From the UKAuthors Collection
Regret
By e-griff · Originally published 26 September 2005
It happens too quickly, too soon... who's to know?
I am so sorry, now that you are gone.
Not in sadness or despair
But for the words we never spoke
When you were here.
I do think often of those days
That sped unheeded past your startled eyes
Unreeling time
You did not have.
I only hope that
While your winter thoughts persisted
There was room
For summer.
And when you left me,
You held fresh flowers in your gaze
And sweet-scented air
Besides.
So, here's a second version (according to Swep)
I think now of the days
That sped unheeded past your startled eyes
Unreeling time
You did not have.
I only hope that
While the winter thoughts persisted
There was some room
For summer.
And when you left me,
You held fresh flowers in your gaze
And supped sweet-scented air
Besides.
version 3:
I think now of the days
That sped unheeded past your startled eyes,
Unwinding time
You did not have.
My only hope is that
Your winter thoughts
Allowed some room
For summer.
And when you left me,
You held fresh flowers in your gaze
And supped sweet-scented air
Besides.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: Regret
What a very touching and beautiful poem. Absolutely beautiful.
You made me cry.
chrissy
Re: Regret
Respect Mr Griff Sir!! Lovely poetry. I love the last stanza. Val x
Re: Regret
thankyou :-)
Re: Regret
thank you Chrissy, I appreciate the thought.
Re: Regret
This makes me want to cry Mr griffy! A lovely poem on lost moments. We have to make the most of each and every day. My hubby always gave people his time, no matter what he had to do. I admire this very much now, yet at the time I resented it. Always say what we mean to say. I have oh so many regrets, too painful to contemplate, so I just remember the miriad of good times and conversations.
I would give it 10 if you would let me.
You are a sensitive soul for sure.
Smiling, whilst crying at the same...bloody easy!
Tai
Re: Regret
John: I would cut the whole first stanza as it embodies sentiments repeated by everyone that has ever lost someone. It strongly prejudices the reader against going any further. That said, the rest is pretty decent, and there is a certain sweetness to the last stanza, for those not critical of sweetness, and I am not. Swep
Re: Regret
thankyou. very interesting. this was initially written in one go, in a 'naive' sense, not a thought-through literary exercise, so I guess that's why it repeats what so many have said before - it IS a strong and familiar feeling, very powerful. The fact it has been said before (many times) - does that make it invalid, less true? I've written whole stories that have been written before in a slightly different form, but if a new set of readers read and appreciate it, that's fine. But if I'm aiming for a 'literate' attempt, then too right, my audience will be educated, will know of all those other attempts in the past, and current fashion to say something 'new'. Most poems that are remembered and studied now are obviously likely to be far better than mine as they have been selected over a long process.
So, if I want to please the knowlegeable poets as well as the man/woman in the street, I should upgrade this along the lines you suggest. Would I lose the sympathy of the m/w-i-t-s by dropping the first verse, hmmm maybe not. I agree the punch is in the later verses.
Thank you for a thought provoking comment, I shall ponder... :-)
Re: Regret
Hello there John,
This is a really good piece, well written.
Enjoyed reading.
Si:-)
Re: Regret
Well done Mr. Griff.
Please prepare yourself for a corny comment -
I'm opting for number 23 from a series of over 200. Here it is....
I bet you've no regrets on subbing this gem.
....
.... isn't it quiet?
Nice one Griff. Eat a vanilla slice.
s
u
n
k
e
n
also available in 100watt
Re: Regret
well, I'd rather it came from the heart.... :-)
Re: Regret
May I 'destroy' your poem just a little?
I think often of those days
That sped unheeded past
Your startled eyes, not in
Sadness or desperation.
Now that you're gone, I
Only hope that while your
Winter thoughts persisted
There was room for summer,
And that you held fresh flowers
In your gaze when you left me,
Supped sweet-scented air besides.
I liked it John.
Nicoletta
Re: Regret
well, for me it is destroy, butthen it's up to others to judge.
The verses are deliberate pauses, breathing spaces before you tumble on to the next thought, as if it is difficult to say/think.
the same with moving 'when you left me' - for me that destroys the sequence/rhythm of the poem that I was intending. However, accepting yours is a valid version, I would say the 'sadness and desperation' is now 'marooned' in your version, and meaningless, so I'd take it out. Then 'now that you're, and 'I only hope that are is too much 'opening' one of those statements is enough, a little poem like this can't carry two in tandem imo. we lose track... :-) so
I think often of those days
That sped unheeded past
Your startled eyes.
Now you are gone.
I only hope that while your
Winter thoughts persisted
There was room for summer,
And when you left me,
you held fresh flowers
In your gaze,
And supped sweet-scented air besides.
or summat...
Re: Regret
Wistful and tender. I like the original version but probably prefer Swep's version better as it allows us more space to work things out for ourselves.
