Religion’s memory facilitations in the psyche perpetually-implanted
by indoctrination from generation to generation, according to, and
accepting the deductive reasoning in the previous writing, must,
hopefully without being too tendentious, be very capable life drive
energy stimulators, augmenting, even replacing in many expedient
cases, the primary erotic function. In fact, this mode of central-self
resupply is easily implanted in the infant at pre-secondary sexual
level as a readily available psychical ‘weaning’ aid, drawing love for
mother away into other ‘external world’ memory facilitations; even
partly taking over the parental role as protector. Religion in symbol
form, like erotica, has an enormous mass of physical reminders of its
existence. So perceptual and cognitive identification is easily
achieved, even while there is by consensus no physical, only an
implied spiritual evidence of God.
When Voltaire (1768) said: “if god did not exist, it would be necessary to
invent him”, did he mean it as a force for good, with a punitive
element, to combat Man’s evil tendencies, or because of a universal
fear of finite death, perhaps too, a longing for infinite life? He was
though, unwittingly referring to religion as a life drive energy
stimulator, an inner-strength provider while being practiced under
conscious self-evaluation and guidance.
To be effective, religions need to be aligned with, dictate, or merge in
with the customary socialisation process in any given society,
promoting gregarious living, harmony, and peace. Early civilisation
doubtlessly owes its bumpy advancement to religion’s sanctioning
influence on Man’s ambivalent nature. (In this respect, the Sun as a
symbol of God was very effective, being universal and periodically
giving both perceptual and physical evidence of its existence and
power). Viewed as the driving force and executive controller, God is
the supreme creator, with supernatural powers, offering great advant-
ages to followers, both in this and a potential further earned after-life
through prayer and worship and by living according to ancient
scriptures that laid down instructions and rules of obeyance. A
long history from a primitive past giving it all greater gravitas,
believability.
In a world where many people, for various reasons, have, a dys-
functional, or deprived family environment, one not condusive to
getting an adequate start in life, and/or problems with the erotic,
sexual self after puberty, is religion today, a necessary compliment
to the supportive family, and for many later, replacement for,
certain types of sexuality, in its resupplying the psyche role?
At the extreme end, people who view their biologically-given
sexuality (i.e. being the actual psychically-based object that
attracts and excites sexually), with abhorrence, due to it being
personally, or perhaps socially, even lawfully, unacceptable,
would be drawn directly to religion’s highly-capable life-drive
provider function as a substitute. But the many cases of sexual
crimes and impropriety in the various churches gives evidence
of sexuality’s often irresistable importance and primary power
in the service of personal psychical health, and with these, and
other orientations, ’emasculated’ procreation.
Also, with there being many contentious religions, defending
a religion-supported psyche, needing to secure its continued
existence confronted by threats to what represents and sustains
it in the external world, would entail fighting those intent on
trying to destroy it, those resisting its doctrines and aims, its
expansion and spread, by any means possible including using
a high degree of fanatical, open and covert, aggression and
violence. Sadly, we have much evidence of this too.
In fact, the most worrying in terms of maintaining world peace,
is that the brain’s cognitive reality-testing function using Nature’s
consistent and reliable laws of cause and effect, internalised
throughout life, but predominately during the early years to
keep one safer and sane, would be in a constant state of diss-
-onance. For, knowing the difference between truth and
falsehood, logical and illogical, cannot be compromised unless
continually defended against by psychical defence mechanisms
like denial and suppression. Without their use, the psyche would
be constantly in aggressive, contra exaggerated exaltation,
modes, waiting to find any pathway of escape, very touchy
when facing any counter arguments, grossly pious, but, esp-
-ecially damaging when directed outwards through striatal
motor routes as psychosomatic stress! Even while the God-myth
still claims credibility by dominating much of the structural
and cultural world, the belief in a ‘Santa Clause’ existence
cannot be sustained, not internally, however much we might
wish it!
Atheists, or humanists, a better word etymologically, or better
still, without epithet, will tell you, that not being religious,
not needing anything it has to offer in the way of purported
knowledge, security, and comfort in their daily lives, doesn’t
leave them at a disadvantage. For them, self-sufficiency comes
from accepting life’s hard and fast truths, its basic unchanging
facts, however raw and brutal, however awesome and beautiful,
from empirical knowledge, from learning from experience,
from the quality of tangible evidence. This means that any
learned coping strategies, being from real life, remain more
reliable, flexible, and effective, giving a greater sense of empowe-
rment, more confidence in dealing with the trials and tribu-
lations that are actively worked on, but mostly unavoidable in
living a life, for anyone. Belief support, and any placebo healing
effects it might have, serve no purpose, has no attraction for
them, weighing up the advantages and disadvantages.
Life has its mysteries, and the spiritual in human experience,
like with e.g. morality and charitable benevolence, need have
no connection to religion. On the practical side, and for purely
aesthetic reasons, it must be so, that everyone wonders at,
appreciates, many of the cultural fruits of religion that comes
from the particular redirected passion it stirs in people, both
today and way back in history: in architecture, in all the arts
including music, even its recurring traditions, that bring people
together in joyful social interaction. But, however inspired,
they are, and remain, human creations like any other, and as
such, can be enjoyed by all. The sense of continuity they instill
in a person’s identity-formation can be a source of comfort
too, even if an unnecessary exaltation of normal living.
Even if there is after all only oblivion at life’s end, it’s a
comforting thought, that all the massive structure of religion,
all the many professional people of the cloth, those we
respect, all is not in vain, for it still serves humanity, that is
when limiting its use to altruistic ends. But, in some cases too,
in helping to resupply the psyche, for people who can hold
the mask, and exert self-control, as one of many substitutes
for Nature’s sexual function, a potent one at that!
