From the UKAuthors Collection
A boy child
By shadow · Originally published 3 January 2003
For my brother, Thomas.
You didn’t stay for long
Nine months I’d waited for you.
I made a teddy bear from yellow felt
Stuffed it with cotton wool. I have it still,
Hidden in some drawer or other.
It was at this time of the year.
We’d thought you might arrive on Christmas Day
But no, you were late.
You waited till the last night of the year
To come; and left
Just four days later.
Four days I had a brother, I wouldn’t say
I mourned your loss, because I never knew you.
I only saw you once, in the hospital
Bundled in a crib, only the top of your head,
The curve of the cheek, showing.
You had a big nose, I remember that.
It was the possibilities. They never told me why,
He wasn’t right, they said, it’s maybe just well.
I wonder now and then
What you would have been if things had gone
As they ought. You’d be forty-five by now, married,
Children growing up.
I could have been an aunt.
There were other losses. My mother.
For the one who returned was not the one
Who went away. My trust in God.
Pray, they told me, and be good, you will receive.
I’d prayed for years, but what loving father
Gives, and then almost at once
Asks for it back?
And Christmases were never quite the same.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: A boy child
wistful but never sentimental, thought this was a very balanced, genuine write. not that i know anything but a few things i'd change. "we'd thought" jarred for me a bit. "we thought"?
thought the last line was slightly cliched. something more novel required to end on.
Re: A boy child
I may be a fogey - OK? I admit it.
Poetry with little rythm and rhyme is not poetry (do they call it blank verse?) .(eg: verse 2 - time of year/night of year. repeats.)
I don't think you write poetry all that well. (Compared with your highly professional stories, which I love above all!). Having said that (ducks) this piece is very powerful because of the writing and the message and deserves its score. Could you have written it as prose? Should you?
meant respectfully. JohnG
Re: A boy child
I thought the message was more important than the medium. It made me very sad and mindful of a brother and a foster brother who both died in infancy. I feel even now how much the deaths of these children I never saw have coloured my life for good or ill, so I am not inclined to carp about this or that line. I think the essence of the poem is the path untrodden.
Shadow, your poem found a home in me.
Re: A boy child
It's OK John, I know I'm not a poet. I would have preferred to do it as prose but it insisted on coming out as it did.
Re: A boy child
sorry if my comment came across a bit rude. I never won a prize for tact, despite worrying about it.
Re: A boy child
I too was moved by it, let me be clear. The message is indeed powerful.
Re: A boy child
Fourth stanza after the comma: replace 'it may be just well' with 'might be for the best'. It think it reads better and still gives the sense of a plattitude from someone trying to be philosophical about their loss. Nice poem.
Re: A boy child
Never worry about tact in critiquing people's work on here because as long as you are genuinely trying to give them advice in the hope of helping them, then your heart is in the right place in doing so. If they don't like you for it, that's their business, you just make a mental note not to criticise their work again. but you can still compliment them on good stuff that they produce.
Re: A boy child
yes, I got a couple of those on my list (never agains)
Re: A boy child
My apology was really because when I reread it, I didn't really agree with my comment!!!!!
Re: A boy child
Hear, hear to this.
I found this a very moving poem, and it had extra impact because I had come immediately from your light-hearted poem about the fairy on the Christmas tree, and I was knocked down with a bonk!
And I don't think you're no good at poetry - don't put yourself down! The poetry I tend to write is the sort of thing you get in greetings cards, (I can't write anything else), but the majority of the best and most meaningful poetry doesn't rhyme.
Mind you, Woodbine's the King, so take notice of what he says!