From the UKAuthors Collection
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
By Gerry · Originally published 10 October 2005
This article is based very strongly on fact.
This was the chance I had been waiting for, to join this exclusive club. Many had tried but few had succeeded. It had come as quite a surprise when the hand delivered envelope had been brought to my door by a private messenger. I had to present myself at the venue at a certain time with my prepared lecture. I would be given a short introductory period, and then it would be straight into the lecture with no interruptions guaranteed. They held over the right to question me at the end if they felt it justified. I had been given a small list of subjects which I could lecture on, I would have preferred to have chosen my own subject but this wasn’t to be.
When I arrived I was taken straight to the podium given a few moments to prepare myself, and then asked to give my introduction. Before starting I looked out and down at the eminent group sat before me, there were perhaps fifty members in the hall I deliberately made contact with a few eyes, and then gave my brief introduction. Two minutes later and without any ado I started my lecture which I hoped fitted in okay with the strict time allowance I had been given.
‘Gentlemen I ask you to consider this—Albert Einstein was quoted as saying “The man who thinks his life is meaningless is not only unhappy but hardly fit for life at all” he also stated that the more life progresses the less room there seems to be for a God. It was of cause Sigmund Freud who taught that God was an illusion. People who deny God though, can offer no explanation for the complex biological design. Darwin tells how he thinks life developed but could not offer any idea how it started. Many people reject God because of the awful suffering they see around them, “How could God allow this to happen?” Many would never believe in God if they met him---they want to live their lives their way without any interference. Still we have to accept that many people keep looking for a purpose and a meaning.
We live in an expanding universe of that there is no doubt. We know then that there had to be a beginning. A beginning of what? would be a good question. Well consider that our Earth would fit into our sun over a million times. That our sun is only one of millions in our galaxy, that it would take light 100,000 years to cross it, that our galaxy is just a minute part of the universe, and each of the other galaxies have billions of stars which are all in order, all in motion. Could this possibly be the result of some huge indiscriminate explosion?
We are led to believe by scientists that everything started with a small dot--a singularity. Well okay but where did this awesome singularity which caused this vast universe come from? I think it was Bernard Lovell who said, “We have to face the problem of a beginning” He went on to state that if the universe had expanded one million millionth part faster our universe would have dispersed by now. He also held that if it had expanded more slowly, then gravitational forces would have caused the universe to collapse early on in its life.
What about this order? I hear you ask, well let us look at the electromagnetic force to start with. If this force was significantly weaker electrons would not be held by the atom with a result that atoms could not then form molecules. On the other hand if this force was just a little stronger electrons would be trapped at the nucleus of the atom. This would mean no chemical reaction, in both cases this means no life. If the electromagnetic force was slightly lower, gravity would be lower, this would result in smaller stars, their internal temperatures would not then be high enough to cause nuclear fusion—the sun would not, and could not shine. If gravity was slightly higher stars including our sun would find their life expectancy greatly reduced. The question then has to be, is this good fortune by design or chance?’
I had to wait quite a long time after my application to the society before I received the invitation to present a talk. I knew the reason for this was to for them to do a detailed background check. I had no problems with that; the problem I had was when I saw the three subjects, which had been selected. The subjects are changed for each new applicant apparently so there is no possibility of lecture by memory. I had three days to prepare.
The first Subject was “On the evolution of the human eye” It did not take me long to dismiss this one. I know that arguments have raged over this subject. I have of course had an interest; it is a fascinating subject. It is also a subject were one could come to disaster very quickly when talking to people who couldn’t be fooled. One would only have to go on the wrong tangent and although the lecture may have been commendable it could fail you miserably. No-- that one was out.
The second subject was “ On the frontal Lobe” Now this was better, there being plenty of scope here. However after a little thought I realised I would just be quoting facts that had been investigated by others over many years; there would be nothing I could add personally, and no matter how good I presented the talk I knew it would not be good enough. I realised that this was (The Stooge) subject and I was grateful that I had spotted it.
The last subject “On Accident or Design” was the one I would go for. This was a subject that had fascinated me for years, and one that I knew I could talk about without any trouble. My memory is poor these days but I knew that plenty of facts were available and the subject offered such scope. The problem was the time limit given for the lecture. It would have to be condensed and the most important bits included. I would not try to influence one way or the other so could not fail on that score.