Love drives the world, but should its source only be Nature’s
sexually-supplied life drive, plus other tangible interests
sublimated from it when circumstances limit its use, or
include religion in spite of the risks? Are both necessary?
The jury is probably destined to always stay out on
that verdict.
Goth:2023
Inexhaustible subject.
True Aurelio, but religion’s role/function for, and effect on, civilisation in modern times seems to have U-turned to a large extent and much of it works alongside financial greed as far as self-interest goes. Instead of taming Man the animal, it’s the cause now of much of the world’s dissent and disharmony, including violent aggression? The type of deductive logic presented here allows the reader to follow the reasoning, and then compare it’s assertions with their own, or observed, experiences to see if there is any agreement.
It’s saying we may be paying a heavy price today, using various indoctrinated theoretical religions as an extra mental support and safeguard, even if in some few cases, it may help by being a substitute for sexuality (and later, augmenting other real tangible interests) in resupplying the drive energy needed by the psyche. Thanks for your comment, much appreciated!
The walrus and the carpenter? You do have a way with the words, Mr. Wordsmith. Well done.
Well, I’ve always been engaged in empirically researching root causes, backing up the logic with real observations, rather than dabbling in manifest idealism, Supratik! Even if an interpretation of hundred year old reasoning, it can still be how things are, and useful in planning for a more tolerant, peaceful world, even if that next stage would take us to where optimistic idealism has its inconsequential foothold! Alice’s hundred and seventy year old friends would ‘be off with their heads’ if they discussed this ‘nonsense’ then! Hahaha! Thanks for your comment, appreciated.
I can completely understand. Repects. On a lighter note, I never trust the Brits when they are praising you; you never know the ‘pinch of salt’ hidden somewhere in the mastery of their language. After all, they are known to be the master of insults, ha ha ha! I find your sincerity to probe very touching. Keep it up, mate.
Yes, true, but keep it under your hat, after Brexit, and then Rishi, Sadiq, and Humza, ’tis our only comfort…
I will, most certainly. If possible, try to get rid of your comfort zone.
Supratik, my friend, I’m sorry you took the long piece you wrote in response to this writing off, because it now appeared to simply be manifest idealism. But resistance, like yours, to accepting at least the logic and assertions as valid argument in this piece was part of its core messaging including the pre-emptive “…..very touchy when facing any counter arguments….”. It proves the case.
Indoctrination is so indelible as part of the embryonic psyche, it doesn’t tolerate any critical examination. The old adage: “people prefer to stay in a well-known hell than risk venturing into an unknown paradise” will sadly offer enough resistance to change anyway, no matter the evidence presented? It’ll need generational change not a quick paradigm shift. And mass globalisation has brought many primitive thinking people into Europe, reversing much of the progress that hade been made…
in peace
God exists, with or without religion. The scriptures do not lead (I’m saying this with my limited visibility and understanding) us to God, in fact, more often than not they take us away from it/him/her. God doesn’t exist in rituals, prescriptions, or proscriptions. God resides in innocence, in purity. The material world and the spiritual world cannot coexist, like love and sex, or love and worry, or temporary pleasure and permanent bliss. For God, it’s okay, tathastu, so be it, for anything one thinks, does, speaks. In my part of the world, there are people, the sadhus who know how to be present in multiple places at one time, to disappear and reappear. They don’t bother to come to the material world and showcase their talents because sure enough this world would have a scientific explanation for their Blackmagic. Listen Goth, we have royally screwed up the real world; that’s why being in the virtual world is bliss at times. To conclude, we cannot dissociate love from sex in the material world; with this, we try to figure out the relationship between Radha and Krishna. Love (prem) is a spiritual quality, a guna (virtue), and sex (kama) is a dosha (sin); they cannot coexist. I am a great admirer of Voltaire; there was a time when I was known as a Satrian; now, I am of the opinion that no intellectual can hold God, let alone define it. One has to get rid of one’s intellect to get his kripa (grace/mercy). According to our belief system, one has to bathe in the Ganges to get rid of their vices, and in Yamuna to get rid of their virtues, it’s only then that they can meet God. I don’t know if I have confused you even more; all I know is that I will meet God in one life or the other. Let me truly get rid of my doshas, vices, and virtues included.
It’s interesting how mankind has dealt with, attempted to explain, give meaning to, Nature’s Birth, Procreation, and Death, its Lifecycle, both historically, regionally, and developmentally with such variety. For we have a need too, to understand all we experience, and India has been richly diverse in this endeavour, that is, using language, behaviour, and physical symbols to transforming beliefs into something tangible, a process we have referred to as Religion.
At the individual level, this phenomena is on a scale from open uncommited interest to total dedication, and at group level, religious acceptance for practical purposes (induction, marriage, funerals, etc.) and world-wide, business-based religious movements.
With some questions unanserable in this respect, and therfore not able to be developed further from mystical thinking during primitive times in Man’s civilization, we’re probably never destined to know how the world would exist and function with a one life, one world situation, with all our energies confined to universal social democracy in communal living and care of the limiting environment we call Earth.
This writing, using deductive reasoning, an extention to the earlier piece, which was an interpretation of hundred year old scientific theory, attempted to explain certain aspects of human behaviour in drives, intentions, consequences, as observable in today’s society. These pieces have received c:a 700 and 1300 hits respectively, which shows it awoke some interest?
Thanks Supratik for your own impressions and very interesting understanding of the two basic subjects presented from both pieces, from your own rich perspective. With few people submitting, it seems to be stuck on the front page! Time to move on.
Trevor