From the UKAuthors Collection

Conundrum

By jay12 · Originally published 29 April 2005

Based on a nightmare I had last week.

Thanks to Claire for help editing my draft.

Steve opened his eyes and looked upwards. He lay on the hard floor, his head and heart pounded; his pulse throbbed in his eardrums. The light in the room was dull but even that hurt his eyes. He sat up, rubbed his eyes and coughed clearing his dry throat. He tried to stand up but could not; he collapsed down onto the cold concrete floor.

“Where the hell am I?” he said to himself.

Above him a long fluorescent strip light started to flicker, it made a low humming noise then the room was filled with a bright white light. Again, Steve had to cover his eyes with his hands; he felt sick. Sighing, he opened his eyes; he blinked several times until his eyes adjusted to the light. Again, he looked around the room, a man lay in the corner only a few feet away from him, this startled him and he moved away to the opposite corner. On the floor next to the body was an envelope with ‘Read Me’ written on the front. Next to that was a wooden box, about two feet square by one foot high.

He plucked up the courage and crawled over to the man’s body and picked up the envelope then quickly scurried away back to his corner. He opened the envelope, took out a folded piece of plain A4 paper, and read it:


Hello,

You are probably wondering what is going on. Well, you are about to play a game. You have been drugged so you will feel a little groggy for a few moments, but don’t worry it will pass. In the room there is a crate. Open it. Inside you will find water please drink it. It will help clear your throats and reduce the immediate effects of the drugs. You will also find two revolvers containing one bullet in each. Both of you take one. You will need them to play the game.

The game is called ‘Conundrum’ and it is very simple. Only one of you can leave alive. You must decide between yourselves, which one of you should survive. The one who is deemed the loser must fatally shoot themselves to allow the other to go free. Above you on the wall there is a closed circuit television camera which allows me to play referee.

The only rule of the game is the person who chooses to die must die by his own hand. If you murder your opponent you will not be set free. You will stay locked up until you too are dead by starvation or suicide.

If the CCTV camera is covered or destroyed you will both be losers.

The winner will be released and set free to return to their life.

Enjoy!

Steve moved back and leaned against the wall, he dropped the note on the floor next to him. Looking up he could see the camera in the corner of the room trained straight at him. He looked back down at the crate and the body of the man that lay flat; he froze with fear as his situation slowly dawned on him.

He was unsure how long he sat like that feeling helpless, but it was quite a while; it seemed like hours had passed by the time the body in the corner showed signs of life. The man began to moan and groan, gasping and coughing, he turned over and rubbed his eyes. He sat upright and looked straight at Steve.

“Where am I bud?” he asked, as if they were old friends.

The camera on the wall moved silently, Steve noticed it. He looked back at the guy, “I dunno. I think we have been kidnapped.”

“Are you shitting me, this is a fucking joke right?”

Steve stared at him for a few seconds, “Read this.” He picked the envelope up and skimmed it across the floor to the anonymous man. He opened it and read it silently. He screwed it up and chucked it into the corner.

“This has to be a joke, someone is winding us up.”

“Why would someone go to the trouble of drugging us and setting up this whole charade, it’s obviously a nut case?” Steve replied.

“So why us and what the fuck are we gonna do?”

“Why us, who knows.”

“Shall I open the box?” the unnamed man said, as he placed his hand upon it.

“Yeah, do it.” Steve was too afraid to open it.

The guy took hold of the rope handle on top of the crate and pulled. It came off easily. Inside the box was full of small balls of polystyrene. He tipped the box up and it spewed out all over the floor. He rummaged through it gently with his hands and pulled out two bottles of water, he handed one to Steve; he thanked him and cracked it open taking a huge swig, the other man did the same. Steve sat back enjoying the cool fresh feeling of the water on his throat.

The nameless man placed his bottle down and continued to rummage through the crate. “Oh my God look at these.” He held up two revolvers, “This is real ain’t it, it’s no fuckin’ joke, it’s real!”

“It’s real alright.” Steve took one of the revolvers and observed it. “These are real too.”

“Fuck man.”

They sat in silence for a short while.

“My name is David, what’s yours?”

“Sorry?” said Steve.

“What’s your name? I’m David, call me Dave.” He held out his hand.

Steve looked down at his hand and then back up making eye contact, “I’m Steve, nice to meet you.” They shook hands.

“Well that’s the formalities out of the way, what are we going to do to get out of here?” said Dave.

“I dunno, maybe if we just sit here and wait whoever has done this will get bored.”

“Well it sounds better than heads or tails to see who gets shot. Do you think there’s a way out?”

