From the UKAuthors Collection
A Secret No More
By Kazzmoss · Originally published 26 January 2007
By popular demand.... I just hope I've done it justice....
When Tasha knocked on the door, my wife looked at me and her hands absently straightened the bedclothes.
I was stunned when I saw Tasha; it was like looking at Miriam twenty years ago. When I found my voice, I invited her in and she looked as nervous as Miriam had.
The two women stared at each other and I knew this was the moment that my wife had been waiting for.
Miriam held out her arms and Tasha went to her immediately. I decided to leave them alone to talk.
It was a secret she had kept from me long after we were married; how her only daughter had been kidnapped from the garden twenty years before. How she had learned to live with that, I’ll never know, but her broken heart had never mended and it was the tragic Miriam I had fallen in love with.
I loved Miriam the moment I saw her and it was the sadness in her eyes that compelled me to make her happy. I never did and that’s when she told me and it made me love her all the more.
I thought long and hard about telling her about the phone call and initially turned Tasha away. She had no knowledge of how fragile her mother was and how unfair it would be for them to find each other only to each lose each other again.
When I opened the door with the tea tray, I found them both chatting. There was a light in Miriam’s eyes I had never seen before and I knew I had done the right thing.
They both looked at me and smiled, it was the same smile. I put down the tray and handed them a cup each as they resumed their animated talk. I listened. For two people who had not seen each other in far too long, it was as if they had never been apart, as if they were one and the same.
When the tea had been drunk and I could see Miriam was tiring, I called an end to the meeting. Tasha kissed her mother and I saw a genuine love there.
As we left the room Miriam lay back on her pillow and closed her eyes.
At the front door Tasha looked me and her eyes were sad. The same sad eyes I had been looking at for a long time.
She kissed me on the cheek and told me her father was not all bad and that he knew it was time that the secret came out.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
A Secret No More
Hi Kazz,
So Tasha was the one in the other story, about her 'dad' telling her she had been taken?
I felt it could be slightly longer, to allow for details like Miriam's illness to be explained more. As it is, I had to assume that Miriam is dying.
Granted, that is fairly obvious. But the questions I had then were 'how long has she got left?', 'what happens between them now?'
Perhaps these questions are to be answered in a later piece?
There is a sense that this piece was unplanned, and had only been written recently to meet the 'popular demand' you mention in the 'blurb'.
However, it's a good addition to the existing story. Maybe another couple of stories are in the pipeline from the POV of Tasha's 'other' parents?
Karl
A Secret No More
The writing comes across as a bit 'jerky' in places, due to some of the short sentences and a fair bit of repetition. Somehow, you didn't make the characters 'live' for me - perhaps some dialogue would break up the telling of the story. However, this is only my perception and I think you can make this poignant story really tug at heart strings.
Ann
A Secret No More
It doesn't quite do it for me, I'm afraid & the for that is because it reads more like a summary than a story - it's all 'telling'.
I think the problem is that you've set yourself far too big a task in trying to tie up, in a few sentences, the consequences of the premise set out in the earlier piece. I just don't see how it can be done - there's a novel's worth in that idea. How about giving it a go?
Rupe
A Secret No More
there is so much that intrigues me in the above, but it is done too quickly. Why was she snatched, why tell her now, why did her real mother not tell her partner, is she dying etc, etc. Rupe is right there is a novel in this, or a least a novella. You should seriously consider working on this.
A Secret No More
I virtually always want more from a piece of flash, and it seems that everyone else agrees here! That's not a real crit, just a desire to see it all opened up in (maybe) 2k words? Yes, there is a longer story still in such a dramatic situation, but I think you could settle the big issues in that length. I'd certainly read it - I think it's only when anyone goes well over 2k words that it puts people off, and, say 1950 or so might psychologically be even better! You have tons ofmaterial here, and I'm sure everyon'e just wishing you on - go for it!
A Secret No More
Hello Karen. I think you've had extremely good feedback on both these stories. Paraphrasing what others have said, the first one was unsatisfying because it just set up a situation and left it at that. The second one was also unsatisfying because it tried to tie up too many loose ends in too short a space and because the characters didn't "live" - probably for the same reason, too little space. And again, inevitably I think in very short pieces, both stories were a bit "telly".
What you've got here is a good basic idea around which to build a story. You say people don't read longer pieces, but I don't think that is entirely true, I have had masses of comment on stories more than 4,000 words long, and even if length does deter some readers here that isn't something that you can allow to dictate how you write. All the major writing contests for example, and most published short stories, operate towards the upper end of the word lengths that get submitted here. I personally think that it's hard enough to write a good short story in four thousand words, to write as good one in a few hundred words is almost impossible. I would say expand this, develop the characters, and on the plot side come up with some reason as to why she was kidnapped, why she was told, and also I would suggest some reason why it makes a critical difference in her life: e.g. maybe she offers one of her kidneys for transplant to someone she believes to be a relative but she is in reality completely different genetically. That's a bit technical, but I think you need a reason as to why it matters in absolute terms. It's a great basic scenario that offers scope for all kind of examination of notions of personal identity and sense of self. Don't cramp it by rationing the words too much.