From the UKAuthors Collection

The Indian Rope Trick.

By Gerry · Originally published 1 April 2005

Most people if they are honest, will have had some personal experience, or at least will have heard of some story or occurrence that seems to defy logic. At best it may be difficult to believe, or it may well be impossible to believe. The problem arises of course when the occurrence that is being related to you, comes from a person of high intellect and standing, and who happens to be a personal friend.

If you by any chance read my story 'The Room' you will need no introduction to at least two of the characters that are featured in the following story. If you are not acquainted with them let me tell you that Humphry is the vicar of our rural church, and Ken is an active member of the church council. We are all good friends and try to meet at least every two weeks if possible, for a meal and a couple of drinks. We have got into the habit of late to take it in turns to relate any occurrences that we have experienced in our lives that would be interesting to the others.

I had been told some quite extraordinary stories by my two friends, which had always been interesting and entertaining. And I would like to think that when it has been my own turn they would have found my stories similarly entertaining and perhaps a little thought provoking. However nothing could have prepared us for the tale we were about to hear. Humphry’s related experience stopped us in our tracks, in fact we have spoken of little else since hearing his tale.

We both wanted to know why he had left it so long to tell us about this event in his life, which would obviously create much interest. His answer was very predictable. He was not the kind of guy who would knowingly try to go one better, or upstage anyone, and although he was obviously greatly impressed by the events he described to us, he was also quite disturbed. He was a man who liked to be able to explain things, as indeed are most of us, however in this case he was totally puzzled.

You will now be beginning to realise why he shared this story, he wanted Ken and I to try to evaluate it with him and maybe come up with some plausible explanation. He agreed that I could write this account of his experience, and I will write it as if Humphry is telling the story himself. He will of course read it before you do, so you can be sure it is entirely accurate. I would ask you to try to refrain from judgment until you have read the whole story.

This then is the story that Humphry told to Ken and I.

"Many years ago when I was at college studying for my Theology degree, we arrived at the point when all students in my year were required to venture out into the outside world, to do some external work towards their final thesis. The choice was really left up to the individual but there was support and guidance available to those who were unsure about what to do. This could of course have been through financial restraint or purely just not knowing what to look for. Many went to schools to practice teaching, others who were probably hoping to go into the ministry chose to be attached to a church. I fully intended to go into church ministry, but wanted to study other religions at first hand. Fortunately in my case, coming from a family that didn’t have any problems financially, and having already decided where I wanted to go, I had no such concerns, I would go to India.

The sub continent of India had always fascinated me, I like many others I suppose, had read much about the country, but to my regret, I had not had the opportunity to go until now. My main desire to go there was to study the many diverse and different religions, and although I knew that time would be short, It would be a great chance for me to extend my knowledge of eastern religions.

It was then, to my great delight that over dinner that evening, the two people I had developed a close friendship with, expressed a desire to go to India. David Mason was a quite brilliant student who went on to obtain a double doctorate. Lorna Crest a similarly brilliant young lady went on to become a research biologist. These two young people had a deep interest in theology hence there studying for a degree in the subject, however neither of them had any intention of persuing it as a profession. I have to say that they seemed to be thinking that a trip to India would be something of a holiday for them.

The next obstacle was to convince the Dean that our trip was feasible and that it would be productive. The Dean was no stranger to my family, we had been friends for many years. I knew that he would have no objections to my going, he well knew of my desire to study other religions, and knew also that I had no financial worries. I was concerned however for David and Lorna, they were not in the same fiscal situation as myself, and the Dean was well aware of this fact.

I decided a prudent word with my father before their meeting would be in order. My father decided that if I was to be let loose on the Indian sub–continent I would need at least two mature and stable companions to accompany me, and he was willing to sponsor the whole cost if they indeed were suitable. The Dean was already in possession of this knowledge before my two friends had their interviews. The Dean had no objections. At this stage of the proceedings neither of my friends knew my father was sponsoring them, they thought that they were getting a grant through the university for further study abroad.

The timing was just about perfect; we were to go in early January, a very nice time to go to India, well clear of the monsoon and still relatively cool, at least by their standards. At the time we went, we were not of course able to take advantage of frequent schedule not stop flights, or even charter flights, I will not bore you with travel details only to say it took longer than it would today. We thoroughly enjoyed the journey though and arrived safely.”

Humphry paused at this point and wanted to tell us a little about the Indian religions. He emphasised that what he would tell us was not definitive, but he told us it would be interesting. He included details of the Buddhist, and Sikh religions, but as they are not really pertinent to this story I have left that part out and just left in the part about the Hindu religion.

He contiued—
“I had done an in depth study of Islam at college and it was now my intention to divert my attention to the Hindu, religion. Unfortunately we had arrived too late for me to study Diwali, the festival of light that follows the end of the monsoon period, however I was welcomed into the Mandir (Temple) by the priests. I have no intention of boring you with religious theories, that is not the point of this story. However I need to tell you a little. The ancestors of the Hindus, settled the Hindu valley as early as 2000 BC, they were a white Aryan race and it is thought they came from Siberia. It was these people who it is thought created the names for the life forces which they worshiped, and indeed many of these Gods are still worshiped by the modern Hindus.

