From the UKAuthors Collection

Letter from the Editor

By e-griff · Originally published 1 August 2005

Wish you'd never submitted to that publisher?

...never been accepted?

Here's the mail you dread...........

Letter from the Editor

Dear William,

May I introduce myself? I have had the pleasure of being assigned to copy edit and design the layout for your impressive novel, ‘Every Good Boy’.

First, let me say that after the first read through, I sat back astonished. What ideas! What language! What a plot! What style! ‘Breathtaking’ is the only word that I can apply without undue flattery.

Obviously, as an editor, I have to apply myself to my mundane task, to turn from the majestic grandeur of your vision and, like a supplicant, scrape around in the foothills of your grammar, punctuation and spelling. Small things, I own, but maybe important to the more pedantic among your readers – and who could deny them this favour, given that their enjoyment of your book will ultimately transcend such petty nit-picks?

So, descending from the Olympian heights of your work to the peasant-ridden plain of my profession, I seek guidance on these points:

1. May I point out that, in a printed book, white space is far more apparent than on a computer screen. (Forgive me, but I guess that you have prepared this novel using internet screen layout). Moderate and subtle effects work well in print, believe me.
So – it could be that your insistence on four blank line spaces between each paragraph may be a little excessive? And may I counsel against the two lines of asterisks? Not only is this against our style guide, but I really feel they may intrude slightly. Once you’ve looked at these features on a printed-out page, I hope you will see my point.

2. I am very sympathetic to your use of italics. I can see how they dramatise and separate text to highlight your intentions. My only doubt is that, as I have said before, subtlety is preferable to overemphasis. Whether the average reader will take kindly to alternate lines of the text being italicised, with no speech marks or other punctuation present, I find debatable. Experimentation is all well and good, but ‘experimental’ novels that have succeeded have been few and far between.

3. Believe me, as an editor, I really have no brief to dictate to you, or insist on any changes, except where there are clear errors in the typography. However, in preparing your ms for printing, I have to abide by the instructions of your publisher. You, of course, may wish to discuss this with him, but I really cannot include your insistence on seven separate versions of the font, three different page set-ups, and four page size changes. If this were an ‘experimental’ novel, then the slate would be blank. However, as your novel is a traditional detective novel, may I suggest the readers will be far more comfortable with a clearly-presented example of your work?

4. While I admire your poetic use of the language, I have to introduce a note of caution. It is not for me to intrude on your flair and impetus in the writing of this book. But really, I find it difficult to accept phrases such as ‘queer as a minker’s squab’, which might well be a colourful and engaging bon-mot, but which, for a third-party POV narrator, sits ill on the shoulders of the mostly serious, middle-class BBC-English presenter’s voice you have adopted for ninety-five per cent of the work. Other examples are: ‘he took her hand with the confidence of a donkey-riding chiropractor’ and: ‘she swayed along the street like a telephone box on heat.’ I fear that such extravagances might well confuse and alienate the reader, unless you are completely sure of your audience.

5. Can we step back from your insistence that every suggested edit point is sent to you individually by post as I encounter them? I would much prefer to go through your fine work methodically, to weigh and consider my views, and then offer you a composite and complete opinion, ‘in the round.’ Also, your request to the publisher that I must change every suggestion you do not agree with back ‘immediately’ is inappropriate, as suggested changes are simply stored, subject to approval, in a computer. – So if you could just let me know your opinion in the usual way…

6. May I just inform you that, in offering opinions on spelling, I am consulting the contemporary Oxford dictionary that does allow many current modern words and usage. I am also allowing leeway on words used for effect. However, my belief is that, for your readers, saying:

‘Jeeezzz!’

is arguably as effective as your original

‘Jeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz!!!!!!!!!!!’

For me, three is enough to make the point, mmm? Have you ever read Lynne Truss’s book by the way (on exclamation points)?

7. As a great fan of Irvine Welsh myself, I can have no quarrel with flexibility in a novel. But does the scene where the hero and villain have a conversation really have to have only one word per line from each, on opposite sides of the page for a staggering eighty pages or more? And the occasional ten lines of the word ‘hate’ with little arrows pointing across the page? Together with the idea you have for ‘columns’ this means your 300-page book would be increased to one covering over 1000? In economic terms this is quite impossible, as well as making reading difficult for your avid fans.

