From the UKAuthors Collection

Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

By e-griff · Originally published 5 August 2005

The author replies!

Letter to the Editor (sequel to ‘Letter from the Editor’)

Dear Mr Montacute,

While applauding your bold approach and your undoubted keenness to bring my work ‘up to scratch’ as you so charmingly might phrase it, may I draw a small pause in proceedings in order to clarify some issues.

Naturally, I take your advice seriously, but may I gently remind you that it is my work we are discussing here, my name which will appear on the book, and I who will be judged by the result. As far as I know, the editor’s name does not appear (except in the unlikely event of a grateful author acknowledging him).

It is thus with some scepticism that I consider your suggestions, many of which I feel would simply destroy my ‘voice’ and stultify what I intend to be a sparkling and witty work by rigidifying both words and layout.

So let us discuss layout: Seven fonts is, in my opinion, the minimum necessary to convey the words I have carefully, o so carefully, crafted. Likewise the page layouts. My wife and my friends agree that expanding the font by two percent makes the world of difference to the Vicar’s intent, and the italics were applauded by all my keen critics as absolutely necessary! While your plea to restrict my soaring ideas has unfortunately been supported, to an extent, by the publisher, I shall not give an inch more on this, and I do not wish to discuss it further.

As to my ‘bon mots’, I see you have inadvertently touched accurately on their true worth. Indeed that is what they are: ‘good words’. ‘Queer as a minker’s squab’ is a well-known phrase in Overcote, for instance and most other places. My wife says she has ‘heard it often’ and indeed I use it frequently myself, as too the other phrases you so cruelly and ignorantly point a finger at. I know for a fact that many of these generate admiration in passing strangers – in my local for instance, many burst into spontaneous merriment at such enlivened and apposite language. Have you travelled much?

Finally, your comments on my language are inappropriate. As the author, I have placed each word in sequence and chosen it carefully (and well, according to those who have read my drafts). You may not realise this, of course, but for those with open minds and a poetic soul, the rhythm and flow of the words is a treat and a delight, at least I have been assured that this is so by Colonel Trotter and Miss Maybe, regular habitués of my writing group. Any interference on your part would disrupt and destroy the inherent beauty of my text. Thus:

… he took her hand in writhing bliss to lead her through the Stygian wood to Mother Nature in her ambit and taste the dim delights of lust in her verdant places. O perfidy! That there was no such sheer pleasure to be had that day as interruption intervened, enleavened by the sauntering policeman, Dick. …

Has been acclaimed as ‘perfect’ by Mrs Satterthwaite, and ‘something which could never be improved on’ by published author, Toby Strapp (A Short History of Kent Lamposts, 1956, oop).

And it is in fact a dramatic and finely-crafted introduction of PC Dick (the Sergeant Lewis character), contrasting the finer, ætherial things of life with his bluff greeting: ‘Why aye, then nah, nah, what’s all this abaht, then, me auld ducks?’ (language which many have said ‘rings with the authenticity of the common man’.)

I give this merely as an example. Who are you to pit your artistic talent against those of the Cottenham Writer’s Circle? I shall listen to tried and trusted friends, rather than someone who has already revealed they have no resonance whatsoever with my style and talent. I must make the assumption that your editorial experience has been limited to railway timetables, telephone directories and the occasional political pamphlet (of one of the less successful parties, I would guess).

Cobbler, stick to your last! For that is what you are, a cobbler. I have been told I may be assigned another editor if I wish, and that is what I am requesting of the publisher. Farewell pedant!

Sincerely,

Colonel William Algernon Flowers (Author and Poet).

cc Ben Mortisham, Managing Director, Benwell Books.

*

Monty,

This F’in Flowers guy!

Jeeeeeeeeeeeeeeezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz! Get back to him using one of your other names, Major Sanders might do it. If he don’t come into line, I’ll bin him, OK?

Cheers,
Ben.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

shadow

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

Splendid! That's told 'im. I shall save this missive and keep it handy, for use as a model if the occassion ever arises in connection with my own work.

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

er, not all of this is fiction.... :-)

Andrea

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

Gave me a good chuckle this one did, Griff :-)

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

thankyou. and for the nib! Damn! You just spoiled my whole 'as someone who hasn't been nibbed lately' credibility on the threads, bugger it! I was planning to use that some more........well, to be honest, ad nauseam as they say..

KDR

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

lol! Great stuff again!
I don't think that book'd be published any time soon... :-)

Karl

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

pedant! It's a GREAT book! :-)

Andrea

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

Sorry to shatter your dreams, Griffy, but it wasn't moi wot nibbed you :-)

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

yeh a wild guess.....

but why do I only get LATE ones EVERY time recently ? (about last 4-5)

and this one arrived just after your positive comment - so someone's apparently watching your own reaction.... better not express displeasure or your obedient right hands may 'terminate' the problem! *really worried now*

Warhorse

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

Hi Griff,

This is a natural from the first, as equally witty, and very well written again, you are brilliant with words,

Well done very very funny.

Regards

Mike

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

Thankyou, again... :-)

reckless

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

A hoot, I enjoyed reading this. I wonder if there's any truth in it? Surely not.

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

my lips are sealed (coupla used fivers?) thanks

eddiesolo

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

A nice reply, very funny.

Si:-)

Claire

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

Oh, well that was very harsh! The poor editor was only trying to help!! I'm trying hard here not to give a kiss arse comment where it just states that I enjoyed the piece...so...erm...bollocks to it, enjoyed it. ;^) Plus, I don't wanna crit if this is the type of stuff you send back to people. LOL ;^)

glennie

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

After reading this and the previous Letter from... I think, 'here's someone who's had experience fo this' am I right? I thought it very, very good; perhaps too good to be fiction. Glen.

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

as I said, its not all fiction............(and some of the truth is worse, honest)

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

no, wouldn't dream of it - both are highly exaggerated based on some facts, but only precariously.

and most of editing is amicably, cooperative and good fun

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

but, I add, any such examples are a tiny tiny proportion of what actually happens, and mostly when such excesses are pointed out, the author responds with embarassment, rather than objection! :-) sometimes you are too close to your own work to see things, I find. Claire recently picked some errors out in one of my stories, which I would have leapt on in someone else's story straight away.

glennie

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

Such are the dangers of critiqueing, that's why I hate it.

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

doing it or receiving it? :-)

discopants

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

I'm with the editor on this one!

e-griff

Re: Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

Yeh, cos I wrote it that way. But what if I switched their characters around? ...Hmm now there's a thought...................................:-)

Beth

Letter to the editor (sequel to: Letter from the editor)

A very amusing write that had me in stitches. I felt kind of sorry for the editor - his requests seemed more than reasonable to me! Lots of little details that added to the effect. Brilliant- regards Beth

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…