‘Excuse me for a moment gentlemen’ I had stopped to have a drink of water and to relax for a few seconds. This was perfectly normal and acceptable during a lecture, and I used the short break to gain eye contact with a few more members of the group before continuing
At this point I went quite deeply into a few physics effects. It is not my intention to bore you with theory; however I will give a very simple explanation as it is very important part of the lecture.
I went on to discuss (The strong nuclear force.) Very briefly this force glues protons and neutrons together in the nucleus of the atom. This bonding is responsible for all our elements. It seems that if this force was only two per-cent weaker only hydrogen would exist. If the binding force was slightly stronger no hydrogen would be found. No hydrogen means no water or food, and the sun would not function. I then discussed (The weak nuclear force) this force is critical because it allows our sun to burn at just the correct rate. This controlled burn gives us life; without the force we would incinerate. I then asked my audience (not expecting a reply at this time) if this fine tuning was by accident or design.
Noticing that my amber light was blinking told me that I had just thirty seconds to wind down. I finished bang on the dot.
There was no obvious reaction from the group before me---after a few seconds a gentleman stood up and asked me to relax for a few minutes. This gentleman then went round his colleagues and who were now in small clusters and exchanged words. He then approached me and told me I could have two minutes to describe how I thought my lecture would be received, and then I would be asked some questions. I again took my place on the podium.
‘Gentlemen, I would like to think that my lecture could have been presented anywhere and understood. I deliberately tried to keep it interesting and understandable. I know that you gentlemen are aware that a lecture on this subject could take a whole day and still not cover all the points. It was my intention to raise just a few of the many points – well enough to possibly start a good discussion.’
The guy who seemed to be in charge of proceedings then told me they had just two questions. I was relieved to hear there were to be just two.
‘Here is our first question. What is the significance in the Earth’s distance from the sun?’
After about ten seconds I answered.
‘Gentlemen our earth is just the right size for our existence. If the earth was only slightly larger, gravity would be stronger and hydrogen would collect--being unable to escape the increase in gravity, this factor would render the earth unsuitable for life. If the earth were slightly smaller our life sustaining oxygen would escape and surface water would evaporate. In either scenario life would not be possible. The earth’s distance from the sun is the most amazing thing. Studies of the ratio of the earth’s radius and distance from the sun concluded that human life would not be possible if the earth had been just five per-cent nearer the sun, because of overheating of the earth. If we had been placed just one per-cent further away from the sun, runaway ice covering would have occurred thousands of years ago. The earth also rotates at just the right speed to maintain comfortable temperatures. Were this speed faster or slower the extremes in temperature would mean life was impossible. These factors would appear to have been calculated very carefully.’
‘Thank you and here is our final question. How does the second law of thermo-dynamics fit in here?’
Again I needed a few seconds to reply, they were clearly testing my immediate knowledge. I answered.
‘If you bought a new building and a new car and left both alone. The building would become a ruin and the car a wreck. This law applies to the universe also, but there we see order constantly maintained. The study of entropy or orderliness of our observable universe shows it to be unchanged. Who is maintaining it?’
‘We take that to mean that you are for design then’
I wasn’t expecting this question, and they knew it--all eyes were on me.
I didn’t know what their thoughts were and I certainly wasn’t going to compromise myself anyway, so I answered.
‘Gentlemen I would most definitely have to come down on the side of design. It is my opinion that we are not here through accident.’
‘We wish to thank you for your lecture, please be seated for a while.’
The jury now departed into an adjoining room, and very soon afterwards a charming young lady entered from another door and offered me tea or coffee. Whist drinking my coffee the young lady told me that the decision on my application for membership would take a while, and would be delivered to me privately. She wished me good luck as I left the building a few minutes later.
That lecture took place three weeks ago, and this morning a courier arrived with an envelope, which I had to sign for. It had a very distinguished emblem on the front. There was no mistake where it was from. I haven’t had the courage to open it yet---
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Now there was I thinking you were joining the funny-handshake gang...but this lot sound even more weird! Good start for a film script here, methinks? It's all a bit deep for a Monday morning, and I'm on the side of accident myself - but your arguments are, as ever, cogent and well-presented. It's a good job we don't all think alike, eh? Much to think about here - and a cliff-hanger too! Excellent.
ps There you are - you made the top slot AT LAST!! Break out a bottle of Vimto!
