From the UKAuthors Collection
The Runner-Up
By sirat · Originally published 22 January 2007
This is a very simple little story that came to me while I was sitting in a Walthamstow cafe just before closing time...
“Did you give Miss Rand my message?”
“Of course. Miss Rand is a very busy lady. She may not be able to answer your message straight away.”
“But she’s only in town for three nights.”
“I appreciate that, Sir. Miss Rand is very conscientious and always responds to communications from her fans…”
“I’m not just a fan. I told you that…”
“I’m sorry, Sir. There’s really no more that I can do.”
He paused for a moment, then hung the receiver back on its battered wall fixture .
Moss looked up from his potato-peeling. “You’re not still trying to get through to that Holly Rand woman, are you? She obviously doesn’t want to know.”
Charlie made his way back to the huge double sink and continued to clean the bean-pan. “What do you know? Nothing. You don’t know a thing. It isn’t Holly, it’s her minders. Her goons. They think I’m a crank or a stalker or something and they won’t pass on my messages.” He attacked the side of the pot so vigorously with the abrasive pad that the handle slipped from his grasp and the pot clattered into the sink.
“Jesus, Charlie, you need to relax. It's not good at your age to get all stressed-out. You’re letting this thing get to you. Want me to finish that?”
“I’m fine, Moss. I’m good. What do you mean, at my age? You get those peeled for the morning.” For a while the two men worked in silence. “You know,” Charlie said quietly, I think I’ve got to find a way to fix it so that she sees me - out there in the crowd maybe. Maybe if I stood in the crowd after the show - shouted or something...”
“You’re going to make a fool of yourself, Charlie. Why don’t you face it, she doesn’t remember you. She doesn’t care. Get on with your life, man!”
“You don’t know a thing, Moss, don’t know a thing.” Charlie’s hands became still. The suds ran down the side of the pot into the frothy water. He lowered it gently under the foam.
“Last two customers have just gone,” Vera barked through the hatch, “I'm going to lock up while I have the chance."
"Yeah, that's fine. The rain's pissing down out there. We won't get any more business tonight." Charlie absent-mindedly wiped his hands and made his unsteady way to the stained industrial dishwasher which he started to unload. "Forget the potatoes, Moss. Make us all a coffee."
***
Charlie limped through the swing doors and sat down at Table 10, opposite Moss and three tall transparent beakers of white-topped coffee. Vera was still standing at the locked door watching the rainstorm through the glass. She turned and wearily joined them. “Vera. You’re a woman," Charlie said thoughtfully as she sat down.
“Aw! Gee! That’s the nicest thing you’ve said to me since I came to work here, Charlie.”
Outside, the rain was blasting the pavement. The street lights lit up the puddles in a firework display of shimmering colours. The hiss was almost as loud as his voice.
“No, seriously. I want some advice. If there had once been… somebody special in your life… and then you lost touch with that person, for a long time…” He hesitated, searching for the right words. Moss shrugged and snorted. Charlie ignored him. “Would you want that person to get in touch with you again… if your two lives had gone in very different directions?”
She gave him a sympathetic look. “Charlie baby, you’re in love, and that’s a terrible thing in somebody of our kind of age. Love stories never end happily, except in the movies. No matter what I say, you’re going to torture yourself over this singer woman, and you don’t really want to hear what I think about it.”
“No, I do, Vera. That’s why I asked.”
She took a sip of her coffee before she answered. “Well, it’s an impossible question. It depends on all kinds of circumstances. But if you want my best guess, I don’t think she wants to be reminded about the part of her life that she shared with you. I mean, look at her. She’s successful, beautiful, famous, wealthy… men are falling at her feet. They think that’s how it’s always been for her. She’s a goddess to thousands of people. Why should she want to be reminded of…” she made a wide gesture with her hand, “this?”
Charlie nodded gravely. “I’m a fool,” he said. A powerful gust of wind flung a sheet of rain against the window, lifting the hiss to a sudden crescendo.
“You’re not a fool, Charlie,” Moss insisted. “You’re a good man. Too good for that Rand woman. She didn’t appreciate you when she had the chance.”
