From the UKAuthors Collection

Hic Sunt Dracones

By sirat · Originally published 13 January 2006

Some members of the Storyshed group have decided to submit stories on a common
theme. This is my contribution.
=======================================

Tanin followed George into the doctor’s office. While George took his customary seat in front of Dr. Hobart's desk, Tanin curled himself up comfortably in front of the grey filing cabinets that lined the rear of the room. Tanin looked at George with his characteristic quizzical, intelligent expression and waited for the session to begin. George looked at Dr. Hobart and waited just as expectantly.

"How have you been, George?” the doctor beamed.

“I’ve been very well, thank you Sir.”

“We've had several of these little sessions now, haven't we? How would you describe them?”

“They're okay, Doctor. I enjoy them.” This reply made Tanin smile but not Dr Hobart.

“And do you get anything more than enjoyment out of them?”

George considered the question. “I don’t think so.”

Hobart stood up and raised his right hand as though to toy with a nonexistent beard. He started to walk very slowly towards the large window. Tanin casually flicked his tail out of the doctor’s path. “How old are you now, George?” he asked.

“I’ll be eleven in May, Sir.”

“You’ll be going up to the big school, won’t you? The Comprehensive.”

George nodded.

“What do you feel about that?"

"It's okay."

"How do you think... people will see you there?"

George looked puzzled. "With their eyes, I suppose."

Hobart suppressed a smile. "What I mean is... well, it's a more grown-up school, isn't it? Do you have any concerns that they might see some things about you as a bit... inappropriate for your age?" He glanced at George's face and decided that he wasn't getting through. "Take me for example. I'm forty-six. I suppose you would consider that very old?

“No, Sir. Tanin is two hundred and thirty.”

Hobart ignored this. “Now, if I were to put on short trousers and go to that park across the road and play on one of the swings, people would think it rather odd, wouldn’t they?”

George considered the question. “They probably would, Sir. And yet when soldiers with guns come along and kill hundreds of people they don’t seem to think it’s odd at all. Isn’t that strange, Sir?”

Hobart scowled. Tanin nodded approvingly. There was a pause.

“I’m going to talk to you like an adult today,” Hobart announced. “I shouldn't do this but the other approach just isn't getting us anywhere. I'm going to tell you what I really think, as one person to another.” He returned to his desk. “I don’t believe that you're suffering from any form of delusional illness whatsoever. I believe that you are a highly intelligent boy who is perfectly well able to distinguish between reality and fantasy. You know what is real and what is not and yet you choose to deny it. Am I right?”

“That I deny knowing the difference between reality and fantasy? No, that’s wrong. I do know the difference.”

“George,” he was beginning to sound exasperated, “I mean that you won’t admit that Tanin is in your imagination. Not anywhere else. Not part of the real world. That is what you refuse to admit.”

“But that isn’t true. Tanin is real.”

Hobart took on his avuncular persona and smiled at George. “I am not saying that you are refusing to admit this for no reason. I think you have perfectly good reasons for keeping up this fiction. I think that Tanin represents something for you and I want to find out what that something is. You probably don’t even know what it is yourself, you probably don’t know what’s really going on in your mind, but that’s okay. My job is to find out, that’s what I’m paid for.” He paused and studied the boy’s expression of rapt attention. “I can’t help thinking about your name,” he said at last, “George. Do you know about the legend of George and the dragon?”

“A little. I don’t know the whole story.”

“George killed the dragon. It represented everything that was horrible and evil and terrifying to George. Dragons often represent evil. Is that what Tanin represents for you? Something that’s bad, that you have to struggle with, to overcome?” There was another pause.

“No, Sir. Tanin is good. He doesn’t represent anything. He’s just Tanin.”

"Alright. You say that you have these conversations with Tanin. Have you asked him why he’s here?”

