From the UKAuthors Collection

Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

By jay12 · Originally published 9 May 2005

It's a sad fact of life in modern Britain that real heroes often become the victims,

The bullets flew through the air like locusts in a field. There seemed to be hundreds of them coming from every direction, the noise I shall never forget - it was immense. The landing craft hit the beach with a thud, we must have been speeding towards the German guns at a rate of knots; the front collapsed and we ran out into a few feet of water. I can remember the tink, tink, tink sound of the bullets as they ricocheted against the lander. It was frightening, the thought of a single stray bullet hitting you in the right place could mean it was all over. I ran across to a steel mine that been beached by the tide and lay there. I could see my men running left and right hiding themselves too - where they could. I noticed a few of them where already hit. They scrawled around in the water which was now red with blood for as far as I could see. A few of my men were already dead. They had taken bullets straight into their heads and thankfully never knew what had hit them. The wounded where not so lucky, they had to suffer before they died. Many of them died because their injuries where so severe, others where taken to field hospitals where they died from disease and infection. It was a terrible time.
Eventually though, a few hundred of us managed to breach the gun nests and killed the German fire. We opened up a corridor of beach about a mile long and radioed in, so that troops could land safely where we where.
I remember the gun nest that I had to clear so well. The Germans were all dead due to the Spitfires laying down there bombs. Inside a German sat behind the entrance door and panted. He held his throat tightly with both hands and gasped for air. When I burst in there was no one alive but him. I sent all of my men out and stood before him and asked ‘Did you kill any soldiers’
Of course, he did not reply, he just continued to pant. His eyes gazed upon me with fear, they pleaded with me to kill him but I wanted him to suffer – this single German soldier was to pay for the deaths of all the allies on the beaches that day. I knelt before him and pulled his hands away from his throat it was then I spotted the shrapnel wound. He was bleeding badly but it was not arterial. I could have saved him, but I left him to die slowly. I know the war was not his fault. He was nothing but a pawn for the fascist military machine but it was a great feeling to see him die. I know it’s terrible to say about a human being but I reveled in it, I felt like a starving animal who knew he was about to feast like he had never before.
It took him ages to die, I would say at least thirty minutes, but it felt much longer. He took one deep breath and then exhaled and his head lolled sideways, the life drained from him and his eyes glazed. I walked over and spat on him and then simply left; we had a job to do, we had arrived in Europe and had many more Germans to kill.
I hadn’t thought about that single Nazi soldier for about fifty years until tonight.
Tonight I was sat in front of the TV in my little flat; I say flat it’s part of a huge sheltered housing scheme. Us pensioners ain't safe these days so we have to lock ourselves away in these places. I heard a noise in the bedroom and ignored it. Why? I don’t know, I guess I thought it was nothing until the young yob walked in with his hood over his head and his knife in his hand.
‘Gimme your money you old bastard’ he said.
I was so shocked I thought I was gonna drop dead on the spot. My heart thumped, that was bad with my angina. I told him I didn’t have any and I shouted get out, you have no rights to be here. He didn’t care bloody idiot. He was probably out of his mind on drugs, they all are these days, bloody criminals. We never had crime in my day and I tell you why – we didn’t have drug problems. Life might have been hard back then but it was not so bad that we had to go filling ourselves with drugs to forget reality.
He asked again, this time he pressed the knife against my throat, ‘Where is your fucking money?’
‘I told you I aint got none’ This was not what he wanted to hear. I dunno whether he panicked cus time was ticking but he pressed the knife into me and I felt warm blood ooze down my neck. I put my hands up and held the wound tightly, for a moment I felt like I was going to strangle myself trying to save myself.
He stood back and just looked at me. It was then I remembered the German. I know now how he must have felt that day all those many years ago.
“I…I’m sorry…” the youth said. He dropped the knife and began to tremble. He then turned and simply left.
I fought and risked my life for my country so that people today can be free…
I can’t hold on to my neck for ever, but when I try and scream I can hear silence and not much else. I’m dying.
After eighty five years on this Earth, I’m finally going to meet my maker and I still don’t know what life is all about.
I don’t want to die, neither did that German; I had another sixty years and ended up like this. That Nazi didn’t. Who’s the winner?
I just want to have another day on Earth, I wanna see the sun rise and smell freshly mown grass, I wanna enjoy a nice glass off my favourite stout, I wanna live life again.
I want to be back on the beach on D-Day. I don’t want to die like this.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

RoyBateman

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

The answer is definitely "hero". Awful choices have to be made in war, and thank goodness I've never actually been in the position to make them - but scumbags who prey on the elderly deserve far more than they ever get. A powerful, thought-provoking piece.

KDR

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Not sure about some of the language used. 'Wanna' sounds American, yet the 'voice' of the narrator sounds English - unless the use of 'wanna' is supposed to be indicative of a regional accent.

As to whether the guy is a hero or victim...IMO he's both. He was both hero and victim of the times he lived in as a young man, and again he's both in the times he sees as an old man.
Interesting little social comment there, too. People thinking their lives are so bad now that they turn to drugs to escape reality...but isn't life much sweeter now than it was then? They didn't have widescreen TVs, loads of channels, or many of the other outlets people have now, after all.