Re: Regret
For me the first stanza must stay and for me the stanzas were used just to make this seem even more important or serious. Falsely, since such poems must be humble. I could see some regret in the four-stanza poem but none in the three-stanza version. Isn't it obvious why? :
I am so sorry, now that you are gone.
Not in sadness or despair
But for the words we never spoke
When you were here.
So back to my "destroying": here is Regret another version I had re-written, but preferred not to post.
I think often of those days
That sped unheeded past
Your startled eyes, not in
Sadness or desperation
But for the words we never
spoke when you were here.
Now that you're gone, I
Only hope that while your
Winter thoughts persisted
There was room for summer,
And that you held fresh flowers
In your gaze when you left me,
Supped sweet-scented air besides.
Next time I will pm you my thoughts or not.
TA:)
Nicoletta
Re: Regret
not at all (PM) . I am totally open. let it be said! this is a site for people to observe - maybe my deficiencies, maybe my triumphs - let it be, whatever, I don't honestly mind, I just BURN to know how to get better! :-)
bless you.
Re: Regret
In regard to Regret, you need the message of the first stanza or you should rename the poem. I'm not sure at all you need all those stanzas.
It's a matter of logic: Regret is the message of the first stanza, there is absolutely no other stanza that refers to your own sense regret, AT ALL. Hope yes (I only hope that you...). Hopefully you will see what I mean.
bless you.
Regret
Prof Griffindo:
I loved the gentle voice in this post. I see a gentle sombre atmosphere evolving out here. But then your line breaks need some thoughts.I don't see enough tension at the places where you enforced your enjambments. More so, read is little passive to this reader. You may call this my lack of poetic intelligence or critical imagination, but IMO that you need to add some solid sequences in the solid backbone you already have. Those stranza breaks are also not giving new views, they seem to add to the beauty of the page! I think you have a brilliant poem in the making.
Calvin and Hobbes
Regret
would you give an example/illustration of your comments on lines of the poem itself? That would help.
Thanks for the comment.
Regret
"Winter thoughts" and "Fresh flowers" are two competing metaphors. Your narrative doesn't challenge enough to hold them. Besides, those metaphors are not expanded that well. But then, I see a rare quality which is so missing in internet poetry. I see a good patterning of thought. Prof Griffindo, sometimes a post just looks correct sententially. N sentences connected by (N-1) links, but then very rarely I get to see second order (N(N-1)/2-N=N(N-3)/2 relations....and higer orders, are rarer. Most of the good poets had these patterning, some of them sucked royal in grammatical skills. Sorry for blabbering too much!
Now about your poem, again.
I think now of the days (an enjambment should challenge the reader, and it does here)
That sped unheeded past your startled eyes (unheeded is not doing much for me, that unheeded-ness is already suggested I suppose! Also that enjambment would be more challenging after "past" )
Unreeling time (Unreeling time is a connotation created out of abstractness, which is not wrong...but falls out of sync!)
You did not have.
I only hope that (A new stanza should give a new view, I just see the same "I" out here...the same first person POV)
While the winter thoughts persisted
There was some room (do you need this enjambment)
For summer.
(Here, I see a justification for strophe break....I don't have any issues with last stanza)
And when you left me,
You held fresh flowers in your gaze
And supped sweet-scented air
Besides. (beside?)
I hope my lack of poetic intelligence would not disqualify me for a discussion with you.
Calvin and Hobbes
Regret
OK, I now have version 3. I listened to what you said, but for now this was the most I was comfortable with, I'm sorry. To explain... removing 'unheeded' destroys the rhythm of that line (as I see it in my head), as would ending the line at 'past' although I understand the point on the enjambment (le Chateau de Chenonceau, qui enjambe la Loire!). For me that long line forces the reader to read hurriedly, and that reinforces the speeding of time passing. That effect is more important for me, as is the sudden slowing that the last two lines bring in contrast. I thought unwinding was more connected perhaps - winding connects with path or road, whereas reeling is cinema film, tape, and has the same primary meaning here.
The second verse for me is three 'steps' followed by a resolution, like someone teetering down stone steps and finally stepping onto the flat, firm gravel, so summer and safety are allied.
The long line in v3 is unlike the first verse one. Whereas the first 'bounces' along, this is soft and smooth (sh, ers). And I've kept 'besides' as 'beside' which can have the same meaning, also has a second (probably the primary) meaning (next to).
Blimey! Look what you made me do! I've never really analysed a poem of mine before - hope it doesn't sound unbearably pretentious. :-) I will read your comments again, and let them sink in, probably keep playing... Very grateful thanks for your interest and intelligent comments...
Regret
having read all your other comments i would just like to say that i like this poem as it stands. Version 2 being the preferred one.
catriona
Regret
thanks. it seems to me that I could actually create several poems here, all equal in merit (whatever that may be) - I guess that's what's so interesting. I like Appoloneia's one as well, but it wasn't 'mine' if you see what I mean.