From the UKAuthors Collection
The visit
By potleek · Originally published 28 January 2005
Going through my old poems I quite often forget some that I wrote but some how this one always seems to stick in the back of my mind.....?
My dear old Dad came to visit yesterday
He said he was sorry but he couldn’t stay
He said I’m glad that your doing fine
I’m proud to call you a son of mine
We talked of times that had long gone by
About other things and wondered why
Talked of times when I was small
Of growing up to be so tall
We talked of the time when Mam passed away
Still as vivid as though it was yesterday
Also the pain that he felt inside
When she was no longer by his side
We talked about family matters
How the world was now in tatters
About the things that made him sore
Most of all why there were wars
We could of talked for ages and ages
Wrote a book with a million pages
There was so much that I wanted to know
But he said he was sorry, he just had to go
But his parting did not make me sad
For his visit had made me more than glad
How I felt, could I let others know
For my dear old dad died several years ago
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: The visit
Potleek, this is a straightforward effort, technically. Doesn't always scan perfectly and so I feel it could benefit from a little revision. Hope you don't mind my trying to make constructive criticism. For example, the last stanza...
But his parting did not make me sad
For his visit had made me more than glad
How I felt, could I let others know
For my dear old dad died several years ago
could be...
His parting did not make me sad,
His visit made me more than glad,
The dad I knew, the dad I know:
The dad that died some years ago.
Having said that, I think the last stanza is touching and resonates with the economical title. It is a moving piece, and the notion of you and your dad reflecting on the passing of your mum as seeming like yesterday brings great emphasis to the conclusion of the poem. I certainly don't want to criticise the obviously genuine feeling in this poem: that comes through. But, out of respect for that, I wanted to say that I feel this could be improved and, perhaps, a revision might give better expression to the important ideas and emotions contained in your poem.
Despite my technical criticism, I found this a touching read.
Steve
Re: The visit
Steve thank you most kindly for your comments, I don't mind in the least any constructive criticism, I'm always willing to listen and to learn.
I take in what you you have said and about the last stanza.
"How I felt, could I let others know"
Was a deliberate input for me mainly because a lot of people think your round the bend or something like that if you tell them you have been talking to a ghost, or others will not admit to such things.
But I do honestly thank you for your thoughts you can PM me any time with any ideas you may have...Tony
Re: The visit
I did not expect the last two lines, Tony, and reread with even deeper feelings.
What a beautiful insight to the shared relationship of Father and Son. I understand why you used the words..."How I felt, could I let others know", but those who can accept the fact, will be as touched as I was, and those who don't...well, do they matter? You know...and how lucky you are, that the end was not. Zydha
Re: The visit
A wonderfully vivid piece for me. Everyone should have a dad they can talk too but sometimnes we leave it to late.
Mike
Re: The visit
Hi Tony I've read this before at P/ E I think.. I liked it then and still do. Love Val x
Re: The visit
Hiya Potleek. A nice simple read/write. I do mean that in a good way as I think it adds to the impact of the last few lines.
s
u
n
k
e
n
Re: The visit
For me, this was direct and simple and beautiful. It said exactly what you wanted, needed to say and it said it very well.
I frequently have visits from my dad and he died over twenty five years ago.
If you love some one as much as you clearly loved your dad, they're never going to die.
Nothing spoiled this for me. You told it the way you wanted.
chrissy
Re: The visit
Hi Tony
Really enjoyed this heartfelt poem with its very universal message. All the best to you.
Kat :)
Re: The visit
Mike thank you for your kind comment, you never said a truer word "Sometimes we leave it to late."
We are all guilty of that, if only...we never know do we...Tony
Re: The visit
Zydha thank you for your vote and kind comment for your words are also very touching...Tony
Re: The visit
Val thank you for your vote. Your right you have read it before and thank you for saying you still like it...Tony
Re: The visit
Sunken thank you for the vote and I take your comment in a good way also so I thank you very much...Tony
Re: The visit
Chrissy thank you so much for the vote and very kind words. Sometimes to say things the way you think or feel is the best way. But I am always open to advice.
But I'm glad you liked the way it was said...Tony
Re: The visit
Kat thank you so much for your kind comment for it is truly appreciated, Im glad you think it has a universal message...Tony
Kindest regards to you also
Re: The visit
A most touching poem that I could readily relate to. I don't think our loved ones ever really leave us, but I have had such moments and treasure them Thank you for sharing your poem...L
Re: The visit
Leila thank you so much for your comment, it's a pleasing thought when someone can relate to your poem.
As long as we have the loved ones who have passed on in our minds they are never gone...Tony
Re: The visit
A heart felt poem. Reading simple but touching poems like this remind me that the people we love do not stay around forever. I thought your poem was wonderful.
Re: The visit
Omniavinatamour thanks so much for your very kind words, nothing lasts forever but as long as we keep the ones we love in our minds they are always with us...Tony