From the UKAuthors Collection
In the Winter
By sirat · Originally published 27 January 2006
This is my contribution to Claire's challenge. It's based on the Janis Ian song of the same name.
“That woman’s staring at you Peter. Do you know her?”
“Yes. God, this is embarrassing!”
“From your sordid past?”
“To be honest, yes.”
“Hardly your type.”
“Oh no, I think she’s coming over.”
“Don’t let me get in your way. I’ll be at the perfume counter.”
“Stay Miriam, please. I may need to be rescued.”
“Shush. She’ll hear”
“Leanne? Imagine running into you! How are you?”
“I thought it was you, Peter. You look so young! I don’t know what to say.”
“Go on. Give him a hug. I know you want to. I won’t be jealous.”
“This is Miriam. She’s… well, we did the husband and wife thing a couple of years back.”
“The husband and wife thing? Hello Miriam. You look fantastic. Are you one of Peter’s film stars?”
“My film stars! Funniest thing I’ve heard all day. I’m just a back-room technician. Film stars don’t even give me their autographs.”
“That’s not true, Lianne. Peter has directed four films. Not commercial crap, real films.”
“I’m the referee who tries to keep the creative people from each other's throats long enough for a film to get made. And the one they blame if it’s a turkey. But you know about that, don’t you Leanne? Leanne was the first actress I ever directed.”
“Peter and I studied together. We made a short film as part of our course.”
“I know you have things to talk about so I’m going to the perfume counter and Peter can come and find me when he’s ready. Nice to have met you.”
“No, please don’t leave…”
“Let her go, Leanne. There’s no problem. We trust each other. Let me look at you...”
“I look terrible, I’ve been ill…”
“Nonsense, you look great. Are you working?”
“No. Please don’t ask me about it.”
“I suppose you got married…”
“Yes… No, I never got married.”
“So… are you on your own?”
“Peter, that summer… was all I ever had. Don’t look at me like that, I don’t want pity, I’m just telling you the truth. I think there’s something wrong with me. I can’t… disconnect like other people.”
“There’s nothing wrong with you! We just weren’t right for each other. You can’t mean that you’ve never moved on from then? We were children, Lianne. We were twenty years old.”
“I know. I said there was something wrong…”
“Please don’t get upset. God, I wish we had stayed together longer because then you would have seen how absolutely ordinary I am. Look at all these people milling around in this store. Do you think I’m different to them? Do you think I’m something special?”
“Yes, Peter. Just like you think Miriam is special.”
“Leanne, we both have beautiful memories of that summer, but it’s over now. It’s been over for a very long time. Nothing’s going to bring it back. We’re only allowed one take.”
“You’re right. The summer is over and it’s winter now. Goodbye, film director. Miriam is beautiful. Don’t keep her waiting.”
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
In the Winter
Hi David,
Not sure this works as a stream of dialogue - there was a lot to get in for 500 words so I'm not sure how else you could have tackled this, but I got confused between the voices at points here and couldn't tell them apart. Maybe work on making them more distinct? And I didn't get a feeling of the relationship between Peter and Miriam to counterbalance the later conversation. As I say, maybe you tried to fit too much in for 500 words.
In the Winter
I found their words to each other too 'unhesitant' I don't believe someone would launch straight in at that emotional depth, so I was not convinced. and the 'husband and wife thing' and 'we trust each other' is laying it on a bit thick, IMO.
I too was confused as to who was speaking. I don't know the song.
Overall I found the dialogue stiff andd stilted. And the story was really telly! I suppose it would have to be (mine is a monologue :-) ) but I just noticed it in yours (whereas I didn't in Claire's because of the indirect way some of it was expressed).
I think a much more tender and understated theme would have worked better, to be honest, and I know you have the ability to write like that when you choose.
as I said to Claire, Mr Grumpy today, sorry! G
In the Winter
Hi there hun,
Never heard of the song. Had a wee listen, and yes you have the storyline spot on. With there being three people the speech doesn't work that well on it's own. It could be cut to just the two, and have the ex mention that she's seen them together a few times.
