From the UKAuthors Collection

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

By Gerry · Originally published 15 January 2007

During the recent problems when UKA was off the air, apart from forums, someone suggested that we post some articles there. I typed the following out and did just that. I think it was popular because there wasn't much else to read at the time, and it was Christmas. It got well over 100 hits before disappearing into the unknown. ;-)

I decided rightly or wrongly to post it here; not to provoke anyone -- but because I have nothing else to post at the moment.
If you want to know what prompted me to write it you will have to read it to the end.

This religious thing. Does it bother you? First of all I will tell you a little about myself.
I was brought up in a Christian family. Was that my fault? I could just have easily been born into a Jewish, Buddhist, Muslim or fifty other religion families. So I cannot be blamed for that.

During my early years I was encouraged to go to Sunday school. I never minded this, I clearly remember having a great time, in fact I made my first stage appearance at Sunday school and sang for the first time in public. I graduated into cubs, again enjoying every minute, and then into scouts. This gave me my first taste of camping and relying on others—many lessons learnt here.

So far I had just gone along with going to church, without fully understanding it. Too young I suppose. However I never had any problems with it. I enjoyed Christmas like any child would. It wasn’t the present’s thing, during the war there were not many presents, but we had a tree and sang Carols and had a few days off from school. I remember these early Christmases as magical times.

I was confirmed when I was eleven, I cannot honestly remember any religious dogma being forced on me; in fact all I can remember was being told to always respect other people, try to be kind and compassionate to everyone, and try to obey the commandments. Well looking back I cannot see much wrong with that. In fact it seems that--that is pretty good advice for anyone to be guided by.

I will move forward now to my working life, I suppose it could be said I was in a quasi-scientific field. I worked with very small voltages that could only be picked up on an oscilloscope to very high voltages in the kilo - voltage range. I worked with Radiation and Quantum problems related to Image Intensifiers and X/Rays, and also Laser Guidance systems. During my National Service I worked with aircraft electronics on the early jet fighters. The reason I mention the above, is that science and belief in a creator never seem to go together. However I never had a problem with this. I have probably read as many books as anyone else has about the start of everything. I can honestly say even after reading the most eminent of science books, I have never been tempted to change my view that we live in a world that was created.

I think that to have a watch—one must have a watchmaker.

Now why do I go to church?

Firstly I am not a religious fanatic. It matters not a hoot to me whether you are an atheist, agnostic or anything else, or what colour you may be, nor will I try to influence you in any way. I like people because of what they are. Who they are does not enter my equation.

I go to church because I like to. Many English churches are very old, and old buildings fascinate me. I love church organs they are amazing instruments. I love singing, although I am the first to admit I am not a good singer. I also love listening to church choirs. There is something very soothing about churches, you can get away from the hustle and bustle of the day and have some peace---not many places left these days where one can get total peace. You don’t have to listen to obscenities, blasphemy or that ridiculous all invading piped music in churches either.

What do I believe? Well like everyone else, I don’t know what happened in the beginning, and I don’t suppose we ever will know. Nor do I know what happens at the end. What I do know is that the grounding I had as a child has never ever seemed wrong or sent me far wrong. I could write a long paper on what I believe was the start of our universe and how and why it occurred, but that is not for here. I can tell you though that it would not have any place for ‘nothing’ exploding.

I am not a goody goody, I consider myself to be just ordinary. I have seen my share of the seedier side of life, and the so-called better side of life, and have not known what to make of either.

Now what prompted this post?
Well I just came across the following on the web.

‘Because people go to church they are more likely to cheat and steal’
Why? Because they think they will be forgiven.

Me. -: Really?

‘People go to church because they are afraid of death.’

ME -: Well not anymore than anyone else I should think :-)

‘People who go to church see themselves as better than anyone else’.

ME-: Well not in my experience they don’t :-)

‘People go to church to reinforce their moral superiority.’

ME -: Really, that’s a bit rich ;-)

‘People who go to church think they are right and everyone else is wrong’

ME -: Well now I definitely have to disagree with that one. ;-)

‘People who go to church are self-righteous and hate filled’

ME -: Well not the one’s that I know, and I know quite a few. :-)

‘People who go church are involved in bizarre behaviour’

Me -: Really, I wonder what that means? ;-)

‘People who go to church are ‘in your face ass-holes’ that think they are better than anyone else.’