“What do you know?” Charlie mumbled his automatic response. “What do you know?”
His thoughts were interrupted by a loud “rat-tat-tat” on the glass panel of the front door. As one, the three seated figures looked up. "You expecting someone, Charlie?" Moss asked.
Charlie shook his head and pulled himself to his feet. Mentally cursing the stiffness in his left leg he made his way to the door and admitted a dripping female figure, hooded in a dark plastic cagoule. “Come in, Miss…”
As she introduced herself she pulled the hood clear of her face. “Rand. Holly Rand. How do you do? I know you’re not open, and I won’t take up more than a minute of your time.” Her smile almost stopped Charlie’s heart.
Staring in wide-eyed amazement he stepped to one side and motioned towards Table 1 where she sat down, unbuttoning her cagoule to reveal an expensive white suede jacket, glowing locks of straight black hair and a figure that would have brought envy to the heart of an angel. The two at the far end of the room stared also, but more discreetly. Out of the corner of his eye he saw Vera give him the “thumbs up” sign. Charlie slumped into the chair opposite, his face drained of all colour. “I’m looking for someone who used to work here,” she explained. “It was a long time ago. His name was Charlie Symmonds.”
Charlie didn't reply, just continued to stare, his lips quivvering very slightly.
"Charlie Symmonds. Does the name mean anything to you? This would have been twenty years ago - maybe more."
Charlie tried to speak, croaked like an adolescent whose voice was breaking, then tried again. “I… I don’t think I knew him. What was he like?”
“He was about two or three inches taller than you, shining sandy-blond hair, broad shoulders… he used to run a lot. He came second in the London Marathon, about 1982 or 3 I think. And he was selected for the Los Angeles Olympic team in 1984. I think he was a runner-up in that too, in one of the middle distance events. He just worked here temporarily, while he was waiting to get into University. He was very ambitious. He wanted to be a scientist, or a surgeon. Something like that. Do you know what happened to him?”
Charlie remained motionless for another moment. "I wish I did," he said quietly.
“No, I thought he wouldn’t have been here very long. Can I give you this…” she produced a card from her jacket pocket, “and if you ever hear anything about him just give me a call. It’s my private number so please don’t give it to anybody else.”
He held it in his outstretched hand and nodded. She sprang to her feet, quickly circled the table, and kissed him lightly on the cheek. “Thanks for your time. Sorry if I’ve kept you back.” Then she pulled her raincoat together and was gone.
He remained frozen in position, hand outstretched and holding the card, while the other two joined him. Vera put her hand on his shoulder. “God, you must feel terrible,” she whispered. His body came back to life and he screwed up the card and placed it in the empty ashtray. “No,” he said with quiet composure. “I think it’s fantastic that she wants to see Charlie Symmonds again. It’s just such a pity that he isn’t here.”
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
The Runner-Up
Hi David,
This is a lovely little story with just the right amount of pathos at the end. I got caught up in it, but quite late on. I had trouble with the positioning of everyone early on, I'm afraid, and kept having to reread to work it out. I wasn't sure why the bean pan was being washed if the cafe was still open, and I think you need indicators earlier on that it is a cafe, as I pictured a house for quite a while. Plus I couldn't picture an age for Charlie initially - cell phone and muscled banging of pots gave me a picture of a younger man.
The break to the second sequence also confusing as I thought it was a continuation of the first scene, and he had just limped into the cafe, so then got confused when Moss reappeared there. Maybe I'm just not reading well today though, but if anyone else has these problems I don't think it would take a lot of changes to make it work.
Also, I wonder if a little more conversational buildup between Charlie and Holly might not help it - he denied who he was very early on, and its a key moment to have very little preceding it. Hope this is of use.
The Runner-Up
A poignant and lovely little story, Dave. It shows how wise we are when we ignore the facts and remember the fancy. It shows great understanding.
Sometimes it's best to let your characters do the talking for themselves. Whenever the writer jumps in to explain things they suffer for it. "Charlie slumped into the chair opposite the apparition, never shifting his gaze from her exquisite face. Holly was used to men responding to her in this way and continued, unruffled." I think the scene is much more telling without those two sentences.
