From the UKAuthors Collection

Terrorist - who, me?

By shadow · Originally published 18 February 2005

Be afraid. Be very afraid ...

Well, we all know what should be done with terrorists. Lock them up and throw away the key. Don't wait till they actually do anything wrong, by then it might be too late. All these legal processes, trials and 'proven beyond reasonable doubt' - there's no time for that kind of thing. This is an emergency. We know who they are (at least, the intelligence people know, that's their job). They have to be stopped!

Of course, there is something not quite nice about putting people in prison without giving them a chance to defend themselves. Or even telling them what it is they are supposed to have done. It's not British. It's the sort of thing foreigners get up to. Ah, but then, we only locked up foreigners, who don't count and are probably used to it. But what about those suspects who are British? What are we supposed to do about them? Just locking up the foreign ones doesn't seem fair, and we have to be fair.

Not to worry, the Government has come up with a solution. Instead of putting suspected terrorists in prison, we'll confine them to their own homes, or if we don't think they're that dangerous we can just tag them, or bug there phones, or maybe make them wear a label saying 'terrorist'. We still won't have to put them on trial or prove they've done anything, and it will look so much better. I mean, we don't want to infringe anyone's human rights. We are all for human rights - haven't we recently fought a war about them? And to be absolutely fair, the new rules will apply to everyone - British citizens as well as foreigners. Like, you and me.

Hang on. They can't do that. What about habeas corpus and trial by jury? What about Magna Carta? An Englishman's home is his castle, not his prison. These are rights which have been fought for over the centuries, they can't just be taken away. It isn't safe to give any government that much power - the lot in at the moment might only have our interests at heart, but even they won't be here for ever. What if that telly fellow, the one who's just started his own party, 'Vanitas' or something - what if he got into power? He looks mad enough for anything.

What worries me is the feeling that my rights, which I have always taken for granted, are being slowly whittled away. Like the right to silence - well, why should criminals be able to refuse to answer questions? Trial by jury - it only helps the guilty get off. There's always a good reason for these measures. We have to trust the authorities. Identity cards, why not? Be useful for people who don't have a passport or driving license. Only - the system will need to be computerised, to they can keep track of people. I don't like the sound of that. Of course the government will have the very latest hardware and software, so nothing could possibly go wrong ... but what if the system mixed me up with someone else? Or lost me altogether? I could end up a non-person.

But of course it won't come to that. Nobody is engaged in some dark conspiracy to deprive us of our ancient rights.They are only trying to protect us, and if this means putting up with extra security measures - only temporary of course- it's in a good cause. They won't introduce any new system, like identity cards, unless it has been thoroughly tested. The only people who will come under suspicion are the ones with beards and funny clothes, who take their religion seriously. Not respectable people, like us.

Hmmm. Don't be too sure. Ever heard of 'Identity theft'? There's a lot of it about, apparently. Someone nicks your bank or credit card details off a carelessly thrown away statement - the next thing you know several thousand pounds disappear from your bank balance. But what if your identity was stolen by terrorists? Your name might appear on some secret intelligence list - and you wouldn't have any idea until you were arrested. It can happen. Two years ago one Derek Bond, a very respectable elderly gentleman, found himself spending three weeks in a South African jail because his name had somehow got onto a '10 most wanted' list. The U.S. authorities were convinced he was a serial fraudster.

But don't let's get carried away. We must remember, if we are innocent we have nothing to fear. There may be the odd computer glitch here and there, but nothing to worry us. Because the system is designed to catch terrorists - and we all know who they are. Well, okay, we don't, but the security services do. Just like they knew Saddam Hussein had Weapons of Mass Destruction.

So that's all right, then.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

discopants

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

And don't be so sure that the Intelligence Services really does know who they are...

Identity fraud is also more common than you might think. However, any identity cards should come with a 'smart chip' that will include Iris Recognition and/or Fingerprints and so should help minimize it.

Have to say, though, that many of our traditional rights are being gradually chipped away and the government justifies just about any measures they intend by muttering darkly about terrorism.

discopants

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

And don't be so sure that the Intelligence Services really does know who they are...

Identity fraud is also more common than you might think. However, any identity cards should come with a 'smart chip' that will include Iris Recognition and/or Fingerprints and so should help minimize it.

Have to say, though, that many of our traditional rights are being gradually chipped away and the government justifies just about any measures they intend by muttering darkly about terrorism.

shadow

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Thanks Disco. I hope you're right about the identity card thing - I just have this feeling that it's all going to be an almighty cock-up.

glennie

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Excellent intelligent writing. Why should I need a card to prove I'm me. And pay for one at that! No one has yet explained to me how it can prevent terrorism or illegal imigration. Did all those poor chinese winkle pickers have cards? No one knew they exsisted til they were dead. And what of illegal imigration, if it weren't for that England wouldn't exist cos the Angles and Saxons were the most numerous immigrants to Britain ever. Right, I'm getting off my soap box now cos I don't like hieghts.

thehaven

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Excelent read and all true...unfortunatly.Id cards didnt help those poor people in Madrid or Chechnya.

Mike

RoyBateman

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Very good, Moya - you took the wind out of my sails there, as I can't argue with anything! It's one hell of a problem, though...I used to teach in Tipton. Along with everyone else, I laughed when some bloke was accused of trying to set off a bomb in his shoe...bloody ridiculous! But it was true - and if he hadn't messed up, it would have been several hundred dead and no apparent cause.
I just don't know where the line has to be drawn nowadays - but, if Blair is so keen on democracy - say, in Iraq - why are we giving ours away? Terrorism is awful, and everyone professes to be against it. Even Gerry Adams. (HA BLEEDIN' HA) But there are other dangers to our liberties, and we're sleepwalking into them with our eyes apparently open....

shadow

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Quite. Compulsary ID cards that you have to pay for - that's like a tax on your identity. It's a diabolical liberty!

shadow

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

No they didn't, did they? Thanks Mike.

shadow

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Thanks Roy. I agree it's a dilemma, and I don't know the answer. I suppose we have to decide which is the most important - personal freedom or personal safety.

JeffDray

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Instead of making them wear a 'terrorist' label we could make them wear a yellow star stitched onto their clothes. Oh damn, it's been done already...

great piece

shadow

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Thanks Jeff - what gets me is, here is this extraordinary attack on our liberty, and no-one seems bothered. Where are the protest marches, the demonstrations? Doesn't anyone care?

Griffonner

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Oh how I agree with this, Shadow.

The 'what-have-you-got-to-worry-about-if-you-are-innocent brigade' have their heads buried in the sand. There are numerous and frequent cases of 'sensitive' information being lost to 'unauthorised' people, be they hackers or simply fraudsters. Take this latest case in the States: (URL for story is on the CNN Money page: http://money.cnn.com/2005/02/15/technology/identity_theft.reut/index.htm?cnn=yes) where tens of thousands of U.S. consumers now face a greater risk of identity theft after criminals gained access to a database of personal records compiled by ChoicePoint Inc.

The Inland Revenue have had employees passing on information to third parties in the past.

Identity cards are OK when they are just that... as in France, for example. But when they hold all the information that the politicians want... it smacks of the proverbial "1984", and I truly believe they won't be happy until we are all chipped at birth!

Amazingly, last year, a high number of mothers were polled, and the majority of them said they would be happy to have their daughters chipped so that they could be tracked 'in the event of them being AWOL'.

Perhaps its just my age.....?

Regards, Griffonner

shadow

Re: Terrorist - who, me?

Yes it is scary - and we seem to be sleep-walking into it ... thanks for comment (and rating).
Moya

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…