From the UKAuthors Collection
The Black Boy's Plea
By e-griff · Originally published 11 July 2005
Right, here's mine!
The Black Boy’s Plea
If you have not yet read my story ‘The Black Boy’, I’m afraid you may have to do so first to understand this. Click Here
I’m sitting here in the garden with my new friend. He is kind, very kind. I’ve never had a friend before. When I played in the woods with the other boys, they were friendly, but I had no special friend. Now I have. He’s a grown up, but he seems to like me. He told me so for a long time before he joined me.
After that time at the pond, I sat alone for years in this misty world. There are many others who have passed, like me. I sense them, but they are far off and I cannot go where they are, there is something that stops me. If I try hard, I can speak to them. But they are uninterested; they do not seem to care. And none of them ever comes here, to this bench in this corner of the garden as he did.
The house has changed little over the years and I can see it clearly, it has substance, like me, although I would never approach it. It looks older, but that’s all. For years, as the insubstantial ones moved around, few of them ever saw me, even though I tried to make them. The house has had various occupants, but few children. I can talk to children. They see me.
There was one boy, he saw me but became afraid. They were a happy family, always laughing, playing in the garden, but he would cry out when I came to sit on the bench after wandering the woods, and the adults would cluster round him. He would point towards me, but they saw nothing. They withdrew from the garden and I did not see him for a long time. Then one day, he was taken away. His parents stayed for many years, growing older, but after that day they were always sad, not happy any more. They stayed sad until they passed. First the man, then the woman, years later.
My world is misty, and lonely, so lonely. I cannot travel far from the pond and the woods, I am pulled back. I cannot tell how long I have been coming to this bench.
My friend could see me before he passed. He talked to me about his son, and his wife. I could sense his burning need. But they were in my world, not his, and I guess that’s what formed the link between us. I became a part of them; he focussed his hopes on me. I searched among the passed and found them: his wife – frightening, a whirl of conflict, unresolved grief, sucking me in; and his son, a boy like me. But a handsome boy, a good boy. Better than me, nicer than me.
I needed a friend. He said he was my friend, he would be happy with me. I drew on his need to give me the strength to give him what he secretly wished, and I did so in a spirit of friendship. Now he sits with me on this bench. He is not sad – he is happy. With me. I know he is. I am sure he is.
He cannot go any further without my help, I am part of it now. He does not know he can, and I will not tell him. It is better this way. I have a friend. He is happy. I have no choice!
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
This is a simple monologue spoken by the spirit of the Black Boy which I think works quite well. It has a melancholy quality, despite the frequent references to being "happy". We get the feeling of a spirit trapped between two worlds, resigned to a fate that is tolerable but imperfect. There are no elements of horror in this one, and the plight of the boy connects with our feelings in a way that I don't think any of the events or characters in the first one do. I think it would work well to tell the whole of the first part from the spirit's point of view also, and finish with this personal testimony from Limbo. A very worthwhile effort, I thought.
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
Honestly, Griff, are you allowed to take part in your own challenge? *Rolls eyes*.
I think this works pretty well- the aftermath of the killing from the Black Boy's point of view told with melancholy and even tenderness. I like the idea that his killing of the man made the latter happy and able to connect with his wife and son.
PS. The prose count is up a bit today!
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
I didn't expect you to go this way with it at all. I started, just slightly, to be glad for the boy, now that he has a companion. Macabre!
The only thing I started to wonder was, the boy has been there in this astral limbo world for seemingly many years, more than his natural life span.
He still thinks like a child.
Perfectly legitimate of course, given his limbo state, but I wonder if he could ever mature.
I probably wonder a little too much. :)
Good continuation, nice PoV shift.
R
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
I like this. A good addition to the original story. Very nice taking it from the boys point of view, which must be quite unique, given his age and situation.
I enjoyed the final exclamation!
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
yeH. That's his plea!
I always think that in 'Portnoy's Complaint' people misunderstood what his complaint actually was - but that, of course was intentional...
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
hhmmmmm... would he be happy? I doubt it. I would say they were both sad and pretty pissed off being trapped in that one place. My personal preference though.
I loved the idea of it being from the boys point of view, great angle to it. And that he has seen many people move in and out of the house. You could do a lot more to this story.
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
well, without being too giveaway, of course, neither are really happy... that's the point..
anyway you ALWAYS say that (could do a lot more) and I ALWAYS say that, don't I?
There is a philosphy that says 'less is more' - the more you leave to your reader's imagination, the more interesting it becomes for them, more involving - they create their own solutions, ideas, they'll even supply their own motivation and plot sometimes... hee hee! :-) G
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
Commenting on prose makes me all hot and sweaty, not a good idea on one of the hottest days of the year. That's my excuse (-: Does it for me though Griff.
s
u
n
k
e
n
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
From the original, I thought the boy. the black boy, was a nasty thing but this makes him more sad than bad.
I liked this. I enjoyed this.
chrissy
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
thanks David. I tried it different ways and softened it a bit, but I felt I had to stay with the 'staccato' approach, as if its the halting speech of a nervous boy
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
Read both pieces and enjoyed them immensely, Love Val x
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
I didn't think this sat with the same story. I read the original, really enjoyed it till I came to the end which I didn't like because I'm not a fan of horror, I'd have liked it to go more like the story you have just done. I like the idea of the boy, I and love the challenge you through out. Both were beautifully written and a pleasure to read. :) Kaz
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
I didn't think this sat with the same story. I read the original, really enjoyed it till I came to the end which I didn't like because I'm not a fan of horror, I'd have liked it to go more like the story you have just done. I like the idea of the boy, I and love the challenge you through out. Both were beautifully written and a pleasure to read. :) Kaz
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
I really like this further insight into your original tale.
'I drew on his need to give me the strength to give him what he secretly wished' and
" a whirl of conflict, unresolved grief'
I wondered whether those phrases might be a bit complex for a young child to use, but over time would his thoughts and understanding of himself and the others he glimpsed, change and grow in that strange limbo? Thought provoking and adds depth, thanks very much for sharing it.
all the best
LE
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
thank you. apreciated! :-)
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
don't forget kids were better educated in language then, Guv'nor :-) (joking).
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
Enjoyed this little addition, it works well.
Si:-)
Re: The Black Boy's Plea
thanks, mate! :-)