From the UKAuthors Collection

Of God and the Universe.

By Gerry · Originally published 2 May 2005

Don't shoot the messenger.

Einstein’s famous formula E=MC2 basically means that you cannot get something from nothing. Everybody will probably agree with that. It is thought that our universe started with a big bang, and that big bang came from a singularity (a point of infinite density). Well okay this singularity must have been some kind of energy. This energy became unstable and exploded. It then expanded like a balloon being blown up—the energy converting to matter on its way. It went on of course to create our universe, and is in fact still expanding at a not inconsiderate rate.

When asked where the centre of the universe is, scientists tell us that there isn’t one.
Well okay, but isn’t the point or singularity of the big bang the centre? Seeing that everything started there. If as we are told the universe will eventually reach its limit of expansion and then start to deflate---or fall back on itself, will it not reach the same point as it started from? If we are likened to a giant balloon. Why do we not have a centre? A balloon has a centre and simple maths will soon locate it.

Doesn’t it seem possible that this may be the answer to our question also? How did it all start? Surely to have a big bang in the first place we had to have the energy---Einstein proved this. The energy then had to come from a collapsing universe. So maybe our universe is cyclical—Bang, expand, collapse, compress and bang again.

It seems to make more sense than the magical (nothing exploded) and created the universe. If as the scientist tell us the universe is like a balloon with no centre IE all matter on the outer side, Why when we look out from any point on earth do we see millions of stars? Surely if our balloon was empty (only matter on the periphery) there would be one direction were we didn’t see much at all.

So we have our giant balloon---now if you can imagine looking at it from afar and gradually pulling back we presumably would see this globe hanging in space, our universe. It cannot possibly occupy all of space---only the part it has had time to expand into. So if we continue to pull back is it not possible we would see other globes? Other universes? If there is infinite space why shouldn’t there be infinite universes to fill it?

We know because the laws of physics tells us, that there will always be big bangs, creation and destruction in our universe; the pictures from the hubble telescope confirm this without any doubt. Maybe then this also applies to universes. If we could watch from far enough away, would we see universes being born and dying just like we observe stars and galaxies now? The big question then how did it all start.

Have you ever thought it strange that we happen to have everything to hand on our planet that we require? As humans have progressed through life from the earliest days, everything they needed has been there for them. Each new requirement has been obligingly provided; even now new elements and minerals are being discovered to supply our needs.

Have you ever though how amazing it is that we are just the right distance from the sun? A little nearer and we would burn up—a little further away and we would freeze. Have you ever thought how strange it is that when the moon is between the earth and the sun, it covers the sun perfectly to a millimetre.

Don’t you ever think that there may be a just a little bit more to this than the brains of men and our knowledge of physics and science will ever fathom? Well I do---

Before anyone asks me why I wrote this. It was Sunday evening, I was sat at my computer and I didn’t know what to write. This came out. It is not intended to be definitive in any way; it is just the result of 25 minutes of fingers on ‘QWERTY’.

Maybe it will give you something to think about.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Harry

Re: Of God and the Universe.

It all depends on how you ask the questions, Gerry. How does it happen? What would happen if it didn't happen? Does it have to happen? Every question begs another, and you put the question very well.

Easyd

Re: Of God and the Universe.

Right - well, nicely written, but let me correct your view of the big bang and all that. The point of the balloon analogy is that we are on the surface of a 4-dimensional balloon. That surface is 3-dimensional, just as the surface of a 3-dimensional balloon is 2-dimensional or flat. A bit hard to picture for a non-physicist (I am a physicist) but in the analogy the galaxies are spirals painted on the surface of the balloon, except that in reality they stay the same size as the balloon expands, while gradually getting further and further from one another. Thus it might be better to picture the galaxies as badges somehow pinned onto the surface of the balloon (without bursting it!): as rigid badges they stay the same size but the inter-galaxy distance gets bigger and bigger. The analogy is good in that you show galaxies dotted all over the spherical balloon in a uniform distribution. As the expansion (big bang) goes on, the badges get further from each h other, but their distribution is much the same as before -i.e. uniform in all directions. The analogy carries over to us on our 4-d balloon, where when we look around us in 3-d at all the galaxies and see there are the same number in each direction, we are just looking along the 3-d surface of the 4-d balloon. Thus there is no centre in our 3-d space - but might be in 4-d 'hyperspace', only we would find it hard to go there. Maybe we could snip off a warp a la Star Trek and float to centre of balloon. We'd need 4-d beings to guide us, though.