This of course explains why some Indians have very pale skins, the indigenous people obviously bred with the incoming Aryans. Hindus believe that through praise, dedication and sacrifice; which can be plant or animal, raw or cooked; ceremoniously poured, or just thrown onto a fire; the participant is making a deal, or exchange with his particular god. The bigger the sacrifice the better the deal. I didn’t have time to study Jainism in any depth, but I understand it to be an extreme form of Hinduism, where all attempts have to be made to avoid harming any animal life; to the point of wearing masks. This is to avoid harming any life by breathing on, or ingesting, because it could of course, be some reincarnated ancestor or relative. There are many other offshoots of Hinduism.

The above words are only very brief descriptions of a very complex religion, and are written, as I understood them at the time. I leave it to you to decide if any of the above is relevant to the story.

It would not be fair to my two friends to say that they had not expressed, or even attempted to gain any more knowledge of the Indian religions, other that what they knew before our trip. However it would be true to say their interest had been minimal. I personally was not concerned about their activities; I was too involved and fascinated to be bothered. Each evening over dinner we exchanged details of our daily activities, which were very seldom spent together. I have to say that they seemed to be having a great time and thoroughly enjoying their holiday.

To be perfectly honest by the end of the day I was happy to forget Indian religion, and listen to the accounts of my friend’s days out as we enjoyed our evening meal.
Both David and Lorna had a great fascination for things mystical, and these were indeed the things they were eager to tell me about each evening. India as you will know is steeped in mysticism, some things can be easily explained as trickery, but some things seem to defy any explanation. It was the latter that my friends were interested in---

On the beach one morning they had witnessed something that they were unable to understand. An Indian family had appeared near the beach to entertain, as they apparently frequently do, and a crowd had soon gathered, (as they frequently do). Most of the spectators were of course indigenous people there for a free show, which they have probably seen hundreds of times. However there is always a smattering of foreigners happy to be deprived of their rupees.

The performance had consisted of acrobatics, tightrope walking, and juggling, quite a normal repertoire for these sort of shows it seems. What created the excitement however was the final act. Two young children of about nine or ten, a boy and a girl, had apparently formed themselves into the shape of a wheel. They then rolled down a slope onto the sand, by this time they were travelling quite fast, after a few yards the wheel stopped, and only one of the children was still there. David and Lorna of course soon worked out that the missing child was in a secret location in the sand, over which they had rolled. This however was not the case, the sand was dug over and examined, the performance was again repeated, and this time the other child disappeared. My friends were completely baffled. I of course could not help; it sounded like an excellent trick to me nothing more.

The next day I was talking to the Hindu priest who I had made friends with, and I mentioned the trick, which had baffled my friends. He would have been a ‘Fakir’ was his reply. He went on to explain fakirs were Hindu ascetics or holy men, originally a mendicant dervish, he told me there were similar Muslim Fakirs, and the word was of Arabic origin meaning, poor man. He clearly did not want to discuss the subject anymore, but told me to tread with care, he said ‘Fakirs’ had amazing abilities, and should be shown enormous respect.

That evening my friends were again very excited they had apparently witnessed -- The Indian rope trick, and we spent an entire evening trying to work out how it was done. At bedtime we had run out of ideas, it had been an interesting evening.

Our time in India had alas run out. We had all thoroughly enjoyed it, although in different ways, but I was sure my friends would have no problem convincing anyone of the value it had been to them.

If I had been asked to predict the results of our final examinations I would have put both David and Lorna down for straight firsts. I am not wishing to brag but of course I was spot on, no surprise there; the surprise was that I obtained a 2-1, I was delighted as examinations were never my strong point, I think shear determination got me through. It speaks volumes for my friends when I tell you that a lot of the examination was devoted to Indian religion. Wherever did they pull the information from?

It was now time to part company. We were all heading in different directions and pursuing different professions, we made the usual promises that we would keep in touch, and I am pleased to tell you that we did. I won’t bore you with the intervening period prior to me obtaining my first Parish as a fully ordained priest. I of course had to pursue the relevent training, take a number of assistant jobs, and do a spell as a hospital chaplain. The parish I was offered was in the centre of a large city and it only had a small congregation, it was a large church and my attitude was that things could only get better.

During my settling in period at the church, I made it my business to get to know the leaders at the various religious buildings in the area. One of the people I met was the priest at the local Hindu Temple. He was a very quiet and unassuming gentleman, and also very friendly, he had achieved the highest position in his religion of Brahman. He was obviously delighted that I had taken the trouble to look him up, and was pleasantly surprised to find out that I had some knowledge of his religion and that I showed an interest in it. We met quite a few times over the following months, and it was on one of these occasions that I got round to telling him of my trip to India. I also told him quite light heartedly of my two companions and where most of their interest had been.

