From the UKAuthors Collection

A History Lesson

By Ionicus · Originally published 26 May 2006

Do we ever learn?

Does it really matter
if Alfred burnt the cakes?
We all have to learn
from our mistakes,
we are told.
I beg to disagree,
if I may be so bold.
History has a habit
of repeating itself.
And if proof is needed,
there is a stack of volumes
lined up on the shelf
reminding us,
to our eternal shame,
that we tend to ignore
the errors of the past.
One particular incident
should illustrate
the crux of my argument.
Napoleon marched on Russia
in winter - of all seasons.
He got a cool reception
and was forced to stop.
For no apparent reasons,
Hitler tried the same
but from its inception
the venture was destined
to be a total flop.
Though we may be tempted
to steal somebody’s thunder
we must always remember
not to repeat his blunder.

© Luigi Pagano 2006

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Romany

A History Lesson

No we don't learn from history Luigi, though I have to say that in the case of Hitler, it's not always a bad thing!

Romany.

Romany

A History Lesson

Ah, but what a lovely old cynic you are!

I think it's arrogance, isn't it? The old human failing, the 'It'll never happen to me/us' attitude? You only have to look at the world today, God help us.

Romany.

Abel

A History Lesson

I think it is because we think we are invincible...that nothing bad can happen when things are going well. We believe our own press, as it were. Luigi, you are a wise man.

Best,

Ward

Sunken

A History Lesson

You would make a wonderful teacher young Ionicus. I hope that this comment finds you in positions relative to spanking... Oh no, that's not allowed these days is it? What a shame. It never did me any harm... I know what you're thinking!

s

u

n

k

e

n

in charge of shuttlecocks

Poet

A History Lesson

This is one for the ages to peruse...though there will be sure to be some who still tend to confuse...they're not my problem though as they are everyone's problem. First rate work here!

Lare

A History Lesson

Hi Luigi...looking back, we don't just have to look at history to learn our lessons in life...as the old saying goes..."Hind sight is the best foresight"...or...something like that.

In any case this is very well constructed...very well done...good to see you again, my friend...

Lare

Jay

A History Lesson

Very wise Luigi, using timeless examples.

We all learn by our own mistakes... arguably there are only so many mistakes one can make... they are bound to be repeated perhaps.

My grandma always said I'll let you learn by your own mistakes. You have to. She was right. What we experience ourselves is no match for advice, no matter how worldly.

Well thats my little input. :)

great write L.

Jenn. x

Jolen

A History Lesson

Clever wisdom here. The metering and rhyme are both delightful.

blessings,

Jolen

sledge

A History Lesson

It seems that the BNP doubled its showing in the recent council elections.

Hitler, 6 million Jews. Nick Griffin, 44 council seats.

You're dead right Ionicus. We'll go on repeating mistakes.

Thanks for a fine poem, and greetings from another old cynic.

Terry

Jen_Christabel

A History Lesson

Being a historian, I can honestly say that no, we never learn from past mistakes. Although we try to rectify them - imperialism being one thing I am always banging on about!

Good piece.

Jennifer :o)

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…