From the UKAuthors Collection
Goodbye
By Emerald · Originally published 18 July 2005
*****************
I won't be there
even when you call
like ballerina shoes
outgrown
they hang upon the wall.
I won't be there
when the moon glows
taking midnight walks
alone
wind whistles
and I don't know.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: Goodbye
There is a deep sadness in your poem Emma. An internal confusion of self comes through for me. I know that feeling well.
Take care of yourself
Smiling
Tai
Re: Goodbye
How very melancholy...a lot of emotion in so few words! Thought the ballerina shoes image was particularly sad and powerful.
Re: Goodbye
emma, i kinda of like this but somehow the lines don't quite fit for me.
this is just off my head, so don't take it so seriously, but :
first stanza. what if the second line read: 'even IF you call' or simply 'when you call.' and what if those ballerina's shoes were 'like my ballerina shoes/hanging on the wall/outgrown.'
second stanza: i kind of want to reverse those second and third lines but i can see that it messes up the alone and that the alone rhymes with outgrown.
somehow, i like that casual and unexpected final couplet.
well, i've probably been no use but you know i read it, right? best wishes, anthony.
Re: Goodbye
In a week of subs that are far too long for a munky, this is like an oasis of literary tranquility. Em, my dear, I have absolutely no idea what I'm going on about either. Well I do, I just can't express it. I lost all communicating skills during a tragic cake mixing incident in the early eighties. I cannot speak of that right now as it is too painful. Your poems are like therapy. This is a compliment Emma. Thanks. Trade a subtle glance with a passing stranger who resembles Dirk Bogart. Oh, and eat apples.
s
u
n
k
e
n
Living on an Island with a girl named Friday, cause he wants to - cause he wants to.
Re: Goodbye
I like it Emma, the hanging shoes make me very sad...love Erma
Re: Goodbye
Thanks Tai for reading a commenting - honestly, I'm not as miserable as I sound lol. I'm caught in a groove of sad bad poetry at the moment.
Emma:-)
Re: Goodbye
Thanks Roy, it is very melancholly - I have a thing about ballet shoes - they seem always to look so lonely when put aside or outgrown.
Emma:-)
Re: Goodbye
Thanks Anthony, all comments and advice are received gratefully - I'm not particularly happy with this poem either - I know it needs a lot more work - and it is hard at times to be objective over what I write. Your comments certainly give food for thought - and I may yet play around with this and see how I can get it to scan and flow better.
Emma:-)
Re: Goodbye
Thanks Sunken - it certainly is a short poem - and again a sad one - honestly I will try and cheer up my writing somehow. I always enjoy your comments.
Emma:-)
Re: Goodbye
Thanks Erma, there is something about old ballet shoes just left hanging that always makes me feel sad. Glad you liked this and thank you for reading.
Emma:-)
Re: Goodbye
OOps. Sorry about calling you Claire...... A lack of sleep.... Anyway Emma.....Wonderful piece of poetry...Actually both these new one's of yours are very strong and poignant.
I can relate to this one quite well too. Thank you for sharing it.
blessings,
Jolen
Re: Goodbye
you know Emma, this is the most valid way to say goodbye when you're still in love. I really liked your poem... you have my respect.
Re: Goodbye
hey Emma
this is done quiet well i thought....and i can feel where your coming from...theres a deep sadness there as you can feel it straight from the poem...
but i think its kind of unfinished maybe you can expand it...but then again it gives it a special something by living it the way it is... so its up to you
take care
xXx...:::...BaBy PoeT...:::...xXx
Re: Goodbye
Thanks Jolen - no worries about the name - I'm trying to not to write sad poems, but thats all I'm producing at the moment - glad you could relate.
Emma:-)
Re: Goodbye
Thanks Apolloneia, glad you liked this and thanks for reading.
Emma:-)
Re: Goodbye
Thanks Baby Poet - It does have a sort of unfinished feel to it I know, but somehow I felt it had to end there - hard to explain - but I do feel that it does need work on this. So thank you for the comments - it is appreciated
Emma:-)
Re: Goodbye
Hi Emma,
I'm so glad that this was short, any longer and I would be bawling! Just thought it was a great write and very emotional.
Si...*sniffs*
Re: Goodbye
lol Si - thanks for making me smile with this comment - I agree its better shorter - I would have been hysterical if I had gone on any longer I think. Trying to make my writing a bit lighter at the moment, but I seem stuck in an emotional phase with it at the moment.
Emma:-)