ME -: I think we have been there ;-)

By the way if you enjoy good music you can thank the church for:-

Elgar’s - Gerontius.

Mendelsson’s – Elijah

Handel’s - Messiah.

Verdi’s – Requium

Mozart’s – Te-Deum

Beethoven’s Missa – Solemnis.

And: -

Gounod's fabulous Oratorio 'Mors et Vita'

Many more Famous composers wrote fine religious works including Haydn, Rossini, Vivaldi, Brahms and Bruckner .

And I wish you all well in 2007 ---
Whatever your feelings are…

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Evitchka

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Dear Gerry, thanks for posting this. I enjoyed it. Though not a churhgoer, I love sitting in them. I agree with you that they are one of the last bastions of peace and quiet

RoyBateman

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Hi, Gerry - food for thought, obviously, and I hope it provokes some deeper responses than the norm! I agree with you fully on some points: yes, I love medieval architecture, and most of that remaining intact is ecclesiastical. Ditto choral music - most was inspired by religious thought...and medieval art, obviously. But, until recently, belief in religion was the norm even in this society and thus art in all its forms tended to be expressed that way. (As it remains in Muslim societies.) Fine!

I remain a staunch humanist, however - I have often come across, though mainly in the past rather than today, "religious" folk whose other beliefs would seem to clash with their alleged piety. Naturally, I wouldn't include you there, mate - I know your beliefs are sincere and good luck to you. I'm quite convinced that there IS a worldwide need for religion of some kind, if only to "explain" the great unknowables: where do we come from, and where do we go? Science, as yet, can't do that. But, I go further: sure, everything has been created or happened - I can't conceive how. It's no use me trying. But, here's the real question for me - if a God created the universe etc., then who created God? We're left with a conundrum, and the only religious explanation is that God must have created himself. Sorry, I don't get that any more than the universe appeared from nowhere. Neither way makes any sense, ergo the requirement for a creating God vanishes. So, we pay our money and make our choice. It's one of the few freedoms we have left in the UK, so we may as well make use of it. And have a good new year, by the way!

Bradene

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

I read this on the forum and thought what a splendid job you had done, We are of much the same generation You and I Gerry and I recognised all you had to say, although I have to admit I am not a regular churchgoer. I tend to think of the great outdoors as my church. Top write. Love Val x

Rupe

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

In the end, when pondering the God question, I always come to the conclusion - how can we possibly know? God may objectively exist, or he/she may be no more than a projection of the super-ego - we have no real way of establishing the truth either way. All we can do is live a good life, according to our lights, and hope for the best...

With that thought in mind, the only viable solution is tolerance on either side of the question. There ARE some sanctimonious Christians (a minority) who impress the rightness of their views hotly upon people. Equally, there are - as on the website mentioned in your piece - some sanctimonious atheists (again, a minority) who'd have us believe that they know for sure that God does not exist.

Dogmatic insistence on black and white certainties, I believe, the hallmark of an infantile mind and insecure personality. Evangelical Christians and dogmatic atheists probably have more in common than they'd care to admit. We have to learn to live with the uncertainty of life and to accomodate different and conflicting views.

I certainly agree that, whether one is religiously inclined or not, there's spiritual solace to be found in churches - and plenty of non-religious literary types have found the same (Larkin in 'Church Going', for instance).

Overall, an interesting and thought-provoking piece.

Harry

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Thanks for the season's greeting, Gerry. You have a very universal concept of faith, I wish it were shared by everyone. I think you're confidant in your appraisal of a common decency in humankind – that's another thing I wish other people shared.

orangedream

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

I am a believer, a bit like you Gerry. Went to Sunday school and all that and my interpretation of God is that he is the good that lives in all of us, the heady scent of Jasmine on a warm, summer's evening, the song of the skylark and the cry of a new-born child oh and I sometimes find him at the bottom of my glass of G &T at the end of a long, hard day!

