From the UKAuthors Collection
About Me
By sirat · Originally published 1 June 2007
This is my offering in the current challenge in the Prose Workshop: A story on the theme of returning to a place that was significant in your life.
'Dear Danny', I read for the hundredth time, maybe the thousandth for all I know, 'I haven't been in touch with you for a very long time, and it's been playing on my conscience that I should write to you.'
Why did Shelagh say that it had been playing on her conscience? Wasn't I the one who was supposed to get in touch? Supposed to make the phone call? She didn't even mention it. As if I'd behaved perfectly decently. Did she do that deliberately? Did she know it would make me feel even worse? No, I can't believe that of her.
I fold it up and put it away again in the pocket of the laptop case on my knee. There are only a few people on the bus and they glance at me every now and again. I must look like a boring old man, grey-haired, fairly well dressed, a bit self-obsessed with my little bits of paper and my laptop. I always feel a kind of compulsion to explain myself to people who don't know me, to make some kind of contact, justify myself. Maybe that's why I try to be a writer. Maybe deep down, it's all about me.
This road is incredibly good. Almost straight dual carriageway, smooth as silk, well-tended fields of wheat, barley and oilseed rape by the sides, the occasional big detached farmhouse with at least one or two four-wheel-drive monsters parked outside. On the horizon, colours faded by the miles, Ben Bulbin's great flat-topped mass presides over it all. This road was once narrow and twisting, with trees overhanging and little clearings by the side where we used to go and pick blackberries and hazelnuts and conkers in season. There were foxes and rabbits and water-voles and... It strikes me suddenly that these could be my father's thoughts. I'm getting just like him, full of nostalgia for the past.
It starts to rain again, and as we pull into the town square it has become a real County Donegal deluge. At least that hasn't changed.
I'm the only one getting out at this stop. They all watch me now, as I pull the plastic hood up over my head and wait for the driver to fetch my holdall from the luggage compartment. It isn't until after the bus pulls away that I get a chance to look around.
It doesn't look all that different. Much smaller than I remember it, a few more businesses boarded-up, the ticket office of the old bus station turned into a fried chicken restaurant that's a down-market copy of one of the big American names. It's the nearest place to get out of the rain so I take up my bag and hurry over.
Inside, I sit at one of the bar stools along the main counter and lower the holdall on to the floor with the laptop case on top. There are just three other customers, all women, all old, all seemingly on their own and surrounded by plastic shopping bags. The name printed on the bags tells me that one of the big supermarket chains has a branch nearby. The whole scene is drab, ordinary. I find myself wondering why on earth I've come back, what I could possibly expect to find here. A mood of depression rises up from somewhere near my stomach.
I wipe the moisture off my face with the back of my hand and smile at the rather overweight middle-aged waitress who is limping towards me from the serving hatch. She doesn't return the smile. There is an ancient scar along her left cheek – deep, disfiguring. I ask her for a large coffee and anything that isn't fried. She says she can do me a chicken salad, to which I agree.
A stupid idea to come back. Nobody will be left from all those years ago. What on earth am I doing here?
At least the coffee is hot. I look around at my three companions. It doesn't feel appropriate to start a conversation. Instead I speak to the glum waitress when she comes back with the salad. 'Could you tell me, please, is there a taxi service in the town?'
'Minicabs? Yeah, we got minicabs.'
She turns to go. 'Where? I mean, how do I get hold of one?'
'Payphone over there. There's a card on the wall.'
In two trips I carry my things over to a table from which I can read the cards on the crude cork notice-board. Barry Dynan Ltd., it says, in big red letters, Cars for all occasions. There is a phone number below it. I punch the numbers into my mobile and press 'send'.
ooOoo
I have to raise my voice over the battering of the rain on the windshield and the hiss of the tires on the wet road. 'So you're actually Barry Dynan,' I say, trying to make conversation as we drive, 'the owner of the company.'
'I am the company.'
'Not very busy then?'
He shrugs. 'We get a few tourists in the summer. Come for the fishing, mostly. This time of year, maybe the occasional guy who's had too much to drink and can't drive home. That's about it.'
'So... I suppose you must do something else, as well...'
'I do lots of things, same as most folk around here.' He becomes silent.
'I lived here once,' I tell him, trying to rekindle the conversation.
'Did you? I would have said you were English. Most young people don't stay here very long. Not a lot to keep them.' Silence again.
'My father had the local chemist shop. The family name was Dorian.'