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Roy, I will have to see that to believe it LOL. I am only on a very brief visit to the site to do a quick edit and I spotted a comment. Couldn't resist peeping--wasn't sure how this would go down. ;-) I am just going to the tip to dump some garage debris, then for a run, then maybe I can have a few minutes here. lol. As always thank you for your entertaining comments...
Gerry.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Gerry, a very instructive and enjoyable read. Now you have me wondering what is in the letter. Let me know....please!!!!
Best regards,
Dargo
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
I have a love of the philosophy of science which goes way back, and would have been pleased to be given your subject to talk on. All the ground you covered and a great deal more can be found in Martin Rees' book "Just Six Numbers". You didn't include his conclusion though, which was that this apparent fine tuning of the universe for life could be accounted for in a number of ways: e.g. by the possible existences of many "universes" differing slightly in their physical constants, only a few of which were suitable for life and harboured life. But since we are here that tells us that our particular "universe" is one of the lucky ones. I'm afraid there are two scientific errors that I noticed in what you have said: the first one concerns thermodynamics. The universe as a whole obeys the second law of thermodynamics perfectly as far as we know. It is only in local pockets where energy is available to overcome entropy that order increases or fails to decrease. The steam engine which gets its energy from burning coal is an example of this. The planet earth which gets its energy from fusion reacions in the sun is another. Systems to which energy is added from outside are not subject to the law. It applies only to closed systems. In the universe as a whole entropy (disorder) is indeed increasing steadily and will eventually lead to what cosmologists call "the heat death of the universe" when it becomes copmpletely structureless, all matter being disdtributed with perfect regularity throughout all space. Your second error I admit is implied rather than stated, but you seem to confuse the size of the earth with its distance from the sun. A bigger (heavier?) earth would not necessarily orbit further from the sun, nor would a lighter one orbit closer, unless of course you assumed that each body started out with exactly the same energy of motion. But in general there is no relationship between a planet's size and where it orbits. At least one of the the outermost planets (Pluto) is extremely small and light. You are right that size matters with planets, and also rate of rotation and the other things you mention, but I don't see why hydrogen in the atmosphere should be a problem, unless you mean it would capture too much oxygen (as water). Even then water is breathable (to aquatic creatures) so I think this argument is weak. The truth is that we don't know how finely tuned conditions would need to be for the evolution of life of some kind. We have only one example to go on. If we find living things elsewhere, as I'm sure we will eventually, we'll be able to place a lot more confidence in statements about minimum requirements.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
David. First thank you for your comment.
You will realise that I barely covered the numerous points which could have been included in this lecture. All the points I mentioned 'however briefly' were substantiated by my reference books. It may be because of the brevity of the talk and even more the brevity of this article that my meaning may not have been abundantly clear on some points.
The talk did actually cover more of the working of the universe in some detail. A longish section on RNA and DNA, and how life could have started, and a some other pertinent points. It was not my intention to present a scientific paper here, but just to provide an interesting and easy read.
This article would not have been any good on here had it been longer. IE. I could not have possibly reproduced the whole lecture. As to whether it is accurate or acceptable I leave for others to decide. The lecture was given without much time for preperation
Once again thank you for your response.
Gerry.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Gerry, I hope you’ve opened the envelope by now…I found the lecture very interesting and easy-to-follow(for my small brains). I agree with you, we are not here by accident, it’s too obvious. There is definitely something or someone out there who does these amazing things for you!Regds,niece
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
This subject On Accident or Design fascinates me immensely. Electromagnetic theories too. The Pythagorean theory of elements and worlds spiraling upwards and the Laws of Physics... A very good strory/article Gerry, the flow and ending just perfect.
Nicoxxx.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Nico, yes indeed all the points I touched on are fascinating.
All will be revealed one day :-)
Thank you for the comment and the pick.
Gerry xxx.
PS and the ten. x.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Gerry,
I envy you for having the chance to give a lecture on such an interesting topic. I was going to do my thesis on a very similar topic but was advised against it. Think you have balanced every thing just right. It is very interesting and I would advice you to open the letter and accept your associate membership.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Mala, thank you for reading this and for your encouraging words.
