Whale, I have been to India on a number of occasions - so I was drawn to this poem.. It is very sad and very well expressed - without careful reading it would be easy to think both verses were the same. gerry
Whale. Polly had two older brothers who were in the army. Many young people put marriage on hold to serve their country. - England was in danger of being invaded. This is not meant to be (War and peace) it is what it is... Sorry if it has…
Wow! You have great imagination. I wish I felt it was worth the trouble. I called this 'An Amusement' because I didn't take it very seriously. But why did you feel that Alan Har-Paz (the director) was unlikeable? And the end was comically cynical inasmuch as the unchanging…
I found the character portrait of Fiona quite involving but the ending, to be honest, a bit disappointing. I was expecting some kind of emotional breakdown, not another explosion of anger which was what we had already seen at the beginning. The fact that this one ended in…
As I have said, you have the prerogative to reject my suggestions as the writing has to be yours. However, one can, indeed, say too little and too much at the same time. P.S. Wise advice I received for short story writers and should be an axiom. Never…
Gerry: A lot of us, born before (me), during or shortly after the war would not know this. And why would Polly accept this assignment just before she was to be married? There are a lot of open questions here which need to be answered for anyone unfamiliar…
Whale, the mainly (young) both women and men were of very high academic ability and were recruited to train as wireless operators and saboteurs behind enemy lines during the war. They were all volunteers and knew if they were caught they would be shot. The losses were indeed…
A bit confusing for me Whale. You complain that I'm saying too much and also not enough. I don't think it's necessary that we know straight away who the narrator is, her age or gender or anything about her. These facts emerge naturally as she tells her story.…
Around the UKAuthors table
Member Shoutbox
Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.
UKAuthors uses essential cookies to keep the website secure
and working. With your permission, we can also count
readership and load media from services such as YouTube and
SoundCloud.
The conversation
What readers are saying
The newest responses to writing published across UKAuthors.
Whale, I have been to India on a number of occasions - so I was drawn to this poem.. It is very sad and very well expressed - without careful reading it would be easy to think both verses were the same. gerry
Whale. Polly had two older brothers who were in the army. Many young people put marriage on hold to serve their country. - England was in danger of being invaded. This is not meant to be (War and peace) it is what it is... Sorry if it has…
Wow! You have great imagination. I wish I felt it was worth the trouble. I called this 'An Amusement' because I didn't take it very seriously. But why did you feel that Alan Har-Paz (the director) was unlikeable? And the end was comically cynical inasmuch as the unchanging…
Exactly where Beckett went wrong in 'Waiting for Godot'.
I found the character portrait of Fiona quite involving but the ending, to be honest, a bit disappointing. I was expecting some kind of emotional breakdown, not another explosion of anger which was what we had already seen at the beginning. The fact that this one ended in…
As I have said, you have the prerogative to reject my suggestions as the writing has to be yours. However, one can, indeed, say too little and too much at the same time. P.S. Wise advice I received for short story writers and should be an axiom. Never…
Gerry: A lot of us, born before (me), during or shortly after the war would not know this. And why would Polly accept this assignment just before she was to be married? There are a lot of open questions here which need to be answered for anyone unfamiliar…
Whale, the mainly (young) both women and men were of very high academic ability and were recruited to train as wireless operators and saboteurs behind enemy lines during the war. They were all volunteers and knew if they were caught they would be shot. The losses were indeed…
I would refer you to the answer I gave to my honourable friend previously.
A bit confusing for me Whale. You complain that I'm saying too much and also not enough. I don't think it's necessary that we know straight away who the narrator is, her age or gender or anything about her. These facts emerge naturally as she tells her story.…