The Runner-Up
OH, glad you told us that David. i had some concerns and was a bit hesitant to point them out if you'd been polishing this - in fact I should have known you hadn't as a couple of the things I know you wouldn't leave in normally. OK, I'll be back when I've concised my ideas. (like my new US persona?).
The Runner-Up
This may be a bit long, I'm sorry.
‘He paused for a moment, then hung (the receiver back on its battered wall fixture)’ – this seems a remarkably long way of saying ‘hung up’. I’m not sure how much local colour it brings – most people have modern phones now. Is it a payphone? (on a wall).
He attacked the side of the pot so vigorously with the abrasive pad that the handle slipped from his grasp and the pot clattered into the sink. – yep good ‘showing’ – we learn he’s upset, angry.
“You know,” Charlie said quietly, I think I’ve got to find a way to let her see me. Maybe if I was in the crowd after the show.” -- missing speech marks.
It’s a curious thing to say – to let her see me. It doesn’t seem natural (as ‘a way to see her’) I realise it is presaging the scene at the end of the story, but maybe it’s a mite too knowing on the author’s part to bring it forward here.
“You don’t know a thing, Moss. Don’t know a thing.” I think that the punctuation here doesn’t suit the repetition (the period). A comma might be better (or an ellipsis), or use a period or comma and ‘Not a thing.’
“Last two customers have just gone,” barked Vera through the hatch, “I'm going to lock up while I have the chance." --- as the first part of the interrupted speech can be read as a complete statement on its own (whether intended or not), the second part should start afresh, punctuation –wise. Eg: “Last two customers have just gone,” barked Vera through the hatch. “I'm going to lock up while I have the chance."
"Yeah, that's fine. The rain's pissing down out there. We won't get any more business tonight." -- well, to be pedantic, if they are the LAST two customers, that’s patently obvious. :-)
***
‘Charlie limped out through the swing doors and sat down at Table 10, opposite Moss and three tall transparent beakers of white-topped coffee. Vera took a last pensive look at the rainstorm through the locked front door and wearily joined them.’ --- I lost the sequence here. I think it maybe cos it opens with Charlie doing something, which is what he was doing at the end of the last section. Perhaps if it opened … ‘They sat round the table, gripping the tall plastic….. it would better indicate a traditional break .
“Aw! Jee! --- I think ‘Gee’ here.
Moss shrugged and snorted through his closed lips (in a scoffing gesture). --- I think, as Harry commented, sometimes you explain too much, too knowingly, so maybe let the snort stand on its own merits. ie, so the narrator is reporting, not interpreting.
For once Vera did not mock his intensity and (barely concealed pain). --- this is either same as above or a quick POV switch to Vera?
“No, really, I do, Vera. That’s why I asked.” /She took a sip of her coffee before she answered. ---- for some reason here, I personally think this would read better if the She was replaced by Vera, and the first Vera removed.
But if you want my best guess, I don’t think she wants to be reminded about the part of her life that she shared with you. I mean, look at her. --- might soften this with ‘I think she may’ Throughout, Vera seems to know far too much about it, although you may have done this deliberately.
Charlie nodded gravely. “I’m a fool,” he said, (mainly to himself.) --- maybe too much explanation again?
“You’re not a fool, Charlie,” Moss put in, softening. --- ‘put in’ is a wee bit strange, although I understood it, but ‘softening’ is Mr omniscient narrator looking inside Moss’s head.
“What do you know?” Charlie mumbled his automatic response, “what do you know?” ----- rules of speech punctuation again, IMO should be ‘… response. “What do …’
As one, their mouths opened in disbelief. --- OK, it’s peeing down, dark (?) there’s a hooded figure buttoned up in a plastic cagoule, and presumably a notice and some signs in the window, and they all recognise her? Seems a little precognitive.