Organised religion however, over the ages, has been the root of much bloodshed, The Crusades, The Spanish Invasion of Peru and Mexico, The Spanish Inquisition, the conflict in Northern Ireland, partition of India, (India & Pakistan), current problems in the Middle East, particularly Iraq, etc. etc.

Mr. Orange is what is termed as a 'non-believer' and so we brought up our children to have an open-mind and to decide for themselves which path they should take. Our eldest got heavily involved with the Salvation Army (Fire and Blood their motto) and when she was sixteen wished to join as a bona fide member. We left the choice up to her until we read the code that she had to undertake to live by. The restrictions which would have been placed on her life had to be seen to be believed. We simply told her, that even as her parents, we would never in a million years have imposed such rules upon her life and asked her if she was willing to have any organisation, albeit in this case the Salvation Army tell her how to live her life. She declined to let them. A few years later she was confirmed and now has similar beliefs to mine - of her own volition. The same thing happened to our younger daughter who came to the same decision and who is now, as her father is, a non-believer.

As far as the meaning of life, the universe and everything - I guess I'll go with '42'. In a way though ... I suppose, maybe we ought to think of the right question before we can hope to arrive at the right answer.

kind regards and thank you for an evocative read.

Tina xxxx

neotom

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

I have totally opposing views in terms of belief but I would love it if everyone followed the basic humanity of the ten commandments. I too love the feeling of peace and order in a church. I think the idea of a watchmaker is nonsense though. However, I enjoyed the piece written and its sentiments. If, you, Gerry, ran the world, I feel a lot safer and happier.

Tom

Kazzmoss

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Gerry, what a wonderful article, you sound like a thoroughly nice gentlemen. I can relate to a lot of what you said. I grew up in church, attended Sunday School and guides, because that's how my parents brought us up. I too, enjoyed it. I don't go any more and my husband and son are athiests, but I still feel a certain peace inside a church and I too, love old buildings. When I hear a sermon on the TV, there is something comforting about it. You've written what I've barely thought about, so thank you, I really enjoyed this thought provoking piece. - Kazz

Gerry

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Kass, thank you for your kind comment, and I am pleased that you enjoyed the read. I feel the church in general has been its own worst enemy. Many have been put off going because of the strange decisions and in fighting that always seems to be going on.

I suppose the church has to change with the times though...

C'est la vie...

Gerry ...

niece

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Gerry,

A very interesting write and I loved this:-

"I think that to have a watch—one must have a watchmaker. "

And just like your love of the "church choirs", I too love to chant the Sanskrit verses from my Hindu prayer books, only because the rhythm is so soothing...even if I don't understand what I'm saying(tho' I do get myself books with interpretations in English)

I'm not a religious fanatic either, Gerry...God(if there is one) is the protector and not to be protected...it is sometimes sad to see people fighting in the name of God...do those people really think their God is so weak that He needs to be defended by mere mortals...?

And yes, God is definitely a power that has absolutely no form...some people experience it more than the others...

A very very thought-provoking piece, Gerry...

Regds,

niece

Gerry

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

niece, thank you for your very understanding comments...

Gerry xxx.

RDLarson

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

What a generous man you are. We all seem to be so connected even those who are "at war" and those who are "at peace." Every one of us has the basic human needs and we all want to have friends and families. A belief in a higher power is as old as humanity. I don't think science and religion are opposites. I do think people who deny their human frailties and survive on their egos will hurt themselves or be hurt. People do need to be kind and good to each other. The watchmaker watches.

juliet

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

I've been grappling with the idea of faith and belief because recently i lost someone dear to me and my family. The catholic priest in his funeral sermon said without faith then there is no comfort in death, and i know that his children found great comfort in the belief that he had to go on a mission for God. I want to believe that he has not gone that he is somewhere around us, and i don't mean in our hearts and memories etc, but out there, yet my brain tells me this cannot be the case. i think fear of death is a major reason why people need religion and belief otherwise life can seem meaningless, hopeless even. Is this all there is?

thank you for sharing your thoughts and i agree with the above posts you come across a thorougly decent person.

