa, tion, so, ur,) Okay, you can merge some of them, but it requires careful study to work out how to do it effectively, and I don't want to have to sit for ages over one line working out how to read it to make it fit the expected rhythm.
Line twelve definitely has an extra syllable, as does line thirteen.
Trouble is, if you fix all those problems you'll have a sonnet that is rhythmically boring. It's very hard to get the balance between boringly correct and inspirationally offbeat just right. I write hundreds of these things, and I haven't cracked it yet.
Cheers,
Delph
Sonnet 24
Just to confuse you (maybe), but in some ways to support your original approach:
I don't agree with delph on defiance and alliance or cower - Read them aloud - they work fine. In theory she is correct, but often metre is about compressing or expanding into an established rythm - you do that here (establish it at the start) - Also syllables are of different lengths in English (which accounts for the complexity of 'rules' ). The odd unstressed syllable at the end of a line is eminently absorbable. Use your ear (which you have - which is why 'cower' rhymes with 'sour' - fine by me).
However, I absolutely agree with delph on line 10 (as I indicated above) it's just lost the plot, and it's hard for me to hear what you heard when you wrote it (which can often be done) - and 'our lot'? the whole construction of that sentence is also grammatically quite wierd. (and the line (10) not iambic in any way as delph says)
The rhythm is established strongly for me from the start, so 'reel I sa shon' is no stretch in 11, neither are the extra unstressed syllables in lines 12 and 14 - (and if you do one, they have to rhyme , so places/ stasis is fine - they do)
Line 13 is incorrect, I agree. But simply removing 'a' fixes it, IMO .
If poets read their work aloud, many anomalies that would result from the written work are avoided - the author dictates the way it is heard. However, I've noted that the 'greats' don't have such anomalies in their work (at least I haven't found them). But what they do do (as I've indicated here) is to set up rhythm, not have any inexplicable surprises (only planned ones) so they steer their reader smoothly through the printed page by predisposing them using accepted forms.
Greek and Latin (and modern Spanish) have equal length syllables, so it's easy - just count them and you're away. English is a problem. Google Wiki for 'accentual verse' and 'accentual-syllabic' verse and you will discover a lot about how modern english verse has developed and why if you don't know it already.
But always remember - this theory is analysis. If you have an 'ear' it will tell you how to write. Here, your ear did well, IMO. It's for you to explain to yourself what happened with line 10 and 13 (at least in my opinion) . :-)
very best, JohnG (and hope I haven't really confused the issue).
Sonnet 24
I'm going to put this as a separate comment as I am addressing both delp and griff. The first thing I want to say is a huge thankyou to both of you for the time and consideration you have obviously given this poem. I found both of your detailed responses fascinating and informative.
In all honesty I hadn't given the syllable count a second thought, in fact I hadn't given it a first thought either! That's just not the way I 'do' rhythm; the count doesn't matter if the rhythm of the words works. That the rhythm works (in a 6/4 time signature) I am certain of. I take the point that delph seems to be making though about the number of syllables being significant. If there is a set number of syllables required in each line (this: http://writing.upenn.edu/~afilreis/88/sonnet.html doesn't mention that) then I can see there is a problem.The way round that of course is not to call this a Sonnet.
What I will do is record myself saying this and post it - not something I've ever done here, but it might be interesting. Perhaps that will also answer your concerns griff. I will have to wait until at least tomorrow so that my voice has recovered from being at Murrayfield yesterday! ;-) (we lost! :-((( )
Sonnet 24
You are right, it's not just about counting syllables. If it sounds right, it IS right. But note what I said about others reading it off the page, rather than hearing an audio where you undoubtedly 'nudge' it your way of 'hearing'. Not everybody read/'hears' the same way. (that's the 'anomaly' bit) That's what you have to consider, just as a prose author has to think how others might read a sentence - that's the value of critique and editing. :-)
Sonnet 24
Between the tick and tock there's all of time is a GREAT line. The passage of time is an illusion which suits out perceptions. It has always been and shall always be now...I really liked this write..
PS..I tried to use that link you gave me and got,"This module is not active", whatever THAT means. If you would kindly give me the name of your write, I'd appreciate it...len
Sonnet 24
A wonderful sonnet - quite Shakesperian in outlook but with several original touches as people have said. Some very interesting comments and responses too. It is a pity sometimes that the format of this site does not encourage a multi-person thread to develop (except on the forums) and allow interesting discussions to bloom like the one here about sonnet format. It is very pleasant to see someone posting a so-called sonnet and upon reading it to find that it actually is a sonnet!
Would you allow me to post your piece with my technical comments on a forum and start a discussion - I would also pm the other contributors to he discussion and ask them to add their original comments and join in.
One nit-pick really - but should not " Norn's " really be " Norns' "?
I will join in the discussion latter anyway if you you would rather I just commented.
Warm Wishes
David