The final reaction of the intruder (apologising) didn't ring true, for me. It kind of let the rest of it down.
What I might have done was to have the old man look into the silent intruder's eyes and 'see' the German he had left to die looking back at him...

All in all, though, a good story because it is so thought provoking.

Karl

Squeaky

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

You've got a potentially very good story here Jammers, i didnae like the apology from the crook, but all in all a good piece and in particular the 2nd half.

Squeaky

Claire

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

James,

Congrats on that nib hun. Bloody well done. Give it a few weeks, have another edit and send this baby off to a mag'. One of your best so far hun. This style suits you.

jay12

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Thanks for your read and comment Roy.

I agree completely, scum bags like the intruder deserve a bayonet up there arse holes and locking up for 20 years to think about what they do!

Jay.

jay12

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Thanks for reading and commenting.

I know about wanna but "want to" sounds too perfect, who speaks so well all of the time? I'm not sure about the apology being wrong, maybe in a way no intruder wants to kill but sometimes they end up doing so.

I will consider what you have said, cheers,

Jay.

jay12

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Thanks for reading and commenting Squeaky. Any kind of positive comment from you I will take well as you are so critical! Glad you liked it mostly!

Jay.

jay12

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Hi Claire,

Thanks ever so much for your kind comment and thanks for reading. Im glad that you enjoyed it.

You flatter me so much, I am considering tidying up a few of my prose pieces to try and get published - I need to get published sometime!

The nib was a shocker! (But a nice shocker)

take care, Jay.

Kat

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Hi Jay

This is a very thought-provoking and timeous piece - full credit to you for writing and I agree with Claire that 'the voice' suits you and is good.

Some more attention to editing (some typos) and 'where' has been used when you've meant 'were', but these are fairly few and far between. I enjoyed it.

Kat :)

jay12

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Hi Kat,

Thanks for your read and your kind comments!

Thanks for pointing out the silly error of mine too! Doh!

Jay.

glennie

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Good work J. Kept my attention all through. I don't have an a problem with the apology, I've never been a drug addict but at times I could ave murdered for a fag! Maybe a bit more editing to smooth things out. What about 'wanta' instead of wanna?

AnthonyEvans

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

dear jay, i've read your piece and read the comments.

i too had some difficulties with some of the dialogue and i thought maybe your protaganist was actually american (and that you were trying for an american accent) because of the line: 'we had arrived in Europe and had many more Germans to kill' i know that, back in the 40s, if you came from england to france you probably were coming into europe but today it rings a touch false. would 'we had arrived on the Contintent' maybe work better? or simply, 'we had arrived in France' (or wherever it is). it's just a suggestion.

one other thing, i too think that the intruder shouldn't apologize. i think it is enough that he trembles and drops the knife. maybe you could throw in more description (eyes widened, whatever) to show us that it was unintentional rather than that apology. if he is a drug addict then i think he will be confused and it will be more of an 'oh shit!' reaction rather than feeling sorry for the old man.

not sure if these comments help, congrats on the nib, thanks for the read. best wishes, anthony.

sirat

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

I liked the story line but felt some of the same reservations that others have mentioned. You have called the piece a monologue, which means it is (literally) spoken I suppose, in which case compressed versions of phrases like "wanna" would be okay, but it doesn't FEEL like a spoken monologue, it seems to use the register of written English most of the time, and when you are writing you don't normally write in an accent, you just use standard forms like "want to". There was a sort of tension for me between written and spoken forms.
I also felt it was just a little bit too explicit, even in its title. As the reader I felt I was being forced to see it in a particular way and ask a particular question: hero or victim? There's something a bit too direct for me about that.
I think what I would do with it (and you may not agree at all) is present it as the dying man's confused thoughts, with flashbacks to the Normandy beaches and maybe to other bits of his life, and make the thug, and maybe even the dying German, slightly more rounded characters. Maybe the narrator felt an impulse to apologise too after what he had done to the German. Maybe he feels a strange impulse now to forgive his attacker. There seem to be so many possibilities for this scenario that aren't realised. I'm not saying it isn't good, it most certainly is, only that it has the potential to be a great deal better.

jay12

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Hi Glennie,

Thanks for reading and commenting. I'll take into account what you have said. I'm still not sure what I wanna (wanta) use.

Cheers, Jay.

jay12

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

hi anthony,

You've given me a lot to think about there. I think Europe was seen more as "Europe" even by Brits back then. As for being American Im not sure what voice I was trying to achieve but I would hope it was English. I'll work on it and give it an edit soon enough. Thanks for reading and your comments.

Jay.

jay12

Re: Hero or Victim (A Monologue)

Your comment is certainly a help. I can see that the story could have been so much more. I think that I will work onit now and I will take into account what you have said. After re-reading though it myself I can see that it struggles to come across as a monologue too.

Hopefully I can get it re-written and edited for in a few weeks time, but when ever I do I will resubmit it. It'll probably have a new title too.

Thanks for your help David.

Jay,

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…