“Yes, Sir. It’s because he’s very young. Two hundred and thirty is very young for a dragon and he still has a lot to learn before he becomes wise enough to live with the other dragons. Now this is the bit that I find hard to understand, but he says that to become wise you must be able to distinguish between wisdom and folly, and he’s come here to experience folly. It seems all the baby dragons come here to see folly. It’s the very best place to see it. They’ve been coming since time began, and it’s not just me that’s seen them. Every civilization that has ever existed on earth has seen dragons. They haven’t understood them, but they’ve seen them, and they’ve made up stories about them.”

The doctor stared at George before writing something on the papers on his desk.

“Have you read a lot about dragons, George? Have you looked them up on the Internet?”

“No. If there’s anything I want to know about dragons I ask Tanin.”

“And he tells you?”

“Not always. There are some things he isn’t allowed to tell me, and some things that I just wouldn’t understand.”

“Alright. Let me ask you a few things about dragons. Perfectly straightforward things. First thing, why can’t anybody else see Tanin except you?”

“Because he doesn’t want them to. You don’t see dragons unless they want you to see them.”

“So… they can do magic?”

“Oh yes. Lots of magic.”

“What kind of things. Tell me about it.”

“Well, I’m not sure. I think they can do almost anything. Is that right, Tanin?” Dr Hobart flinched as George looked past him and nodded his acknowledgement of Tanin’s reply. “He says he can do anything that is in harmony with nature.”

“What does that mean? Anything that isn’t a miracle?” With a nod George referred the question back to Tanin, who had much more to say this time.

“He says that you wouldn’t understand the answer. He says that mankind knows only how to break the things of nature and take them apart, the harmony of nature is beyond our understanding.”

Hobart didn’t reply at once. “This is… a very convincing hallucination. I can see that. Let me ask you something. I mean, let me ask Tanin something.”

“He’s listening.”

“I want to know… if our lives are mapped out for us in advance. If we go through the world like wind-up toys, doing what our genes tell us to do, pushed here and there by the things we bump into, until our clockwork runs down and we stop moving. Or is there something more? Is there something… inside of us… that can change the direction of our travel? Something that stands above it all and decides what it will allow to happen, like the captain of a ship? Can Tanin answer that for me?”

There was a brief pause. “Tanin says that to ask that question is also to answer it.”

Hobart slowly turned and stared at the space between his desk and the filing cabinets. He reached into his inside pocket for a pair of glasses and put them on. “How big is Tanin?” he asked quietly.

“Well, he’s a bit curled up right now, but he’s about as long as this room.”

The doctor studied the empty space, moving his head slowly back and forth to do so.

“Why doesn’t he… Why don’t you allow anybody else to see you?”

“He says most people couldn’t take it. Especially adults. They would go mad.”

The doctor turned around and replaced his glasses in his pocket. He smiled nervously. “Has Tanin done any magic for you?” he asked.

“Oh yes. Mum and Dad were having awful rows just before he came. I asked him to make it okay between them again and he did. They’re fine now.”

Hobart’s face lit up. “I see. You needed somebody who could do magic and somebody came. Doesn’t that tell you anything? Can’t you see the significance of that?”

“You mean, that I was very lucky?”

“No. More than luck. You needed to believe that somebody… some power… was able to help you. You needed Tanin, or somebody like him. It’s very very simple. You needed him, and so your mind created him. Can’t you see that? It’s a classical case. Absolutely classical.”

“You still think he’s just pretend? You’re wrong Doctor. Tanin is real. He can help people, if they ask him, and if it’s okay with nature… and maybe a few other things have to be right, I don’t know. He’ll do magic for you. If you don’t believe me, why don’t you ask him? You will, Tanin, won’t you?” George paused. “Yes. Tanin says he’ll do magic for you if he can, and if it’s right—with nature and all that. Just one thing. One magic thing. What do you want him to do, Dr Hobart?”

The doctor smiled. “What do I want him to do? It’s funny, I’m usually the one asking the questions. I thought if you told anybody what your wish was it wouldn’t come true.”