He immediately became very interested and asked me if I could remember what had particularly impressed them. The only two things that came to mind were the rolling children on the beach and the rope trick, I had to tell him of course that I had not seen these performances myself, but was able to tell him that my friends were indeed impressed. I also told him of the priest in India who had told us that what my friends had seen would have been performed by a Fakir.

The priest then told me that this was not necessarily so. He went on to tell me that in the early days of Colonialism, and the East India Company, what is now referred to as The Indian rope trick, was only referred to as The rope, by Indians. He said further that because the soldiers of this period were not able to accept that what they were seeing couldn’t be anything other than a trick, they were the ones who coined the phrase 'The Indian rope trick'. Of course the indigenous people of the period were very keen to relieve the soldiers of their rupees, and many clever charlatans appeared on the scene willing to demonstrate The Indian rope trick, to the gullible troops; who were well known for drinking too much. My Hindu friend then told me he would tell me how they performed The Indian rope trick.

This then is what the Brahman told me.”

Continued---

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

TheGeeza

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

This is fascinating ... where's the rest?!

gouri

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Gerry,really interesting. Interesting to read people's thoughts. I know being into something and working and learning about something is different. Its always nice to read the thoughts of others. This gives the mind a chance to analyse.

Waiting for the next part to come. Let's see what's in store.

Gouri.

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Hi Gouri. I Hope you enjoy and are not upset by any of the content. (this story has caused me a little trouble)---

Gerry xxx.

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Mr Geeza. Reading more than about 2,000 words of prose, seems to cause quite a problem for many.
I decided to chop it in half rightly or wrongly!
The final part should be posted on Monday.
Thank you for dropping in and reading.

Gerry.

Harry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

You're leaving me breathless, Gerry. I haven't figured out "The Wheel" trick, and now you're threatening me with the "Rope."

You've written this in a very effective Victorian style, my friend - which suits the story very well

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Harry, didn't mean to cause you any health problems lol.
Thank you for your encouraging remarks. The next part may surprise you...

Gerry.

Michel

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

This is so exciting. I loved the relaxed, 'Maugham' style of authentic setting for telling the story - superbly done - and I got all locked-in, utterly hooked and believing every word, and dying to know what happens next and then it's continued...
Arrrrrgggghhhh!

RoyBateman

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

So the story went on, up the rope...where's it gone?? Like the "trick", it vanished! Fascinating, but you're wise to leave it there - too long, and few will read it. Also, we're hooked on what's coming next! Great stuff.

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Michel, Thank you for your kind comments--- I hope you don't mind the wait too much...

Gerry.

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Roy, you are correct--it's a fine line getting the length right, readers are a finicky lot--lol.

I think you will appreciate the final part...

Gerry.

gouri

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Gerry, I'm not upset. I think it is wise to read others - analysis differs from person to person. I welcome different views, it makes a huge difference - gives a chance to know and learn - instead of being conservative in my thoughts why not try to understand what others think, something interesting may be lying hidden somewhere. Why not open the doors and read what others have to say - can pick up a point somewhere.
Waiting for the next part.
Gouri :-)))

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Gouri, Thank you.

Gerry xxx.

Dargo77

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Gerry, this is a bit like Chris Tarrant saying he will let you know if you have won a million, after the next commercial break. Don't forget to post for Monday! Really enjoying this one.
Best regards,
Dargo

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

D. Thought you may like this---If I can find my magic wand! the next part should be here soon lol.

Gerry

shackleton

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

I'm sitting on the edge of my seat, Gerry. Absorbing stuff.

shangri-la

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Absolutely fascinating, you've told this in a very engaging way, I'm looking forward to reading the next part. So far I think this is one of your best, a fave for me.

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Michael, Glad you enjoyed this--thanks for comment...

Gerry.

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Shangri, Thank you for your kind comments and for the fav pic.

Gerry xxx.

Kat

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

A very engrossing read Gerry - I like your style!

Kat :)

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Kat thank you for reading and commenting.

Gerry.

tai

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

A great story gerry, I was dissappointed to realise I have to wait for the conclusion though!lol How long is a piece of rope.lol that is the question.

Smiling at the end of your trick. 9 from me.

Tai

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Tai, you don't have to wait--it is posted.
Thanks for reading.

Gerry xxx.

Bradene

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Hi Gerry sorry I'm late commenting enjoyed the first part just off to read the second. (-; love Val x

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Thanks Val see you there.lol.

Gerry.

Claire

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Well I did have a decent comment to congratulate on this piece but I don't have time to say so as I must run to the next installment. Love these cliffhangers, glad I read it today and not last week or I'll be doing my napper in waiting for the next one. Okay, I've babbled enough, I'm off...

Gerry

Re: The Indian Rope Trick.

Hi Claire--see you over the page...

Gerry xxx.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…