Now to another point: if you'd followed the science news in the last 3 or so years you'd realise that because distance supernovae were seen to be accelerating away from us quicker that expected, it seems there is a mysterious force, dubbed 'dark energy' or 'quintessence' that causes the big bang, not to slow down, but speed up the further the galaxies are from each other. This is a headache for the cosmologists, and it seems there is so much energy in the dark energy that it is 75% of all mass/energy, with Dark Matter (holds galaxies together) coming in second at about 20%, with normal matter coming last at a mere 5%.

Now your question as to where all the energy came from. No one has a clue. The best they can do is defer the decision by saying we are just one in a long series of sprouting sub-universes or even parallel dimension universes a la quantum many worlds or similar. But in the end they are stuck at the question: where did this 'multiverse' come from? There is still plenty of scope for a God in there. Also, Newton was convinced that divine will was needed to keep the universe in existence. This 'continual miracle' is also still a valid theory, as physics just gives the equations, and never say how to breathe fire into the equations, as Hawking says.

Finally, the coincidence that our planet is ideally suited to life - in the 'biosphere' of the sun, here water neither boils nor freezes, with goalkeepers Moon and Jupiter to keep away too many nasty asteroids etc. (though recent theory says we need an optimum number of collisions to drive variety in evolution - after each major extinction there followed an explosion of diversification). Other 'coincidences' are that the earth has enough gravity to hold in oxygen but not too much so we'd be crushed. Then there's a reaction in stars, in the 'CNO cycle' that needs a coincidence to make heavier elements like oxygen and iron. All these coincidences (there are more (e.g. large numbers - universe 10**40 planck times, which is ration of electro to gravity force)) lead to the 'anthropic principle' (strong or weak version). Strong anthropic principle: implying that observers are needed so every universe must be such as to bring them forth. The weak anthropic principle says that only universes in the mutiverse (see above) with the right conditions (all the coincidences) will produce observers in the first place.

Reading consciousness book by Coin McGinn now - his idea: the universe varies between pure mind and mixed mind/matter: before big bang
pure mind etc. Oh and jury still out on BigBang? See Halton Arp and his theory of non-cosmological red-shift. Also Burkhard Heim where the universe is immensely older that 15 billion years.

Gerry

Re: Of God and the Universe.

Harry, You are right, this subject blows my mind. I just haven't got enough cells left. lol.

Gerry.

Gerry

Re: Of God and the Universe.

Easyd, Thank you for going into detail to explain some of my points. I never expected a response like the one you supplied. My article was really written quite light heartedly and quite by chance--however it is a subject I am interested in, and I have devoured Hawking's books even though I have to admit I didn't always understand them fully. I did have an idea about the 4 dimension and centre thingy.lol--- but I didn't think anyone on here would know too much about it. I was bluffing a bit. lol.

I reckon some of my points were fair enough , and it was nice to see that you didn't shoot me down in flames. I do intend now to look into this subject a bit more closely--it really is fascinating. I still believe we had a little help along the way. lol.

Thank you ones more...

Gerry.

Gerry

Re: Of God and the Universe.

'Once'--sorry. Have smacked my pooter...

RoyBateman

Re: Of God and the Universe.

I'm sorry - after this and that most detailed reply I've ever seen (literally) the Big Bang has just happened inside my head. This science...never my strong suit, though I agree that it's fascinating on many different levels, including philosophy. It's so easy to discover what we DON'T know...but the answers? Maybe it's 42, but I don't think it's that simple. It all boils down to this - I have no idea how the matter of this or any other universe was created. If matter or energy can only change form, how did it occur? Where did it come from? Now, a religious person might come up with the explanation - God created it. Sorry, that begs the obvious retort - who created God, and why - and what if anything did God create him/her/itself from? In the beginning was the word - who spoke or wrote it? Because if no-one did, it wasn't a word - but there was nothing there before the word, so round and round we go.
We're still left with the idea of something from nothing, and nothing I've ever seen can solve that conundrum.
Very thought-provoking, Gerry - my brain hurts!

Gerry

Re: Of God and the Universe.

Roy, My brain has been hurting for a long time. Each time I think about this subject in fact--and that is quite often. Religious belief is only about faith Roy, nobody has any proof of anything. The so called big bang if that is what it was, stops
everyone dead in their tracks. Your posed question is of course valid--I have asked it many times myself--I am afraid for the foreseeable future our brains will have to continue to hurt...LOL.

Gerry. 'PM'

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…