“You don’t have to tell anybody out loud. Just think your wish. Tanin will be able to hear.”

Hobart smiled. “George, I’ve been very naughty today, do you know that? I’ve broken all the rules. I’ve played along with you as if everything you said was true, then I've loaded my own interpretations on to you, which is a big no-no too, I've got into confrontations about what's real and what isn't... all very unprofessional. But the truth is, I like you. You're more than just a patient to me. And I've never seen a show quite as convincing as the one you put on. But what you’re saying isn’t true. We both know that, don’t we? There aren’t any dragons, and there isn’t any magic. There’s just you and me, sitting in an office and indulging in a little make-believe. There’s nothing wrong with that. It doesn’t hurt anybody. But if you start thinking it’s real, if you can’t tell the difference between imagination and reality, then it can do harm. It can do a great deal of harm. We can’t go on with this, George. We’ve got to face up to the truth. We’ve got to hold on to that distinction between what’s real… and what we would like to be real. Haven’t we?”

George looked Hobart straight in the eye. “I think I know what you wished for,” he said in a voice that was little more than a whisper.

“You don’t. You couldn’t.”

“You’re a bad man Dr Hobart and you shouldn’t be allowed to be with children on your own.”

The blood drained from Hobart’s face and he froze in his chair. George stood up. “One wish,” he said. “You could have had almost anything in the world and that was all you could think of. I’m sorry for you, Dr Hobart. You’re a messed-up person.” He opened the door of the office, stood back to allow Tanin to leave, then followed, closing the door gently behind him.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Some very deft writing here, keeping the dragon alive for us even though only person in the room can see it!

Have to say the ending didn't work for me at all. For me, it took the story off in another direction entirely and changed the focus from the relationship between the boy and his dragon to a 'brush with abuse' issue which didn't ring true. If he wanted to abuse the boy, wouldn't he use the apparently imaginary dragon in his favour? Instead of saying 'let's stop pretending', surely he'd say, 'let's pretend that' and incorporate the dragon as a lever against the boy? I wasn't sure initially whether we were talking about a wish he hasn't really acknowedged to himself or something he actually does, and I felt that piece of knowledge should be very plain. I had to reread three times before I decided that the psychiatrist was trying to fight those feelings.

Could just be me not picking up on the subtler points, but really, I felt that the ending didn't resolve the issue you'd set up at the beginning of the story, which was the nature of the dragon (at least for me!) As I say, there's nothing wrong with the writing. Just the final direction of the story didn't work for me - might work for others, I'd imagine.

Ginger

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

I thought this was written beautifully. The relationship between the boy, the dragon and the psychiatrist was very well done.

A couple of niggles - my daughter is about to turn 11, and will start senior school in September, so unless he's been held back a year, he should be turning 11 in May. I also have to say the ending didn't gel for me either, seemed out of place in the tale. Maybe that was the point? Or was his wish to see Tanin?

e-griff

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

yes, chiming in - a well written, well constructed story, but for me the ending 1. didn't work practically (when did he make the wish - it was not apparent) 2. I think the paedophile element (presumably) was something of a weak get-out. IMO the depth and tenor of the story demanded something of equal weight to resolve it.

Michel

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

I like the unexpected, interesting and strong storyline in the ending very much, but not the bit where the psychiatrist staggers and splutters, which seemed to make him more unaware of himself than I'd thought at first he was - “The dragons are inside our heads,” he spluttered, even though there was nobody there to hear, “just inside our heads. Nowhere else…” - and this seems to spell it out, which weakened the ending - and slowed it - a great deal:There was little conviction behind his words.

I thought you should cut after this: closing the door gently behind him.

or after this: As he did this an unbearable stench of burning pitch suddenly filled Hobart’s lungs and he staggered across the room to open the window.