'Yes. I remember the Dorians. Don't know where they went. What happened to them.'
I wasn't sure he wanted to know but I thought I would tell him anyway. 'They moved down to a retirement home in County Cork in the 1980s. I'd left by then of course. My father died in 1995. Mother is still alive.' He nods in bored acknowledgement. I gather the courage to ask what is really on my mind. 'Do you remember a family by the name of Hannigan? The father worked on the hydro-electric scheme at Cathaleen's Falls.'
'No, I think you've got me there. That would have been a bit before my time.' I suspect he is pretending to be younger than he really is but I let it pass.
'They lived on Corn Bray. Near the top. Do you think we could go by there on our way to Mrs Sweeney's?'
'No problem at all. I'll stop there for a few minutes if you want to take a look around.' I can see the reason for his being so accommodating. Since he picked me up from the cafe he has been fingering a packet of cigarettes in his top pocket.
The rain has abated by the time we reach the top end of Corn Bray. Shelagh's house seems very small. Just a two-bedroom affair in a crumbling terrace that looks like it might slip down the steep wet hill at any moment. I never thought of it as small, back then. The gardens are unkempt, there are several broken windows in the street and the corner shop is boarded up and has junk piled outside it. Ireland's new wealth doesn't seem to have percolated down quite this far.
In my mind, I hear her voice speaking to me outside this door. It was the last time we ever spoke to one another: 'I'll be over at your heels. You find a place to stay and a job, sort things out, get settled. As soon as you're ready, just pick up the phone. That's all you have to do.' We kiss and I turn to leave, 'It isn't really goodbye,' she says in that laughing little-girl voice of hers, 'we'll be back together in no time.' I start down the hill, look back and wave. She waves too, the image of her shapely little body silhouetted against the setting sun becomes burned into my memory. She goes inside. The door closes.
Just that image in my mind tells me that I can't let it be the end. Wherever she is, whatever life she's leading, there's so much I want to tell her. I'm writing for the stage now. I can get her parts. I have contacts in TV and films. No matter how big her career is, no matter where she's living, there are things that I can do for her... No, that isn't really it. It's about me. I'm the one with the needs. I need her approval. I want to show off to her – show her what I've done... 'Well done, Danny,' I want her to say, 'I always knew you had it in you. We could have been such a team. We can still be such a team. We're not dead yet, Danny!' Maybe most of all I need to say sorry, and to hear her say that it's all right.
I knock at the door and wait anxiously.
Why did I never make that phone call? What will I tell her if she opens the door right now and faces me with it? Never mind what I might tell her, what's the truth? The truth is, I had arrived in a great big city whose scale took my breath away. A city full of writers and theatres and would-be intellectuals in coffee bars and girls with short skirts and come-on eyes. The truth is, I thought I could do better. Not a very nice truth but the truth nevertheless. I try to forgive myself. I was young then, and I was a fool. And now I suppose I've become an old fool. Oh well, that must be a kind of progress.
I knock on the door again.
Nobody answers, but a small boy passing on the pavement pauses to enlighten me. 'Them people's gone away. Don't live there no more.'
'Oh. Thank you. Could you tell me: was the family called the Hannigans?'
'I don't know, Mister.'
'Do you know where they went when they moved away?'
'Naw.'
'Well, thanks anyway.' He carries on down the hill. I didn't think she would still be here. If she was she would have answered my letters. She could be anywhere by now. Anywhere in the whole world.
'Is it an old sweetheart you've come here to find?' Barry Dynan asks, after he has stubbed out his cigarette and we are back in the car.
'Am I as easy to read as that?'
''Tis the dream of many's a one, to start over again where we left off when we were teenagers. Well, I won't say anything about it.'
'Why not? I would like to hear what you have to say.'
'In my opinion, 'tis the curse of a lot of Irish people, living in the past. What's done is done, I say. Roll on tomorrow.'
I know that he's right. Even that last letter was twenty years ago now. She was still young when she wrote it. She's probably passed through that rough patch long ago and met somebody else and had a whole brilliant life that didn't include me. Children probably. Maybe went to America and got on to the Broadway stage like she always wanted to. Maybe wrote books under a different name. Maybe... He speaks again, interrupting my thoughts. 'When you're young, everything seems to be possible. I used to play the fiddle in a céilidh band. Folks told me I was the bee's knees, headed for stardom. Well, this is as near the top as I ever got. But I don't go around moaning about it and feeling sorry for myself. No, I keep a firm grip on reality and count the blessings I've got. 'Tis the only way.'
