From the UKAuthors Collection

What was the sin

By potleek · Originally published 18 February 2005

It's always a controversial subject ?

What was the baby’s sin
For its life was taken before it could begin
Some how it doesn’t seem fair
That it never knew a mothers love or care

The doctors said that all was fine
In nine months it would be on time
But there was to be no happy day
For a sweet life was to be taken away

In a moments lust or fun
A new life had begun
Not caring that consequences had to be paid
As in a passion bed they were laid

In a moments thoughtless passion
Only thinking it was the fashion
Not thinking of the cost
That an innocent life would be lost

But things went wrong
The operation took to long
Now everyone is going wild
A young girl can now never have a child

They say it is a complete shame
Looking for someone to blame
But do they stop and think or care
For the precious life that is no longer there

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

thehaven

Re: What was the sin

As you say contreversial but this encapsulates it very well.
Good read

Mike

Bradene

Re: What was the sin

just about says it all Tony Good one. Love Val x

potleek

Re: What was the sin

Val thank you so much, still digging up a few old ones...Tony

potleek

Re: What was the sin

Mike thank you so much for your comment it is truly appreciated...Tony

Zydha

Re: What was the sin

Hy Tony, I remember this on an earlier airing.

Sensitive words, and with a double edge to them.

a) Depending on circumstances, sometimes this 'may' be the only viable solution obvious.

b) Sadly, an result of retribution, perhaps?

I liked the thought behind then, and still find this a wonderful 'debate' topic, though...perhaps just a little too controversial for a poetry board, pity. Regards, Zydha

potleek

Re: What was the sin

Zydhs Perhaps you have read this else where for it is one I wrote some time ago.

A) Of course sometimes for health reasons there is no alternative
B) We can all understand the result of a rape crime and such like and the feelings behind it.

As a debate I suppose there will always be some for and some against, but I only ask those who read it to judge it as a poem. But I thank you very much for your vote and comments...Tony

Corin

Re: What was the sin

Tony - I do not think that the rythym and format of this piece is right for the seriousness of the topic you are raising - It is sort of in ballad form but it is close to doggeral as if it were a comic piece you were trying to write.

If you are going to put forward such a controversial view in poetry you ought at least to make the format appropriate for the topic.

Needless to say I disagree very strongly with the viewpoint you express here - this is a real tragedy. a young girl deprived of her fertility because of a stupid mistake and the incompetence or unfortunate outcome of an abortiion - lets call a spade a spade so that people know what we are talking about here.

In my view neither an embryo or a foetus is a human being, merely a potential one. Indeed the same is true of a baby. The recent cases of parents trying to force doctors to keep babies alive with high technology highlights this. Everyone feels sorry of course for parents whohave lost their baby but are unable to accept it but the humane thing is to let them die peacefully.

The same applies to an unwanted embryo. If its mother does not want it to become a baby the humane thing is to use the technology we have and let it die peacefully. We should not be forcing young girls to be surrogate parents for those who want a baby to adopt.

Best Wishes

Corin

deepoceanfish2

Re: What was the sin

potleek,

My....this is certainly controversial! I recall the days of illegal abortions and the nightmare butchers who rendered women infertile at best...many died.

I have six children and some people suggested abortion to me, thinking in their finite wisdom that I should keep the number of mouths to feed, down. But I chose to have my children. However, I respect every woman's right to choose not to bear a child, as well.

What I do feel is a true travesty, are women who use abortion as a form of birth control, through apathy and ignorance. This to me, is the worst possible facet of this controversy....that we live in a world where the constant threat of slanderous dogma, may reduce a woman to making herself an object, without true choice. This was never the way Pro Choice advocates wanted things to be.

One can only hope for change....but not a step backward. A most evocative & compelling read!

Best regards,
Adele ;-)

potleek

Re: What was the sin

David I did not set out to offend anyone with my poem nor do I take the topic lightly in any way nor was it meant to have a comic content as you read it.
Ballad form it may be but not with consious thought.
I did state that this poem is fictional but sadly it does happen in life.
My meanings behind the poem was as the title states "What was the sin"
1. To take away as you say a potential being
2. To have unprotected sex without forethought
3. The unfortunate outcome of an abortion
But we are all entitled to our opinions and I'm sure there will be many who do not agree with your views on life.
This type of thing will always be a controversial topic even though I might not agree with all you say.
But I do appreciate your comments on my poem for in this there is some learning for us all...Tony

potleek

Re: What was the sin

Adele I never meant to make this a debate as it seems to be going so controversial as ever it remains.
In life we all do things that we have to live with, some good and some not so good but I understand what you are saying about choice.
As long as we are taking that step forward.
Many thanks for your comment...Tony

Zydha

Re: What was the sin

Ah hah, so my memory serves me well.

Ok, as a poem, I think you lost the rhythm now and then, Tony, but it was not to the detriment of the poem in reading, but you are good with rhythm in your work, so, I wondered if you had left it so as a deliberate softener. Perhaps tight rhyme or rhythm may make the topic just too stacato in reading.

I find it difficult to read a poem or piece of prose, Tony, 'without' the influence of interpretation. The inspiration of thought goes hand in hand with the transposition to words, for me. The concept was what I thought would make good debate, as follows (somewhat more comprehensively) from David below! This is an emotive subject to some, but, it deserves more response than it's had so far, Zydha

potleek

Re: What was the sin

Zydha I do take the point that you and David made about the rhythm of my poem.
I suppose the writers interpretation can only come through from comments.
As for response, that is a little bit difficult to forcast for most of us can look at our own record of hits, sometimes up and then sometimes down.
But I do thank you for your comments...Tony

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…