But I think 'As the door closed' might work better than 'As he did this' which is a bit awkward, I think - however, you've already mentioned 'door', making it perfectly clear, so I think you could perhaps just jump from 'behind him.' to 'An unbearable stench'?

sirat

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Well, there's a great deal to reply on there. Taking Ailsa (Bluepootle's) comments first, as usual for me the last thing I wanted to do was resolve the issue of the dragon's status - whether real or not. I always aim at making a story open to more than one interpretation. I would feel I had messed up badly if that was fully resolved. Much the same applies to giving the psychiatrist plain criminal intentions in what to me would be a heavy-handed sort of way. Tanin (or was it George?) had been able to look into his soul, had seen his unacknowledged and half-formed intentions and desires. The "wish" could have been something that had merely flickered across his mind, perhaps he had been unaware of it himself until the moment he "froze in his chair". The notion that the psychiatrist was trying to fight these feelings was exactly what I had in mind. I had already tried to suggest that the psychiatrist had issues about guilt. The question about free will and determination that he asked Tanin is a classical philosopical conundrum, the one that Martin Luther wrestled with in the sixteenth century - are we free or do we merely THINK we are free? If we are like wind-up toys then moral choice is an illusion, we are not to be blamed for anything we do. Is this what is meant by God's forviveness? Should I be less hard on myself, as I am really nothing more than a mechanism without control of its actions? And of course the answer the psychiatrist gets is not the one he wants and it makes him very uncomfortanble. But the psychiatrist doesn't want to believe in the dragon (you can let the dragon stand for God or religion here if you like) so we're really getting a glimpse of an inner turmoil of his own. And I think this is the kind of question that would be likely to disturb a thoughtful psychiatrist.

Now the ending, which I think satisfied almost nobody. I'm tempted to say: "We only had a couple of weeks to write this and it was the best I could come up with", and there's a grain of truth in that, but it isn't really an excuse! The story remained without an ending for most of the alotted time, the ending was the difficult bit, and if the "special rules" hadn't applied in Storyshed I would probably have asked for help with it. Anyway, what I was trying to suggest was that George's words had produced a crisis for the psychiatrist. Thery had forced him to face up to something he hated about himself and for which he could not forgive himself: his sexual attraction towards children. When he says that "Dragons are just inside out heads, nowhere else" at the end he's using "dragons" in the sense in which he had explained their symbolism himself earlier - evil, hateful things that you have to struggle with to overcome - and tryint to reassure himself that they are inside his head, nowhere else. In other words that he would never act on these feelings. And I don't think I have to spell out why he smells the burning pitch and has to stagger to the window.

Well, that's a lot more "author intent" than I would normally reveal, because I can see that this one isn't really perfect and may need a major re-write.

Many thanks to everyone who has commented, including the more detailed points of style, language etc. which will be extremely useful when I come to re-do it. Not being too negative, thanks also to the people who liked aspects of it.

Claire

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Now I enjoyed this... unlike the others I thought the ending was okay but as Michel said the last two bits should be cut, ending with 'closing the door gently behind him.'

As for Hobart being a dirty old man... yes it takes the story to a new place, deffo not expected and it's shocking... which is why I liked the ending. It certainly wasn't a boring plain ending.

Harry

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

A very fine piece of writing, sirat. The conversation is handled brilliantly, the psychological jargon put in its proper place. From my own humble point of view I'd stop it at "closed the door gently behind him."

sirat

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Many thanks Claire and Harry. I think it's almost unanimous, the last two mini-paragraphs have to go. I'll leave them there just a little longer in case anybody disagrees, then they go to the big recycle bin in the sky.

e-griff

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

This may or may not work. How about you leave out the paedophilia? Forgive my intrusion but I'd like to illustrate my thinking with a small rewrite. I wouldn't regard this as final, BTW

George looked Hobart straight in the eye. “I know what you just wished for,” he said in a voice that was little more than a whisper.

“You don’t. You couldn’t.”