I would have tackled this one different though. I would change the POV to the ex. Have a wee bit where she's watching them shopping, they hold hands kiss etc. She waits till he's alone and the pounces on him, will chats to him. And of course I'd have to have some wee mental thoughts slipped in here and there.
In the Winter
Yes, I think that change of POV and limiting it to two is a very good idea. I think the song is really heart-stoppingly poignant, and it was the emotional content that I was trying to transplant into the story: the girl's distress and the total emptiness of her life, especially when compared to his, and what she would have felt at seeing the object of her obsession with his stunningly beautiful new wife. It's all in the song and it isn't in the story - maybe Janis Ian is marginally better at this sort of thing than I am? No, I'm sure that's not it...
In the Winter
An interesting excerise. What might be useful is to see in a post-article what minimal speech tagging would be useful to make this stream work. Personally, I love writing and rteading dialogue more than anything else.
My constructive comment is that by ommitting the speech tags (which was presumably the task?) meant you were forced into putting the characters into the dialogue more than would be expected in a real-life scenario. Would these same pointers to characters end up in speech tags?
Good excercise, I got lost only on one line (where I corrected myself before continuing). Out of curiousity it was on the line beginning: “My film stars! Funniest thing I’ve heard all day..." And I got stumpted because the voice did not fit with the character in my mind at that moment in time.
Keep that wagon rolling, rolling, rolling...
Wirlong.
In the Winter
Perhaps I'm unusual here, because I could sing (badly)..."You have a lovely wife...and in the winter, extra blankets for the cold, fix the heater..." It's one of the best songs on an absolutely classic album, along with "Tea and Sympathy", "At 17", "Light a Light"...possibly my favourite album by anyone ever, which is why the title caught my eye.
Anyway - you certainly caught the essence of the story, but that wretched word limit hamstrung you, as you've said. It needed filling, a bit of life, and with more breathing space you could have made the whole thing possibly more hesitant and realistic. I'm quite convinced that you could have, without those artificial restrictions. Perhaps a mark two version might be in the pipeline? Given the inspiration, it's worth doing well - I see no reason why you shouldn't do an excellent job.
In the Winter
Sorry - it's only me again...I didn't actually mention the album's name, did I? "Between the Lines" dates from 1975. I agree, "At 17" possibly was written earlier, but I don't know of another outing for it before this album, which is a normal mainstream issue. I have the CD (1993) but somewhere in the loft I also have the vinyl from the 70s. So, if anyone wants to know, that's the one!
In the Winter
Maybe you don't like flash, but I thought this was a commanding vignette of a terribly awkward moment. The tension in who is the victim/main character here is the choice for the point of view. Who has the most to lose if the ex shows up? Will it save someone or break some one? The fact is lives can be lost in five hundred words, and hearts can be broken. It's a really difficult exercise but your theme has great merit. I can run it in my mind like a movie -- a 30 second commercial for clean breath? OK, but it does have a deja vue poignancy to it that many people would recognise. Good job, even (I think) especially since you do not care for flash.
In the Winter
Hi Sirat
I thought I'd commented on this! Hmmm. Our internet kept going down at work yesterday so maybe it got lost.
I didn't find it too hard going knowing who was speaking and didn't mind the fact it was all dialogue. The only thing I had issues with was that the conversation didn't seem realistic. That's totally down to the <500 word limit, I know. I'd have cut the new partner out altogether and just had two old loves meeting in some real mundane way, like in the supermarket. I can't listen to the song at work today so might be coming up with options that wouldn't work. Anyway, it'd be nice if boring normality carried on around them while they were lost in their little bubble of memories. They'd both go back to their mundane little lives, parting company in the loo-roll aisle or somat and wonder what might have been. Anyway, I liked the fact you wrote it as just dialogue. Always good to try something a bit different! Looking forward to the next one...! Take care. Hazy x
In the Winter
I dont know the song but this is a good bit of writing. Will check it out now though!
Jay.