“I’ve had a look around,” Steve said. “I can’t see a way in never mind out.”

“From the looks of it you’re right,” Dave replied scanning the room. “Fuck it. Let’s wait the bastard out.”

Steve nodded positively. They both sat down in opposing corners and waited.

“So, what do you do for a living Steve?”

“I’m an architect. I design homes and apartment blocks.”

“Wow! That sounds great. I bet you earn a fortune.”

“Well it pays the bills, but the hours are terrible. I hardly see my wife anymore.”

“I bet she don’t mind spending the dough though eh?”

Steve smiled, “She spends it alright but she’s worth it.”

“Yeah,” said Dave. “Well I’m a lawyer.”

“Nice. My wife’s a legal secretary. She’s very busy too, but at least it’s normal nine to five hours.”

“A legal secretary, wow! That’s a coincidence.”

“I suppose that is a coincidence…” Steve looked Dave up and down. “You don’t look like one; or sound like one.” Steve felt silly saying this.

“What do lawyers look like?”

“Nothing, you look… aaaah well nothing.”

“What, like a bum.” Dave rubbed the stubble on his face and smiled, “I’m good at my job, the partners don’t worry too much about my appearance when I win all of my cases.”

“So you’re good huh! There’s a guy at my wife’s firm who’s good. She says he’s the best.”

“Oh yeah, what’s the firm called, I might know him.”

“I’m not sure of the name, its just the partners’ names something like Smith and Jones Solicitors… not that exactly I can’t quite remember. She’s new at the firm, only been there a few months.”

“Sounds like my work… but they are all the same ain’t they. The names I mean.”

Steve smiled, “Yeah they are all the same ain’t they! Bloody lawyers.”

“Hey! Be careful, this is loaded.” Dave held his revolver up.

“Yeah, we can’t use them remember. Unless you wanna shoot yourself and let me go.”

Dave laughed aloud this time, “There is no way I’m shooting myself. Not to pleasure some psycho. You shoot yourself.”

“No way! I have a wife I wanna see again. Have you?”

“No I ain’t, I got a few women on the go though. In fact I got a lovely piece of ass at work and I wanna see her again too.” Dave winked.

“So, what the fuck are we gonna do. We’ve sat here now for nearly an hour waiting and there ain’t been a peep. We ain’t going to get out of here…”

Dave interrupted, “Okay, say we play the game. We ain’t got no guarantees that the one left alive is going to be released anyway. If this person is sick enough to go to this trouble they could be crazy enough to let us rot anyway.”

“So what are you saying, that we should both blow our brains out cus there is no hope? There has to be a way out,” Steve said optimistically.

“No there doesn’t. I had never met you until I woke up in this cell. I can accept that as a lawyer, I can sometimes piss people off. There are probably dozens of people I worked for and against, who would love to do something like this to me… but they wouldn’t but I can’t be sure of that fact… What are you in here for Mister Architect? Is there any reason that you would be in here?”

“There is no reason for me to be in here, Dave.”

“Well perhaps you were just in the wrong place at the wrong time cus buddy we ain’t got no connection with each other, I ain’t gonna kill myself to save a stranger any more than you are. So we are fucked anyway.”

“Well not really, it’s a game right. So there has to be a time limit or an ending otherwise it ain’t a game.”

“This is no game, it’s a sick fuckers IDEA OF FUN.” Dave began to raise his voice as he spoke. He stood up and walked across to the camera on the wall. “LET ME OUT, WHAT DO YOU WANT OFF ME YOU FUCKER, LET ME GO!”

“Hey,” said Steve, “Calm down man, you’re giving them what they want. Just sit down and shut up.”

“Hey don’t you tell me what to do Okay.” Dave waved his revolver at Steve, “You ain’t my boss, I’m my own boss.”

“Put the gun down you idiot you’re going to fuck this all up, do you wanna get out of here alive?”

Dave stared at him for a moment then slowly lowered the gun and returned to his corner of the cell. Then there was silence. Nothing was said for two hours. They sat with their thoughts and fears.

“Are you scared of dying Steve?”

“Yes, Yes I am. I don’t want to leave my wife yet, I love her.”

“I wish I had someone I loved.”

“You said you had a woman at work you were seeing, why don’t you try and settle down with her.”

“I can’t she’s married.”

“Married! You want to be careful, you play with the fire you’ll get burned.”

“I’d feel worse if I had chased her down, but she came to me for… y’know.”

“So, her marriage is over then is it.”

“She says her husband has no time for her these days. If you were to see her you would be amazed. She is perfect. He must be crazy to neglect her.”

“She sounds nice,” said Steve, “But I got my wife and I don’t think there is another woman in the world that compares to her, even your bit of slice.”

