From the UKAuthors Collection
Cargoes
By e-griff · Originally published 24 February 2007
poem written for Poetry Workshop challenge. subject 'restoring waterways'
Cargoes
Where barges once plied
A trade on the waters
While bright-painted boats
With pink-cheeked young daughters
Sailed past with a smile
There’s now plastic bottles
And cycles and mattresses,
old baby rattles
The stream that was full,
Uncluttered and pouring
Is sluggish and muddy,
Congested. The mooring
Where vessels were tied
Is matted and thick
And clogged up with wire,
Old fence posts and brick
The waterway proper
Is filled in with rubble.
Choked of its life,
It breathes the odd bubble
From something that’s lying
Trapped under the scum:
A dead dog or rat,
A leaky old drum?
And further along
Beneath the old bridges
Lie bedframes and bicycles,
TVs and fridges
Microwaves, radios,
Little girl's dollies
Fishing rods, railings,
Tripods and trolleys
For man is a doer
He dug all these courses
He built all the boats
He reared the horses
He made all the engines
He found all the fuel
He ran the rat-race
To technology’s rule
Water carried the goods
As no other means could:
Stone, coal and pig iron
Flour, corn, wheat and wood
It provided the channels
To power the nation
Now we are seeking
To make restoration
Bring back good health
To our ways and our waters
Unblock the culverts
(bring back the daughters!)
Free the lock gates
Unshackle the flows
Give water its life
And see how it grows
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Cargoes
...and speaking of 'Cargoes', John, as we were some time previously, John Masefield, I am sure, would admire this. As I do. A brilliant poem, worthy, more than, of its nomination.
best regards
Tina
Cargoes
Great one griff, really hits the spot. Val x
Cargoes
I like this e-g. It's excellent. So simple yet very effective. A poem for all. Well done, Albert.
Cargoes
I like the way you turned the initial challenge, i.e how rubbish grows, onto its head at the end with:
Give water its life
And see how it grows.
Clever!
Romany.
Cargoes
Ah the golden age, those darn railroads, did you know Burke and Hare worked on our canals before they became grave robbers. I understand your point fully but then for me to really agree I'd have to come out of my comfort zone. The canals now are to polluted to ever use again, why do you think we have a Nobel prize.
RODEL
Cargoes
Nobel polluted the canals with mercury from his dynamite factories, he dumped all his chemical waste in the canals where his factories were and its still there, hmmmm maybe he was mad as a hatter, and yes I share your dream.
RODEL
Cargoes
I wouldn't ever use 'Cargoes' as a title. I love that Masefield poem... you're setting yourself up for comparisons here. Okay, I can see why you've done it, but still wish you hadn't. I'll resist the temptation to compare, ignore the title, and take the poem on its merits.
This is going to be tricky. A phrase like 'pink-cheeked young daughters' is such a turn-off, that had anyone else written this poem, I'd have stopped at that point. However, I will persevere, partly out of curiosity, partly out of respect for your writing, but mainly because you pointed out early on in the challenge that 'they're probably quite conservative, so it's more Betjeman than Eminem'. For the record, I don't like Betjeman, but am something of an Eminem fan. I'll try and forget that for the duration of reading your poem.
To continue. These strange barges of yours have procreated and produced pink daughters. Yes, I know that's a misreading. I'm just being pedantic. I'll be sensible now. "There's now plastic bottles" is necessary for the rhythm, but you're stretching the grammar slightly. There is now plastic bottles, is there? Or there are plastic bottles. Trouble is, of course, "there's" is fine, but "there're" ain't great. Pedantic quibbles aside, the rhymes are fine, and the rhythm never falters. A good introductory stanza.
Second stanza, delicious bit of enjambment here. However, the mooring can be wrapped round with wire, but it can't really be wrapped round with old fence posts or brick.
Third stanza, best so far. I like the image of the "odd bubble", and the possibilities of what's rotting down there. However, I'm not sure a rusting oil drum would rot and produce bubbles. I think it needs to be something organic.
Fourth stanza, fine, except that only little girls call their dolls "dollies"; poets should call them dolls. Trouble is, then you have to have "Tripods and trolls", which is the sort of line I would write, and would take you off into a fantasy waterway where next thing you know, the Billy Goats Griff would be wandering over a bridge. ;)
Fifth stanza, fine, except that if you put "reared" and "horses" in the same line, the reader can't help but see horses rearing, even though it's clear that's not what you meant. Last couple of lines don't quite scan, but I like them a lot.
Sixth stanza, too many syllables in the fourth line. Reads better if you drop "corn". Last couple of lines are a bit pat. Not convincing. I should, of course, offer an alternative at this point. (Thinks.) Don't have one, unfortunately.
Seventh stanza, yay! Humour! I like the "bring back the daughters" line. Makes me wish there'd been more humour throughout the poem. Last four lines are good.
Right. That'll do. You may now refute all my points and I'll come back and have a rethink.
Cargoes
Sounds a lot like the A'dam canals - they dredge 'em occasionally and come up with the most bizarre stuff, including the odd corpse or two. Should you be so unfortunate as to fall (or be pushed) in, you're advised to go straight to hospital to have stomach pumped and a tetanus shot. Lovely.
Like pome, Griff.
Cargoes
I thought this a well thought out piece John.
I too liked the ending, clever and enjoyed it.
Si:-)
Cargoes
Edited a wee bit again now - thanks Cathy! G
Cargoes
Excellent poem, John. More Auden than Betjeman IMO.
I tend to agree that rhyming dollies with trolleys is a bit contrived but it is a minor point. All in all a very skilled composition.