Jolen

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Gerry, what a wonderful article and you brought it to life without preaching or pretense... I for one can appreciate that greatly... This was a very interesting and informative piece of work and that too is all good. I have been to 'church' that are buildings and I have worshiped in the woods and by the rivers and sea. To me the world is a church and we are always with our 'god,' whatever we perceive that to be.

Thank you for reposting this here.

blessings,

Jolen

jody

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

This piece was done with finesse, a thoughtful work. Although we may not be on the same page with some of our beliefs, you have stated some fundamental truths here: that true spirituality has little to nothing to do with dogma. Cathedrals and lovely churches are wonderful places to get away to.... the art work is inspiring, the music is wonderful, the calm is also welcome. You worked within the scientific sector ... then you must know that the cathedrals in Europe were essentially built with performing music in mind. As I understand it, the architectural rules for the buildings and the mathematical rules for the sacred music relied upon one another. In ages when most people did not own books, perhaps could not read, and certainly did not have access to music on demand, cathedrals served as places to learn, listen and see imagery that inspired them. But don't you think that the beauty in constructions and the appreciation for what goes on inside of them is something that appeals to a distinct sector of the population? Hmm, what do I mean by that? Well, churches are not needed to 'teach' us about religion through iconography - we aill can read about it. And if we wish to listen to Verdi, Mozart, et al, we can simply turn on our personal music devices (although nothing compares to hearing Bach's Fugue on a big pipe organ...).

Your essay put me in mind of Stephen Jay Gould, who is sadly, deceased. He did more to reconcile religion with science than anyone before him.

If you don't know of his work, I highly recommend it.

Thank you for posting this here. As I am new on this site, I haven't figured out how to work it all yet and I might not have found this essay.

peace-

jody

Easyd

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Good piece as always Gerry. I too started out with a conventional Christian upbringing – I recall thinking with fervour as a schoolboy, reading of priests tortured in Communist Eastern Europe, that I would resist under torture etc. But later with a scientific education despite myself doubts did blossom, certainly for the orthodox church religions. Your list of questions should include ‘Do you go to experience mystical union with an extra-mundane reality?’ But if it was from one of the standard rags of course you would only see the sort of cynical questions you list. Nowadays I hardly ever go to church but still consider myself religious in the personal sense. In the book I’m working on (see intro and contents this Friday here, I hope) I have a bit where I criticise the tendency of ‘quality’ journalists to wheel out the old cavil, every Easter, of a ‘ God centre in the brain’ as if this showed it all to be an illusion. As I point out in the book, this is rubbish as when an area of our brain is stimulated by the image of a vase or a cat, does this show the vase or cat to be an illusion? On the contrary, such a ‘God centre’ is indicate of an extra-mundane or subtle realm populated with mystic entities that have been so much a part of man’s perception down the ages that evolution has provided us with the means to perceive this subtle realm as much as to smell, hear or see danger, food or beauty in the ‘real’ world. Reading Deepak Chopra’s ‘Life after Death’ at he mo and he talks of the Vedas and the view of subtle layers of reality. This sort of talk is of course anathema to the numbskulls of the quality press.

Gerry

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Hugh, sorry late replying, just returned from Scotland.

If everyone thought the same as me there would be no trouble in the world ;-)

Thank you for your comments, always interesting to read them.

Gerry.

Easyd

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Thanks Gerry and congrats again on a wonderful piece. I wish I had more time to devote to writing - this free energy lark is sapping a lot of my attention: watch for Stoern on Spril 1st: , we shall see if this is the greatest joke since Bob Hope or a turn up for the books.

walters

This religious thing. Does it bother you?

Gerry, I really look forward to going to church with you as I'm sure the experience would be most entertaining! I myself like the pomp of the Catholic Church, and am glad to here that its reactionary pope is taking up Latin again. I recall a Latin American priest who said he was an atheist but remained a priest because he loved the Church so much - perhaps he will be canonized one day. As for those who do believe, they fall into different faiths by chance of birth if not by choice, and I do not blame people for keeping the faith of their credulous childhood. Mary Queen of Scots made a great deal of sense to me when an effort was made to convert her immediately before her decapitation, and she said she was born a Catholic and would forever remain one.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…