The two at the far end of the room stared also, but more discreetly. --- I think there is a sort of coy circumlocution here in describing the characters. I would be tempted to cut this sentence out altogether. It’s clear from the focus of the narration on the two at the table that the others are not at the table with them, or close enough to be involved.
but a response would have been inappropriate ---- who makes this judgement, Charlie? If you’re going to ‘tell’ like this it would be better to do it directly. Although this all appears to be Charlie’s POV, we aren’t getting enough reminders of that to keep us on track, IMO
The two below also fall into the same category for me
Why ‘apparition’? --- first read I felt it was the narrator steering us.
her exquisite face. ---
Holly was used to men responding to her in this way ---- Not her POV - Mr omniscient narrator /too much explanation.
The pause became almost embarrassing. --- one, ‘almost’ – either it was embarrassing or it wasn’t. Maybe it was about to become embarrassing. --- and once again – I don’t know who is saying this?
"Charlie Symmonds? Does the name mean anything to you. --- Q mark missing after ‘you’ (and maybe lose the one after Symmonds)
“He was about two or three inches taller than you, -- - Charlie is sitting down, so how does she know? she can't have had time to judge, bustling in from the rain ... you could say, your kind of build, but bigger.
Can I give you this…” she produced … ----- She produced…
Nodded, he felt, inanely --- slightly awkward and prob. unnecessary. We’re in Charlie’s POV, so why not just indicate his feeling of awkwardness in some way.
(while the other two moved up the room and joined him.) --- this is almost a stage direction, don’t think you need it, we can sort that out ourselves.
His immobilised body … - you said he was ‘frozen’ two lines ago, no need to repeat it.
As I’ve said, I was never sure who was in charge here, the narrator or Charlie. There’s only sporadic mentions of his feelings, and the narrator appears to put his own interpretations in in places, as well as the POV slippage.
The big thing for me, reading this is that when I have met people I knew well, even after a gap of 30 years, I recognised them at once, so sitting at a table and talking, well, it would be hard for her not to recognise him. The only dodge I can suggest is she’s forgotten her glasses (she’s vain and doesn’t like people to know). Or he’s been horribly mutilated in a chip fryer accident --- no, just joking! :-)
Overall, though, It’s a nice story with an effective snap at the end, I think. My niggles are small, as you will appreciate.
The Runner-Up
I like the writing very much - the narratorial authority, the realistic dialogue - but am in two minds about the premise of the story (that she no longer recognises Charlie because he's changed so much). It's dramatically very effective, but is it literally believable? And if it's not entirely believable, does it matter?
The issue is complicated further by the fact that she comes to the cafe to find him - she must know already, therefore, that he's no high flyer. By extension, she must already have an inkling of his reduced status and his possibly moth-eaten state. The place where she's seeking him, therefore, already indicates reduced expectations.
And the realism of the treatment you've used here doesn't leave much space for the lack of recognition to work on a purely symbolic level - the reader expects it to be literally believable too.
These issues make the fact that she doesn't recognise him less credible than they might otherwise be - and, arguably, at the same time more damaging to the story.
All that said, I suspect there's plenty you can do to the narrative to minimise this problem.
Some small points:
- 'You're a woman'. I'd put the word 'Vera' before this, so that it's 'Vera. You're a woman.' I can really 'hear' that - but I don't hear it so well without the name.
- the use of '...' to indicate the hesitations in Charlie's speech. There is a slight ambiguity here - it's possible to think that you're using the dots to indicate that something is missing from the speech.
- I was a little unsure about the sheet of rain against the window. You have mentioned the rain earlier, but it does seem like a rather self-consciously dramatic touch. Perhaps it's just a personal prejudice though.
Rupe
The Runner-Up
Thanks, David. I gave you a good-length report because 1 it's a draft and 2 it's you :-). In fact such a level of crit is normal/required on some writing sites (glad it's not on UKA - phew!).
While I'm grateful for the politeness in your full response, there is really no need for it (I'd hate to think my long feedback demanded a long reply - not at all). What I've given is feedback from one reader, full stop. It's up to you as the author to decide what to do after reading all the feedback you get ( and none of my business!) G :-)
The Runner-Up
In the light of your answer, I just went over the piece again. I have to admit that my eye must have slid over the line about Charlie working temporarily in the cafe when she knew him (sorry about that) - it DOES make a difference to my feelings about the credibility of the premise.