“You wanna see her? I got a picture of her in my wallet.”

“Yeah sure.”

Dave took his wallet from his pocket and fumbled through the contents, he took out a small picture and passed it to Steve.

Steve’s jaw dropped, he held up his gun and pointed it square at Dave’s head, “Is this a fucking joke, you filthy mother fucker?”

Dave looked shocked but knew what was coming, “What… what’s up.”

“This is a picture of my wife.”

“I’m… I’m sorry man… I never meant anything by it… like I said she came to me for sex. You said yourself that you hardly saw your wife these days. Can you blame me for doing it… huh?”

“You bastard, I ought to blow your fucking cock off right now.”

“If it’ll make you feel better, do it. But you will be fucked too. So I fucked your wife a few times, get over it if you ever want to see her again.”

“Next time I see the bitch I will be throwing her out of my house.”

“I thought she was your world, man. You ain’t gonna throw her out.”

“SHUT UP, you know nothing about me, NOTHING!”

“FUCK YOU, if you weren’t such a bad husband she would never have come to me. This is your fault. You neglected her needs so she went out and found a man who could satisfy them for her.”

Steve pressed his revolver against Dave’s forehead, “Any last words mother fucker. I ain’t playing the game any more, I just want my revenge.”

“Don’t shoot me,” Dave pleaded.

“You fuck my wife and expect me to show you mercy.”

“That’s the connection. Can’t you see? Your wife has set up this entire thing.”
Steve pressed the gun harder, “If she has set this up, she knows you are a cheating, using asshole and she also knows my feelings for her are still strong.”

Dave leaned forward into Steve and pushing him away, “This all ends here. I’m sorry man. Get your family back together think of your kids. This is my apology to you. If I’m gonna die I’d rather do it by my own hand.”

He put his revolver into his mouth and pulled the trigger.

BANG!

Half of his brain hit the wall and slid down to the floor leaving a bloody mark. Dave’s body hit the floor with a sickening thud.

Steve stood back unsure whether to feel sick or happy. He had won, would the referee keep to their word. He waited in the room with the corpse for five minutes then there was a loud clicking sound and a hidden door in the wall became ajar. He walked over, opened it, and peered out. There was a long corridor and he could see daylight at the end of it. Stuck to the outside of the door was an envelope. He ripped it off and opened it:

Congratulations,

You are the victor and therefore can go free. I hope you enjoyed playing Conundrum.

Steve still held the picture in his hand. He looked at Dave’s lifeless body, then he looked at the picture, then back at the corpse. He smiled and threw the picture, which landed in a pool of crimson blood that had collected in the centre of the cell, and smiled, “That’s not my wife. I’ve never seen that woman before in my life.” Steve walked out of the cell, down the corridor, back to his life.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

Re: Conundrum

Hi Jay,
Thought this was a strong idea and I never saw the twist coming, which is pretty hard to manage nowadays! Good stuff. One thing in the opening passages - you used the word 'eyes' a lot in the first three paras and I found myself counting them. I've found that using the same word a lot close together takes the reader's attention away from the story, so maybe have a bit of a rethink there to make it flow better? Hope that helps.

jay12

Re: Conundrum

Hiya,

Thanks for reading and commenting. Glad that you liked it, I willlook at the "eyes" thing again later tonight after work.

Cheers, Jay.

Claire

Re: Conundrum

Just proves how bad I am at editing... I never noticed the receptiveness of the word eyes. I'm sure there will be other errors too.

Well as you know, I love the idea of this and loved the twist at the ending. A great little plot. I'm just a sucker for these types of stories.

jay12

Re: Conundrum

Hi Claire,

Thanks very much for reading and commenting. I know you had read it when I sent it to you to have a look at for me. I hoped it would get a better response but never mind. I will look again through it for errors and will try to sort out the "eyes" business.

Jay.

Squeaky

Re: Conundrum

Hi Jay

I was yapping to Claire earlier on about this, and first thought is there is an obvious comparison to 'Saw,' so the first problem i have with it is that it isn't an original idea.But the main problem is the way you've applied the idea.

The sentences were a tad prefunctionary, static and mechanical and affected the rhythm of the peice.

The dialogue between the two prisoners is unrealistic,Dave's opening line in particular, i couldn't visualise that being his very first line after waking up disorientated.

Someone else mentioned the over use of the word eyes early on.

And i just didn't buy the twist, again it's done so abruptly it doesn't work for me.

Squeaky

jay12

Re: Conundrum

Thanks for reading and commenting. I will look at what you have said when I go through this story again.

Cheers, Jay.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…