“You’re a bad man Dr Hobart.”

The blood drained from Hobart’s face and he froze in his chair. George stood up. “One wish,” he said. “You could have had almost anything in the world and that was all you could think of. I’m sorry for you, Dr Hobart.” He opened the door of the office, stood back to allow Tanin to leave, then followed, closing the door gently behind him.

that gets us guessing, dunnit? just a suggestion? G

bluepootle

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Griff's just written down exactly what I've been thinking - from my point of view, much stronger if we're left to guess. I would add something about the boy and the dragon's unity in that last para though...to put the emphasis back on them and give a gd ending point.

sirat

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Hello Claire and John. Thanks for the return visit. I think if you leave it unclear what it was that Hobart wished for and why he was "a bad man" you lose the ambiguity as to whether Tanin is real (and a mind-reader) or whether George is just very intuitive and has guessed Hobart's guilty secret. He could easily shrug off George's claim to know what the wish was if George didn't give any indication beyond his opinion that Hobart was bad. The revalation wouldn't affect him so deeply. You would also have less insight into Hobart's character and motivations. I suppose I see it as a story about Hobart as much as it is about George and his dragon. I don't really want to take the focus away from Hobart again at the end. He is the one with the inner demons, not the boy. As to "the boy and the dragon's unity", do you mean I should suggest that they are one person, that the dragon only exists in the boy's mind? If so, that is something I certainly don't want to do. I have been ultra-careful throughout not to come down firmly on either side the reality of the dragon, I certainly don't want to do it here. So to be honest, the chasnge that appeals to me most at the moment is to cut out those last two paragraphs and end at: "closing the door gently behind him". Many thanks for the suggestions though.

e-griff

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

OK David. Then how about not just flinging it in at the end as a fait accompli 'tell' , but putting some pointes in along the way so we get the picture, then doing what I suggested. For me, it would be subtler, and suit the majority of this story, in which the writing leads us along and makes us guess.

Ginger

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

I am a great fan of ambiguity, and I attempt this in many of my short stories. I would not like to see it disappear. I hadn't clicked with the dragon comment at the end, makes it all a bit deeper.

sirat

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Thanks for coming back with that, Ginger. I'm in two minds about it myself now. All that the last two paragraphs really do is reinforce a notion about Hobart's inner mental state which may have been made clear enough anyway by that stage. They also seem to produce a feeling of confusion and untidiness for a lot of people. I think common sense says they should go. I'll leave them until tomorrow in the hope that I can harvest more opinions about them. Thanks again.

RichardZ

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

I'm not convinced it needs a major rewrite David. The pedophiliac ending seems slightly out of place, if for no other reason than it takes the focus off the dragon and boy. In that respect it feels out of place.

I'd suggest either an alternate ending, or more clues leading up to the existing ending.

At the moment, you lead us down one path, only to take a sharp turn toward the end which jars slightly. If there were more clues, perhaps from the Doctor's POV, the ending might sit better.

Apart from that, it's the same tight work I've come to expect.

Still a very readable and enjoyable tale regardless.

jay12

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

I enjoyed this read all the way through. I think it is very well written and edited David. The ending didn't jar to me but was unexpected. It didn't seem tacked on but I feel you could have done more with it and not simply had the doctor wanting to abuse him and then being found out by the dragon who could read minds. Maybe the dragon refused to tell him straight away, then the doctors actions leave him no choice but to tell him, then the tension can really be built up.

Still a sudden and unexpected ending isn't a bad thing at all. I think you spoil us with such satisfying endings in your other prose we always expect you to blow us away with a marvellous ending or twist. This aint got that, but it does have some impact.

Regards,

James.

Jen_Christabel

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

I found this intriguing and read it a few times to 'feel' the depth. There are so many layers, as it were, to this story, and multiple reads, I believe, reveals this.

Cracking story Sirat.

Jen :o)

sirat

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Many thanks Jen. A great compliment.