I look forward very much to working with you, and hope you can forgive my rather pedantic requests. I am sure we can discuss these as we travel through the magnificent edifice that is the construct of your mind, your novel.

I, as a supplicant to the shrines of Apollo, Hermes, Clio and Thoth, at which we both worship, salute you!

Your humble and obedient servant,

J Treadgold Montacute, D Lit, MBE, OOCG,
____________________________________________________________________
(Editing at reasonable rates. Please contact me, attaching your references.)

To read the author's response, Click Here

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

Re: Letter from the Editor

I rather like 'donkey-riding chiropractor'...

e-griff

Re: Letter from the Editor

you would! :-)

but you must NOT use it in your next book...

KDR

Re: Letter from the Editor

Funny, with a serious point to make. Had me chuckling.
However, I feel that including examples of examples like 'Jeeeeeeeeezzzzzzzz!!!!!'... ;-)

Karl

shadow

Re: Letter from the Editor

This is OUTRAGEOUS!!!!!!!! It is uite intolerable that petty considerations of 'typography' and 'economics' should be allowed to influence what is obviously a work on the cutting edge of literary endeavour.
Yours, Shocked & Disgusted.
PS - what is a 'minker's squab'?

e-griff

Re: Letter from the Editor

oops! tell you the truth, I'd forgotten the origin of these. Was 'Jeeeezzzzz' it one of yours? It's sorta generic anyway if it is. Most of these points are true, and have happened several times :-)

Still, I'll not tell anyone... shhh !

e-griff

Re: Letter from the Editor

it IS rather obscure, but it's probably a variant of the saying ' as quilly as a weaver's knowl.'

Linear

Re: Letter from the Editor

Ah the challenge of subtly deviating from the accepted literary styles, while not pissing off and alienating readers. :)

Claire

Re: Letter from the Editor

*Throws novel in the bin*

Amusing read!

Warhorse

Re: Letter from the Editor

Hi griff,

I take my hat of to you, absolutely bloody sensational,

The wit is a lesson in the art, sincerely, remind me not to ever bandy words with you again,

I give you the ground sir.

Regards

Mike4.

Warhorse

Re: Letter from the Editor

Hi Griff,

I take my hat off to you and your power of words and wit.

This is absolutley bloody brilliant.

Remind me not to bandy words with you again.

I yield, and give you the ground sir.

This deserves the credit it is bound to get.

Regards

Mike.

e-griff

Re: Letter from the Editor

so good you said it twice! seriously, though, bowled over, mate thanks for this and the hottie and the author... V Kind.

I recognise you are an author of the 'old school' as am I mostly. If you liked this, you might like 'My Response to Some Site Members Comments' (see my back catalogue) same kinda thing. will look for link.. G

e-griff

Re: Letter from the Editor

there you go:

http://www.ukauthors.com/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=12931

e-griff

Re: Letter from the Editor

oops!!!!
http://www.ukauthors.com/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=3503

it cseems to change it automatically - wierd

Andrea

Re: Letter from the Editor

‘she swayed along the street like a telephone box on heat.’ ...cracked me up, that did.

Wonder why the bloody thing wasn't binned in the first place?

reckless

Re: Letter from the Editor

Thought I'd read the impetus behind the other one, just as good. Wonder if they'll get the point. (??????????????????????..... !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) Now that's art.

eddiesolo

Re: Letter from the Editor

Very amusing and truthful, great write John.

Si:-)

Lulu

Re: Letter from the Editor

Great as ever, glad you are still here! With a smile I rush to re-read the novel I've writting for the last 200 years. Hope to find no Jeeeeeez in it! :( ;)

Missed you.
Lu.xx

e-griff

Re: Letter from the Editor

Thanks, Simon

e-griff

Re: Letter from the Editor

Bless you, Lu. Be happy!

e-griff

Re: Letter from the Editor

er, Andrea, I've seen worse...

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…