I take your point about her possibly embellished memory & the way in which people might change over 20 years or so. But on the other hand, wouldn't there be a tiny spark of almost-recognition?
I wondered, in the light of that idea, whether there would be any mileage in making her pursue her enquiries a little further. Something along the lines of - this is purely to indicate the general point, however - 'His eyes were a little like yours,' she said slowly. 'But of course he wouldn't be as old as you - sorry, no offence - and he's a taller man too.'
Or would this kind of thing be a slightly false way of wringing extra pathos from the situation? Depends on the handling, I suppose.
Rupe
The Runner-Up
There's not much I can add to the extremely full critiques you have already had. I was mildly surprised when she did not recognise him at all, and I would like to have knwn more about Charlie - why did he not fulfil his early promise? I like it though, it has a real sense of pathos.
The Runner-Up
I enjoyed this and everyone has, more or less, said what I'd say...but, taking Moya's point above, I don't think even the title 'runner up' sums up the pathos. There's a whole lifetime between the runner up and the man in the story and it would be nice to know the reason why.
eg
Charlie remained motionless for another moment. "I wish I did," he said quietly, staring at his needle scarred arms.
Now I'm not suggesting that as a reason, but it gives the reader a clue.....
I hardly feel that I should crit yours, Sirat, so I'm bowing out now! Ann
The Runner-Up
How about,
'Also ran'
as the title.
Instead of being 'picked' for the marathon, you could say...'he also ran in the......'
Would tie in the past and present.
Heyho, just a thought.
Ann
The Runner-Up
surely we've got a reason in his awkwardness in his walking, and isn't there a 'limp' in there somewhere - I assumed these were deliberately placed, and he'd suffered an injury at some stage or just got worn down ...
On the recognition - your own experience accounts for the difference in our views, I think. I invited several old pals from 30 years ago to both our 25th and 30th wedding annivs. Large numbers were turning up, some I didn't recognise (my wife's friends) but I knew my old pals immediately. What is more, after saying hello, our conversation fell immediately into the patterns and easy familiarity of 30 years before ...
The question for you is, though, OK, you might lose someone in a pub crowd ... but , never mind 'friends', a more appropriate question in relation to your story is: would you fail to recognise one of your old girl friends, sitting down at a table and talking to her? And in the story, she's prob got old pics of him or she wouldn't be there in the first place. :-)
The Runner-Up
I actually had a thought for a new story last night, based on the bit where he's runner up a lot in this one. It's called 'Second Best' (and is completely different topic from this).
The Runner-Up
My dear Sirat,
This is a lovely story! It reads almost like a Hollywood script! The pathos and the poignancy of a man's lost love, a man who held a lot of promise but lost out in life somewhere along the way, who probably lived by the memory of this love, but when faced with reality, just could not rise up to the occasion, probably because he was brought back to reality by that one incident from his life of fantasy...
Sometimes meeting old friends of youth make us realize our own reality, very acutely... and you realize how time can change you completely into another person, unrecognizable to your own self even...
I love the ending!
(((Hugs for sharing the nice story!)))
Love, Zoya
The Runner-Up
Hello Sirat,
Somehow I had a feeling all along that she would barge in on him and renew their acquaintance. The ending was quite a surprise, though.
Interesting story, very poignant.
Soman
The Runner-Up
I always post my comment then go back and read what everyone else has said - so I shall probably get some answers on reading those. I enjoyed this story and liked the atmosphere it created. It was different, but was completely baffled at the end - Kazz
The Runner-Up
Hi David,
It's more me, I'm easily baffled, your not the first story I have read where everyone understands and I don't - Kazz
The Runner-Up
Hi David,
I cannot add anything that has not already been said in the comments above. I enjoyed the way this story carries itself along. I never expected her to come in at the end and then certainly didn't expect him to chuck the card away. But I did like the ending a great deal. This is a lovely little story and if you edit it let me know so I can come back and re-read it.
Jay.