OolonColoophid

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

OolonColoophid

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Hi David

Apologies if my points repeat was has been said above, but I try not to read other comments before posting.

- I liked the story overall.

-The arrangement of characters in the first couple of paragraphs threw me for some reason. I had to re-read them, but that could just be me. Possibly because Tanin is gender- and age-neutral, I assumed it was the boy's parent...anyway, went up a blind alley.

- The name 'Tanin' jarred a bit, but I appreciate that might be deliberate. Something significant about naming him after a chemical compound? (This might only be a problem because I'm drinking tea right now!)

- Behaviour of the therapist was slightly odd. You explained this as playing make believe after lots of sessions where other techniques may not have worked, and, of course, he might be a paedophile. But because the latter twist happened at the end, I spent much of the story thinking that you hadn't quite got the demeanour of the psychologist right. Of course, being a psychologist myself, I might have an unusual perspective on this.

- The ending absolutely great. The mythic creature, so divorced from reality, reveals the truth of himself by making a sudden connection with the reality of the therapist. I thought that was excellent, a nice marriage of story and theme.

Cheers,

Ian

sirat

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Hello Ian. Thanks for a true "insider" perspective!

I don't mind if it took you a moment to work out who/what Tanin was. Actually "Tanin" is a traditional dragon's name, not quite the same spelling as "tannin", the informal name for substances that precipitate proteins. If you Google the name you'll find that The King James version of the Old Testament translated both the Hebrew "ten" and "tanin" as "dragon", which is probably where the association comes from. He's in the mythology of Islam too, including the Arabian Nights, and many other places.

I'm concerned that you found Hobart's demeanour wrong. Wrong in what way? More feedback would be very useful

I think you're the most enthusiastic fan of the ending so far. I'm glad somebody likes it!

Many thanks. David.

OolonColoophid

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Hi David

Thanks for clearing up the 'tanin' thing - v interesting...

A bit more on the behaviour of the therapist:

If he's a psychiatrist (a medical doctor with mental illness specialism), then his behaviour might be OK, since I don't know any psychiatrists. If he's a child therapist (probably a psych degree plus PhD, or doctorate in clinical psychology), he would probably go about things a bit dfferently: a colourful, cosy room with nice wallpaper, toys (castle perhaps, for the younger kids, PlayStation for the older ones), and a two-way mirror for the parents to watch through, and to record sessions for later reviewing or discussing with colleagues. He would very rarely impose his interpretations on the child, and would never, I think, compete with him in the manner that this therapist does. He wouldn't attempt to disprove an illusion through rational grounds because tends only to be anatognistic for someone with an irrational belief. Many of his earlier questions are 'closed' questions in that they direct the child towards an answer, e.g. "Are you getting something out of these sessions?" A real psychologist might ask, "How would describe our chats, George?" A real psychologist probably wouldn't suggest that comprehensive children will view George as odd.

Overall, I think you can explain all this away by indicating at the beginning that the therapy isn't working well, or the doctor seems unusually stressed, or something.

Hope that helps. Like I said, it didn't harm the story too much, and I appreciate that you can generate more dramatic power if you heighten the conflict between the two characters.

Best,

Ian

RDLarson

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Well, lots of comments. Being yourself is important as a writer. I think that I have to think about responses and turn them around sometimes edgewise or just not use suggestion if it doesn't fit my own scheme. But I do have to say when I get a consensus of opinion, I usually figure I was too close to the story. A new thing I am learning to is to write a critique of my own stories just as if I were a reader, didn't know the writer, etc.

I love these dragon tails. I like it all. It's very entertaining and of course since it's here in workshop, you must be working on it.

The characters are quite defined. There really only need to be a bit of tweaking, eh?

wirlong

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

I thought this was well constructed. Since the dragon swished his/her tail out of the way of Hobart I'd say because of the point-of-view approach taken that I as a reader had to take it as read that the dragon existed. For me it was a matter of how Hobart would find out and what his reaction would be.

