From the UKAuthors Collection
Triolet
By Yutka · Originally published 13 August 2007
My heart has locked its door shut closed
as firmly as it could.
There is no entering for those
my heart has locked its door shut closed.
I threw away the key that shows
You will be there for good.
My heart has locked its door shut closed
as firmly as it could.
.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Triolet
I wrote a triolet a while ago, and at the time said I'd found the form very constrictive.
This one has meaning that works well in the form. My only doubt is whether the phrase 'door shut close' is a little contrived - it doesn't have a clear meaning for me, and I found a confusion between 'close' (adj) and 'close' (verb) especially as the 'wrong' meaning (verb) is the one that rhymes most directly with 'those' ...
best, JohnG
Triolet
Dear Ms. Yutka, you will never be trying. I don't even know what a triolet is. To be frank, I thought they were some kind of sanitary device for ovulating triplets. This comment has now gone critical and I would advise that you step away from the computer. Well done Yutka. Good to have you back and no mistake.
For one week only, I am using a system of grading that was made popular by Cheryl Baker of Bucks Fizz fame. Thanks.
Rate: Tumble Dryer (with eco setting)
s
u
n
k
e
n
treading water in doc martens
Triolet
It's a very, very tricky form. 'Closed' certainly works better than 'close', but it's still not all working. Third and fourth lines, "There is no entering for those / my heart has locked its door shut closed." doesn't make grammatical sense, and it needs to for the form to work.
These are great fun to write, but infuriating at the same time.
Triolet
I am not familiar with very many forms, but I thought the poem worked well for the reader. I salute you for even attempting it, as I don't have the courage to.
blessings,
Jolen
Triolet
Ah yes, the triolet, always good for adamant or obsessive subjects. I always try to pronounce triolet in as un-French a way as I can, so that it rhymes with violet. Tree-oh-lay indeed. French is so limp. Give me a muscular tongue like German any day.
Are you German? Or do you speak it? It strikes me that English is not your Muttersprache, because of the refrain "My heart has locked its door shut closed". That clangs on my Anglophone ear. You see, you say 'locked', 'shut' and 'closed' all in the same line, which is a bit much. 'Shut closed' is a tautology. How about 'tight closed' or 'fast closed' or something like that instead? Only, an English-speaker wouldn't really say "My heart has locked its door shut closed".
Also, yes, Delph is right, lines 3 and 4 don't make grammatical sense. It is a tricky form, and other than that, you do a good job of it.
Alles Gute,
Mac the Sausage