Blessings. Life isn't all blessings. Not by a long shot. I hear the voice of Shelagh's letter playing inside my head:
'I'm afraid some bad things happened since I last wrote to you. Mammy got taken into hospital in Sligo with suspected breast cancer. By the time they got her there it had spread, it seems. She died about four months later. We visited her three times a week. Daddy took it very badly and had to give up work. He wasn't able to do anything much after that and I had to look after him here at home...'
ooOOoo
Mrs Sweeney's Bed and Breakfast smells of stale cigarette smoke but it's clean and she seems friendly. She insists on making tea for me as soon as I arrive, and wants to know what kind of food I like. She asks me about myself. I'm pleased that she's interested and answer all her questions. In the lounge the framed photographs around the walls tell Mrs Sweeney's entire life story. Middle daughter of a farmer's family of five, marriage to a sergeant in the Dublin Garda, three children of her own, husband's death and setting up the guest house on the money he left, daughter's wedding, first grandchild. One space left blank on the wall, to complete the circle. Best not to think about what will go there.
Mrs Sweeney excuses herself to go about some task of her own. Telling my own life story, skirting around what's really on my mind, has left me quite drained. I sit in silence for a moment, then, absently, I take Shelagh's letter out again. I don't need to read it, I simply look at it and hear her voice in my head again:
'I met somebody else a couple of years after you left. He was in the Irish Army, based at Finner Camp, and he rode a big American motorbike.'
She arrives back with a fresh pot of tea and a copy of the Donegal Democrat. 'Have you seen Thursday's paper?' she asks, handing it over.
'Seen it? I didn't think the Democrat still existed. Brings back a lot of memories.' I glance at the headlines. Then I lay it down. 'Mrs Sweeney, could I ask you something? About a local family.'
'Of course, Mr Dorian. I'll tell you whatever I can.'
I go through my spiel again: where they lived, what the father did for a living, the daughter named Shelagh with the long auburn hair and sweet laughing voice. I surprise myself this time with the tenderness of my description. I forget that I'm talking about someone I haven't seen in more than three decades. Mrs Sweeney looks blank at first, then brightens. 'Shelagh Hannigan as was. Shelagh Breslin as is, the one with the husband in the wheelchair?'
I put down my cup. Suddenly I'm not sure that I want to hear her story. The letter is still in my hand. I glance down at it. I don't need to read it, I know exactly what it says:
'We fell in love, Danny. I'm sorry but there's no kind way to say it. I hadn't seen you for such a long time and he was so nice to me. And it was great, riding around on that big American motorbike. But then something terrible happened. I can't bear to tell you the details, but he had an accident on the bike and died. We were planning to get married. And now I feel so bad about it all. I hope your life has gone better than mine...'
'Her father worked for the ESB – the electricity people. She married a soldier from Finner Camp...'
'Who rode a motorbike,' I put in.
'Aye. That's right. You know all about it then.'
'All about what?'
'The accident. The accident the two of them had at the bottom of Corn Bray, where it comes out onto Bridge Street?'
I think she must see that I have gone pale. 'The two of them? Did you say the two of them had an accident?' I ask very quietly.
'Why, did you think it was just him?'
I report Shelagh's version in a faltering voice.
'That wasn't it at all,' Mrs Sweeney says, clearly indignant, 'I'm afraid she's been telling you a pack of lies. They were both on the bike when it hit the car – and neither of them died. Though it might have been better for him if he had. And they were already married at that stage. I went to the wedding myself.'
We sit very still and look into each other's eyes. 'Look,' she says, 'I didn't know it was as personal as that. I'm sorry I said anything.'
I can't think of a reply. In my head Shelagh's letter goes on playing like a stuck gramophone record:
'I'm on my own again now. Daddy has gone into a retirement home, much the same as the one your own folks went into, but nearby in Letterkenny. I never got to Stage School. I do a really grotty job that I hate. My life is very dull, and I often think of you, and wonder what it would have been like if I'd gone over to England when I was supposed to. I don't expect you've thought about me very much. We were only children really, weren't we? You've probably got a wife and family of your own long ago. I suppose we would hardly know each other now if we met. It's been such a long time. But I just wanted to tell you that I still think of you a lot, and how it might have been.'
'So you're telling me her husband is still alive, Mrs Sweeney?' My voice sounds strange. My throat is drying up.