I'm interested to know why you did not choose George as the point-of-view? If he was chosen then I would not have known if the dragon existed which would mean the ending expectancy would be different. If Tanin was POV then this would again open up a different flavour and expenency. If the Dr, we could only have had Tanin's existence by the speech of George, yet another set of expectancies and experiences for me the reader.

Was the POV taken the best?

Well written and highly interesting.

Jo

wirlong

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

I am afraid I disagree. The POV from George is just not truly there in any strength. Like, OolonColoophid the characters at the opening threw me too. In my case it was because there was no obvious POV character. It seemed to be Tanin, then Hobart, and finally, George. But it was never comitted in my reader's mind at any stage in the entire story. clearly things were being said about Tanin and Hobart that I did not think George would be seeing. The piece looks to me like a hybrid of third-person omniscient point of view and objective point of view, and touched ever so lightly upon each character's POV but never settled there. In my mind it was the Doctor's POV I most got into. A further confusion was caused in that I felt the boy's english was too similar to the Doctor's. To emphasise my confusion consider this: are we really expected to believe that George knew the Doctor had previously had a beard? Or in the first paragraph, did George turn his head in his chair to see Tanin's look?

Simply consider the first paragraph to see my confusion. It also carries a dangling modifier. George could have curled himself up. I don't know if Tanin is a dragon even if I can guess. I've also got to work out the geography of the furniture. There's just too much work I as a reader have to do.

The ending was very alarming to me. It hit me like the episode at the end of Stephen King's 'IT' where a girl of 12 (or was it 13) gets involved in a distasteful set of actions with similarly aged boys for no reason that enhances the story. I cannot see the point of the ending really. It seems like a misjudged cop-out. Of course who knows what the Doctor was really thinking.

I can only comment as a reader in as constructive a way as possible. I do not want to be confused by things of a structural natural but challenged by things of a storyline nature--if that makes sense.

I still think there was potential in the writing.

wirlong

e-griff

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

I tend to agree with wirlong, David. If I look very hard and have to guess if the POV is with George or the Doc, Yes, I'd chose George. (only the absence of description of george's facial expression and the presence of Hobart's (who I see smiles a lot :-) would indicate this, nothing more concrete)

But it's marginal. I would tend to lapse into thinking it is a third party narrator, so the points on thereality of the dragon, I think hold true. I can see the logic. However, it IS and easy problem to solve by letting us see into George's head a bit along the way. G

sirat

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Okay. Thanks to everyone who copmmented, especially Ian, Griff and Wirlong who casme back twice to make themselves clearer and offer more help. I've done a major edit and tried hard to take everyone's advice into account. I've made the therapist more explicit about breaking the rules and added a hint of an unprofessional attitude to this particular patient. I've tried to make the POV absolutely explicit, without going to first person narration, and clarified the opening when the boy and dragon walk into the room. I have modified the boy's speech a little bit but I want to suggest that he's a pretty precocious ten-year-old but also extremely literal in how he understands things, as a lot of bright children are. I don't want to make him any more "childish" just to distinguish between his speeches and those of the Doctor. I don't honestly think there is much room for confusion. When he quotes Tanin of course he introduces very sophisticated philosophical concepts which we wouldn't expect him to understand himself. The line "To ask that question is also to answer it" is from Jean-Paul Sartre.

I didn't envisage spending so much time on this one or putting so much thought into smoothing it out. It was just a writing exercise scribbled down at a single sitting. But I'm getting to like it better now. Many thanks for all your help. Much appreciated.

wirlong

Sirat - Storyshed - Hic Sunt Dracones

Well done. A nice job, sirat. I agree with your decisions on keeping the boy intelligent and 'bright'.

As Jean-Paul Sartre once said: "It is only in our decisions that we are important."

I look forward to the next piece of prose.

JK

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…