Regards
Gerry.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
I thought you did this extremely well, Gerry. Your subject matter is close to my own heart (as I think you will know.) Here's hoping for the outcome to be satisfying and fruitful for you.
Griffonner
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Griff, Thank you for your understanding--I know you realise it was not an easy subject, as did Mala.
I can assure you that the result was satisfying ;-).
Gerry.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Hi Gerry.
Great piece. You probably guessed I'd like it. Funnily I was just talking to a friend recently about the Anthropic Principle - I reviewed Paul Davies book ' The Accidental Universe' in the
1980's. And the points you raise are those quoted as basis for the strong or the weak A.P. – as you doubtless are aware. But again you’ve shown how well you can popularise these concepts. Though having said that, the term Anthropic Principle is in a sense an attempt to sweep the design implications under the carpet. The favoured version of the principle says that we observe a universe with all these incredible coincidences because we are by definition the winners of a cosmic lottery – the quantum dice had to be thrown umpteen times to get new variations on the laws of nature in different universes (e.g. from quantum many worlds or bubble-sprouting multiverse) until the combination was finally lucky enough – strong, electro-weak and gravitational forces in exactly the right ratio to allow stable galaxies and stars to form, some of which would have planets in the biosphere stable enough over long periods to allow evolution to proceed to intelligent creatures. But reading your piece the thought struck me that never had before: if it’s not God throwing the dice here then who or what? It#s part of the same question raised by Hawking – the equations of relativity and quantum mechanics are well and good, but who said they had to be incorporated in reality or who breathed fire into the equations? Who fleshed out the possibilities? Your’re right as well to have your lecturer avoid the usual evolution of eye example, as e.g. I think it was Humphreys in his book ( ref later) who showed how an eye could in principle evolve from a light sensitive spot on a membrane. Though I haven’t yet seen the proof that natural selection alone would allow that to happen in hundreds of millions of years. So those cosmic coincidences are stronger evidence of at least a divine dice thrower. And I suspect any standard science board would have rejected your lecturer, since this design issue has become so politicised. Maybe the term Anthropic Principle is an attempt to paper over this crack in the anti-design argument.
Regards,
Hugh.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Hugh, Yes I thought this must draw you in.:-)
I had indeed heard of the Cosmic lottery and dice theories.
My ref books told me that the chances of everything being chance were too incredible to even contemplate. Could you ever put all the words of WS into a drum and take them out one by one to make even one sonnet. I think not. But then what do I know ;-) The purpose of the lecture was not necessarily to be overly pedantic. It was to present an intelligent understandable and interesting paper. I realise it could be pulled to pieces and probably would be. I think I got off quite lightly. lol. Thank you for your interesting response.
It is a subject I shall follow with interest.
Gerry.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Hi again Gery,
Let me just come back on this for a Sunday morning cogitation. Funny how things turn out - years ago I wouldn't have thought it, but by chance i got to know one of the few physicists working on the theory of Burkhard Heim (www.heim-theory.com or pages in Wikipedia that I started on Heim and have been edited ad nauseum), which is a form of quatum gravity and for my money the best bet for a Theory of Everything (TOE). Points for: Heim was an eccentric genius and his theory predicts the masses of all sub-atomic particles to great accuracy. Points against: he didn't leave enough notes to fill in gaps in the calcualtions. Anyway, if he's right, then all particle masses are fixed and the forces too. The only free parameters in his theory are h (Planck's constant), G (Grav constant) and c (velocity of light). So the only way to get other universes with different (not so ' lucky' ) states of galaxies, planets etc. is to twiddle h, G or c. But who is leaning back with the instruction booklet tuning the knob on these parameters? Maybe when quantum gravity is further refined it will also fix G and c and maybe even h. Then there would be no multi-worlds but just this, the best of all possible. Makes ya think, eh?
Ciao,
Hugh.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Hugh Thank you for coming back--It is always nice to read what you have to say. I was listening to a live interview with Stephen Hawkin the other day. He doesn't seem to have added anything new re- TOE. but he sure is an interesting guy. It is easy to be classified as a crank if you don't adopt the party line. But who's to say what is right. ;-)
Gerry.
ON ACCIDENT OR DESIGN. (The Lecture)
Good Going, Gerry! I regret however that you did not mention the Krotrons who are maintaining the Works.