She glances at the photographs on the wall before she answers. 'That was a terrible thing to happen to somebody,' she says weakly, 'I suppose she gets to the end of her tether at times. Looks for a way out. Maybe that's why she wrote to you – hoping for some kind of a rescue. With the things she has to put up with – maybe she isn't entirely rational any more. Maybe she needs a little bit of a fantasy life, to be able to carry on.'
'What is it she has to put up with? Why did you say it might have been better for him if he had died?'
Mrs Sweeney looks very uncomfortable. 'Well, they didn't wear helmets back in those days. His brain was affected. He's a child now – you know what I mean. A child that's never going to grow up. Never going to walk again either. It's very sad. She was left with a scar and a bad leg – and a man in a wheelchair without his wits to look after for the rest of her days.'
Realisation hits me like a physical blow. I let the letter fall from my hand, flutter down on to Mrs Sweeney's polished wooden coffee table. For a moment I am completely still.
My powers of speech have almost left me. I can only rasp: 'A scar you say. Is it on her left cheek?'
Mrs Sweeney nods.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
About Me
Ere, David, we agreed to post on the 4th - Monday! :-)
About Me
I like the writing itself very much - the conversational tone, with its underlying wistfulness, strikes just the right note for the theme of the piece. The description works well too - puts the reader right into the situation & gives a great feel of a slightly out of the way little town.
At times, I felt some of the actions in the narrative were slightly over-articulated, e.g.:
'There is a phone number below it. I punch the numbers into my mobile and press 'send'.
I thought this was one of those rare occasions where 'tell' would be better than 'show' - we don't necessarily need to see the character dialling the number etc.
You might want to have a look at this line too:
'She says she can do me a chicken salad, to which I agree'
There's a slight ambiguity here - i.e. it could be read as him agreeing that she's capable of making a chicken salad.
My biggest problem was with the plot. The general idea was good - a universal theme - but it struck me as dubious that the emotional impact of the whole hung on him seeing her as the waitress in the café and not recognising her due to the scar on her cheek.
I take issue with it for various reasons: (1) it seems improbable that there's no recognition at all (not impossible, I admit, but unsatisfactory); (2) I read a story of yours not so long ago in which you used exactly the same device; (3) the non-recognition thing is surely a little hackneyed; and (4) it's unsatisfying - it ducks the issue.
Personally, I'd much rather they met and talked - and then maybe found out how little they liked or cared for each other perhaps. A lot of what's in the story by hearsay - his conversations with others - could be shifted into that conversation & might be more powerful as a result.
All that said, I liked the gradual uncovering of the truth of what had happened to her through those conversations - it was done with great skill and subtlety - but the twist at the end didn't work for me.
Rupe
About Me
Good story, though it needs some tightening, as it's a bit wordy here and there.
Plotwise, I believed that he wouldn't recognise the fat and scarred waitress as the delectable Shelagh, but not that she wouldn't recognise him, as the impression given is that he is simply an older, greyer version of his old self. Maybe you could give him a beard that he never had before, or something like that. Or maybe hint that she has recognised him but chooses to keep quiet. That would be even better.
Good, well-paced story-telling. Watch out for words like 'seemed' and 'rather', which are always superfluous in my experience.
About Me
I thought this was excellent, the dialogue realistic and I never saw the ending coming at all, gave me quite a shiver. Can't pick any faults in it personally, got completely caught up in the story and thoroughly enjoyed it, too!
Romany.
About Me
I saved reading this 'til all the others were in.
Not much to say here - I thought this was very well-written, and I have no issue with characters remembering/forgetting - it's all in the writing, and you pulled it off. (And anyway, if he weren't famous, I would defy anyone to recognise Keith Richards as the same big-eared goofy youth of the sixties).
All I will say is , it maybe could do with a light trim, but more importantly, I think the start lets you down, it doesn't do the story justice and makes it difficult to get into.
In other words, if i was flicking through an anthology, I would have skipped it at first.
If it started at the point of "I'm the only one getting out at this stop," then I would have been grabbed. The story hits the ground running, as it were.
Having another look, I think it was the second para that stalled me; it just seemed to fall over itself.
But overall, a very wistful, sad little tale.
Cheers.
About Me
Having heard you do a reading, I could really hear you telling the story - not something that's happened before when reading your work. It added a depth and reality to the whole story. Didn't have a problem with the waitress scene. I didn't put much importance on her, and at the end, I had to skip back and reread it. Nicely done.
Lisa
About Me
Thanks very much Ginger. I'm glad that it worked for you.