From the UKAuthors Collection
Secrets
By Kazzmoss · Originally published 15 January 2007
Some things are better left unsaid.....
Secrets are a terrible thing. Sometimes its better to take them to your grave and never tell a soul.
I was told a secret and I so wish I hadn’t been confided in. How do you deal with things that mustn’t be told?
How do you get through the day knowing what you know? I don’t know what to do. I lie awake at night. I struggle to eat even when I am hungry.
It happened on a drunken night when things are said that shouldn’t be. We’d gone outside in the fresh air to take a breather from the hot humid room. And then he told me.
“Tasha, you must never tell anyone, but we wanted you so much. You were so beautiful, so full of happiness, we stole you.”
“Stole me? What do you mean?”
“You must never tell another soul, it would break your mother’s heart.”
“Wh-where from?”
“A garden.”
I looked at him too stunned to speak when suddenly he started retracting, but it was said now.
Our secret, my father said kissing my cheek before going back inside.
What am I supposed to do with that?
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Secrets
Excellent. You seem to have an unerring instinct for good fiction ideas. This one certainly packs a punch, particularly when it's pared down almost to the bone as it is here.
You could possibly cut a few words from the first four lines - there's slight overlap here - but overall I thought this was brilliant.
Secrets
Ditto , Kas. Good stuff.
Tina
Secrets
Very powerful. Maybe change 'come to 'gone' - "We'd gone outside..." - and the 'for' later in that line should be 'from', I think. I'd also consider losing the 'sat on a wall, talking about childhood' line. Maybe the impact would be increased further.
Is this the opening to a longer story about how the narrator finally resolves her issue? What happens to her next?
Karl
Secrets
Startling short story, Brilliantly done Val x
Secrets
Kass, this is 'Writer of the month material'. Excellent little vignette. What a question to pose...
Gerry xxx.
Secrets
Splendid piece, really packs a punch. Well done.
Secrets
Very hard-hitting indeed! Very short and cryptic, but it leaves us with a lot to fill in for ourselves...yes, and what a thing to be told. That would really turn your world upside down, wouldn't it? I reckon that leaking secrets like that, far from clearing the air, is unbelievably selfish - passing your problem on to another. It's not "a problem shared is a problem halved" in the words of the proverb - it's doubled!
Secrets
I could grow to like this flash fiction. I never clicked on it before because I mistakenly thought I was something to do with pervy blokes swapping stories about nocturnal trips to the local park. A very strong piece and no mistake. A flash flood of words that leaves you soaked to the skin you're in. I hope this helps. Thanks.
s
u
n
k
e
n
he has sole custody of the turnip
Secrets
ouch, such a great pinch on the brain. love the guilt, the terror and the responsibilities that secrets cause. I knew a man who's father told him as he lay dying that he was part black. The man didn't care either way; he didn't want to lose his father. When the funeral was over by a few weeks, he happened to mention to his wife of fourteen years what his father had told him. She left him and took his children. He had thought they were happily married. I was so glad when he found a woman who loved him as he was. This is a grand flash; you should be so happy with yourself -- I wish that I could "snap" stories in such a way. Well-done
Secrets
i think it could begin from just "Tasha" it is quite moving...scotch
Secrets
these lines really would make an excellent opening to a novel. Why did he tell her at that moment? So many ways the story could be developed and so many ways it could conclude. An excellent conflict set up... go on write some more :)
Secrets
This works very well, as the others have said. All you can do in an ultra-short piece like this is set up some situation that engages the imagination of the reader, and that you have done admirably. I once read on the Internet what is claimed to be the shortest short story in existence, which works in a similar way to yours. Here it is:
For sale. Newborn baby clothes. Unused.
I love stories like this that are practically all subtext. Well done.
A tiny thing you might change: where it says: "things are said that shouldn’t" I think you might add the word "be" at the end.
Secrets
Yep, it says a lot in so few words and while it hits the mark as a piece of flash fiction it could also go off in any number of directions from here if you wished to develop it.
Secrets
I'm in two minds about this. I enjoyed the blunt approach on a complicated subject, and it wasn't overplayed. It does work as a piece of flash fiction. But it left me so unsatisfied - I wonder whether it's really fair to leave a reader hanging after something that reads like a starting point?
Anyway, I would cut the last line as it states something that doesn't need to be said, IMO. And please think about extending it. Oh go on.